UNION CITY, Pa. -- An Erie freshman comes into Congress in a revolutionary political year, faces down national attention and attacks during a bid for a second term, and ultimately squeaks out a win.
That was the story of Erie Republican Phil English in 1996. In 2008, riding the Obama wave, Democrat Kathy Dahlkemper toppled Mr. English from seven terms in the U.S. House, and she hopes to hold on to the 3rd District seat this year.
"I have a vision for this district that is going to take a number of years to help come to fruition," she said in an interview last week. "But the vision goes back to why I first ran in the first place, and that is the fact we don't have opportunities here for young people that we had 15 to 20 years ago."
Like Mr. English, who entered office after the 1994 "Republican Revolution," Mike Kelly is trying to ride the GOP's next wave into office. The gregarious Butler car dealer shares the anti-bailouts, anti-health care reform and anti-Washington message that is propelling GOP candidates nationwide -- and said it was poor experiences with the government during its bailout of General Motors that pushed him into running for Congress.
"A lot of things I thought were rock solid and were going to be there for a long time started to get shaky -- and it was all because of the government getting involved in our business cycle," the Cadillac, Kia and Hyundai dealer said. "It was a call to action."
The generic ballot lead for Republicans nationwide early this month was the biggest in Gallup's 68 years of doing the poll, and the district makeup has led national prognosticators to say the seat is ripe for a Republican pickup in November.
But how well do the national experts know Erie -- which dominates a district that runs through parts of Crawford, Warren, Venango, Mercer, Butler and Armstrong counties? They commonly note John McCain won the district in the 2008 presidential race, failing to note he did so by 16 total votes.
Voting in the 3rd District has been trending Democratic. In every county in the district except for Armstrong, more people voted for Barack Obama than they did for John Kerry four years earlier, and the Democrats have an 8-point registration edge district-wide. That is further emphasized in Democratic-dominated Erie County itself.
There is good reason why the last three House members from that part of the state -- Ms. Dahlkemper, Mr. English and fellow Republican Tom Ridge -- were all from the city.
"For the most part this is a district that is kind to incumbents and gives them a chance," said Renee M. Lamis, author of "The Realignment of Pennsylvania Politics Since 1960" (Penn State University Press), and now an Erie-based strategic consultant who supplied much of the data above. "People are willing to give the benefit of the doubt."
Republicans feel magic in the air this year and think they can beat the registration and historical odds, especially if they can get disaffected Democrats to vote for Mr. Kelly, a former Notre Dame lineman who lives in Butler city and has an easy way with friends across the aisle.
The lure of the GOP's smaller-government, lower-taxes pitch "is not ZIP code-specific or registration-specific. That's just America," Mr. Kelly said. "People of this area are very conservative and very responsible fiscally and socially."
Daniel Shea, director of the Center for Political Participation at Allegheny College in Meadville, sees the GOP making inroads this fall. "In this district, and this is true across the country, Democrats are more likely to defect than Republicans," he said. "For Republicans, turnout is better in this district in midterm elections than for Democrats, and the energy is behind Republicans right now."
Like many other races this year, this one seems poised to turn on two things: how voters think about the economy and about Washington. Unemployment rates the district are worse than those statewide, though the Erie area's 9.9 percent rate has shown slight improvement lately, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics.
"Obviously the economy hasn't rebounded as quickly from the great recession as we had hoped it would, but I think it's important for people to not lose sight of where we were two years ago," said Ms. Dahlkemper, a supporter of the Obama administration's $787 billion stimulus package.
"If we had not put in place the policies that we had, then we would see our unemployment figures up about 16 percent, and we would certainly be in a depression, not a recession. We have a lot more work to do to."
Mr. Kelly says he sees the economic uncertainty plainly on his Route 8 sales floor.
"It's all about jobs. Until we can get a clearer picture of what's going to happen with the government policies, people are so uncertain they are not willing to step outside of where they are right now and make investments. ... Out here on the sales floor, people want to buy a car, they need to buy a car, but they're not sure if they're going to have a job, so they have to hold off."
The solution? "The 800-pound gorilla in the room is the spending. You just can't spend money you don't have."
Mr. Kelly often ties -- as is the wont of GOP candidates nationwide -- his opponent to House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, with whom Ms. Dahlkemper has a 94 percent voting record. "That's not something I have to say. That's her record, it's not Mike Kelly making bad comments about her.
"Instead of taking into consideration the people who sent her," Mr. Kelly continued, "she's more interested in the party. I will always refer to her as 'Congresswoman Dahlkemper' because it is out of respect but it will never be 'Representative Dahlkemper,' because she does not represent this district."
Ms. Dahlkemper has tried to inoculate herself from the anti-Washington backlash, saying in one of her television ads, "I didn't create the mess in Washington, but I'm working every day to solve it." To the Pelosi attack lines she said she "hardly ever talks personally" with the majority leader. "I've never once been asked by her to vote a certain way," she said.
In addition to the stimulus, Ms. Dahlkemper voted in favor of health care reform, but broke with party leaders over cap-and-trade energy legislation. The health measure caused the biggest splash because she joined a group of other anti-abortion Democrats in voting for the bill after getting a White House order affirming it contained no federal funding for abortion.
The former dietitian campaigned on changes to health coverage in 2008 and said the package would boost health coverage for women and babies. "There's no greater friend to the unborn in Congress than me, and the health care bill is probably the most pro-life piece of legislation we've ever passed," she said.
Anti-Washington backlash or not, Ms. Dahlkemper has been using the powers of incumbency lately, traveling through the district with federal grants for rural schools, hospitals and agricultural producers, and touting trade protections for American manufacturing. At an elementary school event announcing $1.1 million for rural schools south of Erie last week, she showed up with a giant check that looked like it came from a Publishers Clearing House ad.
"For that check, you have to have a giant envelope," quipped Hunter Thomas, 8, a third-grader at Union City Elementary School.
"That's why I hand-delivered it," Ms. Dahlkemper replied.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.