HARRISBURG -- A Pittsburgh attorney appeared well on her way to victory in the race for three open seats on state Superior Court. Meanwhile, a tight battle was developing for the other seats.

With 96 percent of voting precincts reporting results, Democrat Christine Donohue appeared headed for the bench.

Ms. Donohue, 54, is a commercial litigator for Buchanan Ingersoll & Rooney in Pittsburgh. She has not held elected office before, although she served a three-year political appointment to the Pennsylvania Court of Judicial Discipline.

Ms. Donohue wasn't yet ready to claim victory early this morning.

Advertise with us

"I keep thinking this looks really good, but it's not over tlil it's over," she said from her home, where 60 friends and supporters gathered to wait for the final results. "We have to see what happens. I've been holding my breath all day."

The contest for the remaining two seats was even tighter.

Pittsburgh attorney Jackie Shogan and Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Cheryl Lynn Allen, both Republicans, were slightly ahead of Democrat Ron Folino, also an Allegheny County Common Pleas judge.

Trailing a bit further behind were Democrat John Younge, a Philadelphia County judge, and Republican Bruce Bratton, a Dauphin County judge.

It was a nerve-wracking night for candidates as they waited for results.

Advertise with us

"I feel good about it now," Judge Allen said from her campaign treasurer's house where several friends gathered. "I believe I'm comfortably in third place, and that's all I need to be."

Ms. Shogan, 54, of Murrysville, is a former nurse and a mother of three.

Ms. Allen, 59, of Hampton, is a former second-grade teacher who has three sons and five grandchildren.

Mr. Folino, 53, is a Penn Hills native and a former stand-up comic.

Mr. Younge, 52, of Philadelphia, is a father of three and is active in his church.

Advertise with us

Mr. Bratton, 58, of suburban Harrisburg, is an amateur historian and has one son and one stepson.

Meanwhile yesterday, three Superior Court judges won their retention elections. They are John L. Musmanno and Joan Orie Melvin of Allegheny County and Correale Stevens of Luzerne County.

Superior Court could yet wind up with two more vacancies, depending on the outcome of another statewide race. Superior Court judges Seamus McCaffrey and Debra Todd were leading a four-way race for two Supreme Court seats.

If they win, Gov. Ed Rendell would nominate replacements for them on Superior Court. His nominations are subject to Senate confirmation, said Art Heinz, spokesman for the Administrative Office of Pennsylvania Courts.

Appointed judges serve for two years, until the next municipal election, when voters will fill the seats with judges elected for 10-year terms, Mr. Heinz said.