HARRISBURG -- Republican gubernatorial candidate Tom Corbett's support for a lawsuit to overturn the new federal health care law is "stunning," said Gov. Ed Rendell, because if the lawsuit is successful, the state would lose $119 million annually and thousands of small businesses and young adults would be hurt.
Democrat Rendell, who leaves office in January, also says it's hypocritical for Mr. Corbett to issue a position paper about how he would implement the benefits of the law that's he's trying to get tossed out.
Mr. Corbett, of Shaler, is one of 14 state attorneys general, almost all of them Republicans, who have gone to court to fight the new health care law, which Congress passed in March and which began taking effect this week.
"You don't try to void something that is delivering tremendous benefits to people," Mr. Rendell told reporters Thursday. "It's stunning ... stunning. I think the word is hypocrisy."
Mr. Rendell praised two benefits of the law, which took effect Thursday. One permits young adults to stay on their parents' health insurance until age 26, rather than being removed at age 19, as they have been until now (unless enrolled in college.) Another provision will stop insurance companies from denying coverage to children 18 and under just because they have "pre-existing" health conditions.
Thousands of young adults "will now be able to access quality, affordable coverage through their parents' health plans, and children who were previously denied coverage due to a chronic condition, such as asthma or diabetes," can now get insurance, he said, and yet Mr. Corbett apparently wants to stop such benefits.
The new federal law also provides $119 million a year for Pennsylvania employers, to help them pay for health insurance for employees who retire before age 65, when they become eligible for federal Medicare. The law also gives a $250 check to people age 65 and older, to help them pay for medical costs not covered by Medicare.
Mr. Corbett is running for governor on Nov. 2 against Democrat Dan Onorato, the Allegheny County executive and the candidate Mr. Rendell supports.
Corbett campaign spokesman Kevin Harley said Mr. Corbett's position on the health care law is neither surprising nor hypocritical.
"The attorney general took an oath to uphold the constitutions of the United States and of Pennsylvania," Mr. Harley said. "In his legal opinion, and in the opinion of other attorneys general and other legal experts, the U.S. Congress cannot force an individual to buy health insurance," as he said the new law does.
"The law passed by Congress in March violates the commerce clause of the U.S. Constitution by forcing individuals to buy health insurance," he asserted.
But there's obviously no guarantee the lawsuit by the attorneys general will be successful, so the next governor "must be prepared to deal with the implementation of Obamacare," Mr. Harley said. Mr. Corbett "believes we need health care reform," and so issued a health care policy paper this week.
In that paper, Mr. Corbett said the new law "offers great opportunity to extend coverage to thousands more people throughout Pennsylvania." But he said it still must be "implemented properly by state government."
Mr. Corbett said he would try to grant "greater access to [health] coverage" while seeking to "encourage the development of new [insurance] products ... [and] mitigating the cost impact of the federal law."
In the position paper, Mr. Corbett talks about "the current legal challenge of attorneys general from across the country" but doesn't mention that he is one of them.
Mr. Harley said his boss also would push to expand "the affordability of health insurance" and seek "medical liability reform," such as limiting the size of damages awarded to a plaintiff for "pain and suffering." The political power of trial lawyers has so far prevented the Legislature from imposing a pain-and-suffering limit of, perhaps, $250,000 per case.
Mr. Harley said Mr. Rendell, as a candidate in 2002, vowed to support a liability reform called the Fair Share Act, but after the Legislature enacted it in 2006, Mr. Rendell vetoed it. "That's the height of hypocrisy," Mr. Harley said.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.