HARRISBURG -- State Sen. Jane Earll's two-week campaign for a spot on the ballot for state Superior Court fell just short yesterday, as the senator from Erie lost the Republican nomination to a lawyer from Westmoreland County.
Jackie Shogan of Murrysville, who practices with a Downtown Pittsburgh firm, became the third and final Republican candidate for the court during a close vote of the Republican State Committee here.
In a separate committee meeting in the Harrisburg suburb of Camp Hill, Democrats picked Philadelphia Common Pleas Judge John Younge in a unanimous voice vote after other contenders withdrew from consideration for the Superior Court nomination.
The exact tally in the Earll-Shogan contest was never announced, as Republicans wanted to present a united front. But according to informal tallies taken by several committee members, Mrs. Shogan defeated Mrs. Earll by a tally of about 171-141.
Mrs. Earll noted that she had entered the race just two weeks ago, after a third spot on the appeals court opened up when Superior Court Judge Michael Joyce of Erie said he wouldn't seek re-election after being charged with insurance fraud.
Mr. Younge had run in the spring primary for the two ballot spots available then. He came in fifth in a seven-way race, even though he had been the only party-endorsed candidate.
"It is not often an individual gets a second chance at realizing their dream," Mr. Younge, 52, said. "In the faith community, where I come from, we say it's a matter of grace."
He is a deacon at the 7,000-member Sharon Baptist Church in Philadelphia, chairman of the West Philadelphia Community Mental Health Consortium and chairman of the Cobbs Creek Community Environmental Education Center.
Mr. Younge's supporters say that, as a black man from Philadelphia, he brings racial and geographic diversity to the ticket's lineup of Superior Court candidates: Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Ron Folino and Pittsburgh lawyer Christine Donahue.
"When we bring together these people with talent and diversity, and when we communicate, and when we coordinate and when we talk to each other, our ticket can always win," said Allegheny County Democratic Committee Chairman Jim Burn, who nominated Mr. Younge.
Mr. Younge has been a Common Pleas judge for 12 years. He said his experience with trial court and in community service would help him be an impartial and understanding appeals court jurist.
"In this era when there is so much skepticism and lack of confidence in the courts and other branches of government, judges need to have demonstrated commitment by giving back to the community," Mr. Younge said.
Mrs. Shogan has been running for Superior Court for about two years. She had been endorsed by the GOP state committee in the May primary, but couldn't win one of the two GOP nominations. The primary winners were Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Cheryl Allen and Dauphin Court Common Pleas Judge Bruce Bratton.
Some Republican Party leaders favored Mrs. Earll because they thought she had better statewide name recognition, a better chance at raising campaign funds, and a better chance to win in November. She has served in the Senate for 11 years and ran, unsuccessfully, for lieutenant governor in 2002.
Running so long for the appeals court, and losing in the May primary, "has been an emotional roller coaster,'' Mrs. Shogan told the committee after winning the nomination. "I know it was a tough choice. Jane Earll is a real class act.''
Mrs. Shogan works for Thorp, Reed and Armstrong in Pittsburgh, specializing in civil litigation and health law. She was a nurse for 12 years before going into law. Mrs. Earll is also a lawyer and was an assistant district attorney in Erie before being elected to the Senate in 1996.
Mrs. Earll said, "It was a quick, two-week run. The party was lucky to have several qualified candidates to choose from. These judicial races are important and we need to be unified.''
Three seats are open on the Superior Court in the Nov. 6 election.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.