From opposite corners of the state, and of the policy spectrum, Pennsylvania's U.S. Senate candidates renewed their running debate on health care reform Tuesday as Pat Toomey derided the controversial measure as "a series of false promises," while Democrat Joe Sestak criticized the Republican for advocating its repeal.

In an appearance in Philadelphia, Mr. Sestak told an audience that as a result of the health care law "my child and 2.5 million others in Pennsylvania can no longer be denied care for pre-existing conditions."

At a news conference at the North Side office of the Pennsylvania Medical Society, Mr. Toomey contended that the bill could increase the costs of health care by as much as 17 percent above the existing rate of health care inflation. And he said that, contrary to the projections of the Obama administration, as many as 9 million Americans would be forced to change their current health care plans as the law is fully implemented.

The former congressman, who reiterated his desire to repeal the bill, said that the issue of pre-existing conditions could be dealt with separately. He argued that by extending the tax deduction for health insurance payments to individuals, many could afford policies that would stay with them when they change jobs. Acknowledging that such a shift would still leave some people vulnerable to the pre-existing conditions roadblock, he said, "We need to subsidize the cost of health care for some people ... a small percentage."

Advertise with us

Mr. Toomey spoke as he accepted the endorsement of the Pennsylvania Medical Society's political action committee. Dr. Amelia Pare, speaking for the group, praised Mr. Toomey's grasp of "the difficulties and challenges of medical care. She said the medical society's 14,000 members represented roughly half of the doctors in the state. She said the group made the endorsement decision after interviewing both of the Senate candidates.

The ongoing health care debate came as national and state polls continued to find majorities opposed to the bill. An August Gallup Poll reported that 56 percent of Americans opposed the measure while only 39 percent favored it. A Franklin & Marshall survey of Pennsylvania voters, however, showed that the overall health care issue had slipped as a priority for many voters.

Speaking to a couple dozen people at a Hispanic community center in Philadelphia, Mr. Sestak accepted an enthusiastic endorsement from the Rev. Luis Cortes Jr., the CEO of Esperanza, an organization representing Christian Hispanics. Mr. Cortes told Mr. Sestak that the top concern of the Hispanic community is immigration reform and the controversial Arizona law that makes not carrying citizenship papers a crime.

"I did not defend this nation's citizens for 31 years to have someone go around and ask them for papers based on how they look," said Mr. Sestak, a retired Navy admiral.

But most of Mr. Sestak's speech and question-and-answer session focused on the economy and inner city problems. Mr. Sestak said abysmal high school graduation rates, especially among minorities, must be addressed. He cited his support for additional funding for Head Start and after-school programs as steps toward that goal, but said much more must be done.

Mr. Sestak also repeated his opposition to Mr. Toomey's embrace of proposals to allow younger workers to invest their payroll taxes in individual accounts, known as privatizing Social Security.