HARRISBURG -- Unless one standout candidate emerges, the Democratic race for governor in 2010 looks like it will be a geographic battle of West vs. East.
POTENTIAL DEMOCRATIC CANDIDATES
DONALD CUNNINGHAM, JR.
AGE: 42
HOMETOWN: Bethlehem, Lehigh County
CURRENT JOB: Lehigh County chief executive since January 2006
POLITICAL BACKGROUND: Secretary of state Department of General Services, 2003-2005; mayor of Bethlehem, 1998-03.
ROBERT MELLOW
AGE: 64
HOMETOWN: Scranton, Lackawanna County
CURRENT JOB: Democratic leader of State Senate
POLITICAL BACKGROUND: first elected to Senate in 1970; elected Democrat leader in 1989; held top Senate position, president pro tem, in early 1990s.
DAN ONORATO
AGE: 46
HOMETOWN: Pittsburgh (Brighton Heights)
CURRENT JOB: Allegheny County chief executive since 2004
POLITICAL BACKGROUND: Pittsburgh city councilman, 1992-99; Allegheny County controller, 2000-2003.
JACK WAGNER
AGE: 59
HOMETOWN: Pittsburgh (Beechview).
CURRENT JOB: state auditor general since 2005
POLITICAL BACKGROUND: state senator, 1995-2004; Pittsburgh city councilman, 1984-94.
In the southwestern corner of the state, two well-known names could be vying for the state's top job -- Allegheny County Chief Executive Dan Onorato, who lives in Brighton Heights, and state Auditor General Jack Wagner, of Beechview.
But they almost certainly won't have the race to themselves. During the past two weeks, two prominent Eastern Pennsylvanians, state Sen. Robert Mellow, D-Scranton, and Lehigh County Chief Executive Don Cunningham, a former member of Gov. Ed Rendell's cabinet, have expressed interest in the May 2010 Democratic primary.
"Geography is always a factor'' in statewide elections, said G. Terry Madonna, a pollster at Franklin & Marshall College in Lancaster.
As well known as Mr. Onorato and Mr. Wagner are in the southwest, he said, "They could cancel each other out and help out someone from the east like Mellow or Cunningham.''
Thomas Baldino, a political science professor at Wilkes College in Wilkes-Barre, said that so far he sees "no clear favorite among the Democrats.''
Both Mr. Onorato and Mr. Wagner, he said, must work to get their names known in the heavily Democratic areas around Scranton and Wilkes-Barre, not to mention the huge Democratic base in southeastern Pennsylvania, which has provided so much electoral support to Mr. Rendell, the former mayor of Philadelphia.
Mr. Mellow said there could even be a third candidate in 2010 from the Pittsburgh area -- the current lieutenant governor, Catherine Baker Knoll, of McKees Rocks.
"I wouldn't discount her running for governor,'' he said.
There is the delicate factor of age in her case. She turns 77 in September and would be 80 if elected governor in November 2010.
"She's not ruling out running for governor in 2010,'' said aide Sean Pendrak.
Age could also become a factor for Mr. Mellow, who is 64. But he said he exercises every day and is in good shape.
He said he's thought about running for governor ever since 1986, when another Democrat from Scranton, Robert P. Casey Sr., beat Mr. Rendell in the primary and went on to become governor.
POTENTIAL REPUBLICAN CANDIDATES
TOM CORBETT
AGE: 58
HOMETOWN: Shaler
CURRENT JOB: state attorney general, elected 2004
POLITICAL BACKGROUND: assistant district attorney in Allegheny County, 1976-80; U.S. attorney for Western district of Pennsylvania, 1989-93; appointed term as state attorney general, 1995-96.
PATRICK MEEHAN
AGE: 50
HOMETOWN: Drexel Hill, Delaware County
CURRENT JOB: U.S. attorney for Castern district of Pennsylvania since 2001
POLITICAL BACKGROUND: former district attorney for Delaware County; as U.S. attorney he has investigated alleged wrongdoing by several prominent Democratic politicians in Philadelphia.
WILLIAM 'BILL' SCRANTON III
AGE: 60
HOMETOWN: Scranton
CURRENT JOB: businessman
POLITICAL BACKGROUND: lieutenant governor, 1979-87; Republican gubernatorial candidate, late 2005 and early 2006 before withdrawing.
PATRICK TOOMEY
AGE: 45
HOMETOWN: Allentown, Lehigh County
CURRENT JOB: president, Club for Growth
POLITICAL BACKGROUND: U.S. Congressman, 1999-2005; unsuccessfully ran for U.S. Senate, 2004; a leader in the conservative wing of state GOP.
"Unless I don't have good health or the good Lord doesn't want me to, I will run for governor in 2010,'' said Mr. Mellow, who was first elected to the Senate in 1970 and now is minority leader.
"I know as much as or more about state government than anyone. I won't need a learning curve. I can hit the pavement running.''
If Mr. Mellow were to win the governor's job in 2010, Mr. Madonna said, he would accomplish something that hasn't been done since 1954. That year, George Leader went from the state Senate to the governor's mansion.
"Going directly from the Senate to being governor is a tough thing to do,'' said Mr. Madonna. "As a senator, you tend to be relatively unknown to voters in the state as a whole, and you have only a small base from which to raise a lot of [campaign] money.''
Incumbents also have voting records that opponents can shoot at. Opponents are certain to bring up Mr. Mellow's July 2005 vote for the infamous legislative pay raise, which was later rescinded after a public outcry.
Mr. Mellow said he wouldn't run away from his pay-raise vote.
"I think a salary increase is a normal sequence of employment in government or private industry,'' he said. "People expect to receive pay increases from time to time. I won't shy away from discussing anything.''
For the Democrats to win in 2010, however, they would have to overcome an eight-year turnover trend that has developed since 1970, the first time a governor was allowed to run for a second term.
Democrat Milton Shapp served from 1971 to 1978; Republican Dick Thornburgh was in office from 1979 to 1986; Democrat Bob Casey was governor from 1987 to 1994; Republican Tom Ridge was in office from 1995 to 2002; Democrat Ed Rendell's second term ends in 2010.
Both Mr. Mellow and Mr. Cunningham are little known in Western Pennsylvania. Mr. Cunningham, 42, ran the state Department of General Services from 2003 to 2005 before he became chief executive of Lehigh County, north of Philadelphia.
Like Mr. Onorato, he's often seen as a rising Democratic star. Before coming to Harrisburg, he was mayor of Bethlehem. Like Mr. Onorato, he has close ties to Mr. Rendell. Mr. Cunningham has been hitting Democratic political meetings around the state, letting folks know he is interested.
"The Lehigh Valley is a strategic area for Democrats,'' said Frank Kane, an aide to Mr. Cunningham. "It's the third-largest metropolitan area in Pennsylvania, and it's growing.''
Mr. Cunningham's first priority is winning re-election as county executive in 2009, Mr. Kane said. As for the following year, "Party leaders have been talking to him about running for governor and he has talked to them.''
Pittsburgh political analyst William J. Green said there's a way Mr. Wagner and Mr. Onorato could avoid a head-to-head clash in 2010 -- if Mr. Wagner were to run for the U.S. Senate, against incumbent GOP Sen. Arlen Specter, of Philadelphia.
Mr. Green said Mr. Wagner is a Democrat "in the mold of Sen. Bob Casey. He could have a better chance of beating Specter than more liberal Democrats who have lost in the past."
Mr. Wagner, 59, a former state senator and former Pittsburgh council member, and Mr. Onorato, 46, a former county controller and Pittsburgh council member, say they aren't even thinking about 2010. Both say they're focused on winning re-election to their present jobs, Mr. Onorato this year and Mr. Wagner in 2008.
So far there isn't a prominent Democrat from the Philadelphia area who's being mentioned for governor in 2010, but that could change this fall if former U.S. Rep. Joseph Hoeffel wins a race for Montgomery County commissioner.
Mr. Hoeffel lost a Senate race to Mr. Specter in 2004. He'd been thinking about running for lieutenant governor last year with Mr. Rendell, but dropped out to avoid a split with Mrs. Knoll.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.