It's a court that gets little public recognition even though it handles more than 3,000 cases each year.
Some people don't even know what the Commonwealth Court in Pennsylvania does.
Still, four candidates are vying for two open spots on the bench in the Nov. 3 election.
The Commonwealth Court, created in 1968, is unlike any other such jurisdiction in the nation.
Designed to handle cases that involve the Commonwealth, its jurisdiction includes appeals from state administrative agencies -- such as workers' compensation or unemployment boards -- and Common Pleas courts involving state or local governments. It also serves as a trial court in lawsuits involving state agencies.
"It handles all public disputes," said Rob Byer, who served as a judge on the court for two years after being appointed by Gov. Bob Casey. "Its cases, by and large, aren't sexy."
However, there have been several important issues before the court in recent years, including lawsuits filed over the Allegheny County drink tax and property tax assessments.
Because of its wide-ranging jurisdiction and the legal complexities in the cases they hear, judges sitting on the Commonwealth Court bench need a similar breadth of experience, said Mr. Byer, who twice ran unsuccessfully for a seat on the court.
All of the candidates running this year have worked on issues considered by the Commonwealth Court.
Linda Judson is a Pittsburgh attorney who has spent much of her 20 years in practice handling workers' compensation cases.
"What has kept my interest," Ms. Judson said, "is learning the cases from multiple perspectives."
She has represented both injured workers and their companies.
"The workplace-safety [area], for me, has been the most exciting," Ms. Judson said.
She enjoys studying trends in the workplace and figuring out steps that could be taken to avert future workers' compensation claims.
"That fascinates me," she said. "We have to learn from our mistakes."
Ms. Judson, who was a nurse before becoming an attorney, cites her background in insurance regulation as a qualification for the Commonwealth Court. She also serves on the Pittsburgh Parking Authority.
Kevin Brobson, an attorney practicing in Harrisburg, has spent his career working on state administrative law.
He has handled cases involving the state Insurance Department and the Gaming Control Board, as well as the Department of Revenue.
"All of my clients I've represented over the years have one common goal -- they want the state and local government to follow the law," Mr. Brobson said.
That is the jurisdiction of the Commonwealth Court.
Mr. Brobson has spent 15 years practicing before the court, which he already considers to be well-run, noting that its time for issuing decisions is ahead of the national standard.
He would, however, like to see the court be more transparent. In a large number of cases handled by the court, the decisions go unreported to the public and therefore are unable to be used as precedent in other cases.
Barbara Behrend Ernsberger, a practicing attorney for 32 years, has wanted to be a judge since she volunteered to help with a judicial election in her youth.
She has a lengthy background in Democratic politics in Pittsburgh and has served as a ward chair, city Democratic chair and a member of the local committee. She also is a member of the Pittsburgh Planning Commission.
Her practice before the Commonwealth Court has involved workers' compensation, unemployment issues, and zoning and land use cases.
"I think I can add that perspective -- of someone who lives in an urban area."
Much of her practice from 1993 to 2007 involved litigation against Metropolitan Life Insurance Co.
She, too, mentioned the issue of unreported opinions by the Commonwealth Court as something she'd like to address on the bench.
Ms. Ernsberger is the only candidate of the four to be rated "not recommended" by the Pennsylvania Bar Association.
Throughout her campaign, she said she has had to defend herself against that.
She believes one of the problems with the reviewing panel was that its members did not appreciate her involvement in Democratic politics.
"I understand when you're elected to the bench, the politics is over."
Ms. Ernsberger also said she believes there may have been a bias on the panel in favor of the insurance industry.
Patricia McCullough is now working in private practice. She previously worked as the executive director of Catholic Charities of the Diocese of Pittsburgh.
She was also a member of the Allegheny County Board of Property Assessment Appeal and Review from 2000 to 2005.
In March 2005, she was appointed as a family court judge in the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas for nine months. She ran unsuccessfully in the November 2005 general election for a seat on that bench.
Ms. McCullough has extensive experience in nonprofit corporate law and in tax issues.
"I think it's important to have a judge who has some knowledge of the issues that come before you," she said.
She also believes judges must base their decisions on the law and not legislate from the bench.
"I really believe we have to have a judiciary that functions as a check and balance for state and local government," she said.
Further, Ms. McCullough said she feels it's important, overall, that public confidence in the judicial system be restored.
Throughout her campaign, Ms. McCullough has not accepted donations from any lawyers, special interest groups or political action committees.
"I believe judges are public servants," she said. "For me, it was important to have that be consistent with what I'm feeling."
Ms. McCullough's husband, Allegheny County Councilman Charles P. McCullough, currently faces criminal charges in the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas for allegedly defrauding an elderly woman whom he represented out of $200,000.
Among the allegations is that he wrote a $10,000 check to Catholic Charities while his wife worked there for the organization to meet a fundraising goal.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.