HARRISBURG -- A group of pay-raise protesters called PA Clean Sweep last week called for voters to oust all 67 judges who are up for retention elections on Nov. 6.

As of yesterday, however, the number had dropped to 66.

Russ Diamond, head of the Clean Sweep group, said Superior Court Judge Joan Orie Melvin had been taken off the vote-no list because in August she returned $14,402 to the state treasury. That represented the amount she had received via a judicial pay raise approved by the Legislature in July 2005.

The Legislature in November 2005 repealed the pay raises it had approved for itself and more than 1,000 state judges. But some judges filed suit in an effort to get their raises back, and in September 2006 the Supreme Court agreed to restore the raises just for judges. Mr. Diamond is calling that move "the judicial swindle."

Advertise with us

"We believe Judge Orie Melvin has done everything in her power to personally reject the judicial swindle," Mr. Diamond said in a notice posted on his Web site, pacleansweep.com.

The Pennsylvania Bar Association has criticized Mr. Diamond for urging voters to oust every judge up for retention. The association said they should be judged on their individual merits.