Just about everybody talks about local school taxes. But what, if anything, should be done about them? And how should the state and local communities pay for public schools?

In the May 15 primary election, voters in nearly every school district across the state rejected the idea of shifting some of the property tax burden to higher income taxes. That means the state elected officials likely will have to take up the issue of local school tax reform again.

This reader forum is a chance to say what you think should be done. Please send your comments to postscript@post-gazette.com. Be sure to include your full name and hometown.

Below are some responses so far.

Advertise with us

Have S.T.O.P put up to vote before it is too late. A supporter, Sean Logan, is one of the few politicians who stands by what he says.

Also change the law so that any school tax increase has to be voted on first.

Sincerely,

Mark Sustarsic, Robinson Twp

We must always be strong proponents of an education system that provides every opportunity for the children to succeed. Citizens of every locality are accountable to provide for the younger community, just as we are dedicated to providing for the older community. As we accept and are proud of such responsibilities, it is certain that there will always be a need to tax, in order to provide.

Advertise with us

Our attention must be directed towards responsible spending and creative solutions. Raising taxes has always been and still is the easy way to solve a problem. There are other answers that can be sought.

Currently, State Senate Bill #248 is aimed at reducing the Pennsylvania legislature by 20%; this equates to almost $90 million annual savings. We must continue to believe in limited government with sufficient representation, and send the money back to the people. Where this money will go after the decrease in government size is still uncertain.

What about the Federal role in education spending? While education has been primarily a local and state responsibility, we must find ways for the federal government to play a more significant role in an already struggling school system.

So playing with the tax system will not solve our woes; we must rather investigate on where the money we pay to the government is being spent. Lets improve the system, not change it.

Michael Grant, Birdgeville

Advertise with us

I think everyone should understand one thing: property taxes will never be eliminated. They are a stable source of revenue, are efficient to collect, and do not wreck the economy of working families the way income and sales taxes do. Our elected officials may be saying what you want to hear; but the property tax is here to stay, unless we want to accelerate the out-migration of young people, young families and recent graduates. Pennsylvania is the second most aged state in the USA, so pandering to seniors is all well and good but it is structurally impossible to implement.

One alternative - already in place - is the land value tax (or LVT). In Clairton last July the school district and the city enacted this program that lowers the tax on houses and other structures and increases the tax load on land values. Some families have seen their total city and school tax go down 55% to 65% annually.

LVT is used because some people know that the property tax is actually two taxes: a tax on land and a tax on buildings. A tax on buildings is terrible. People keep up their homes and invest their savings into them. Taxing the positive things people do is what is hurting our state.

Their land is usually a minor part of the assessment for homeowners and productive businesses. By going to LVT, we reduce taxes on good citizens, and increase taxes on vacant lot owners, slumlords and corporate interests who make money from de-investing in our communities.

Everyone can come up with formulas, assertions and loud voices, but Clairton DID something about high city and school property taxes without taxing businesses, sales and incomes. Why don't the powers that be in Harrisburg talk about it?

Advertise with us

Joshua Vincent, Philadelphia

Why are we not supporting the STOP plan just introduced by Senator Logan. That plan would completely elminate property tax at every level.

Henry D. Woods, Lansford

I would just like to say one thing.... It is a sin to be paying such exuberant school taxes in the Pittsburgh Area. Can I just say I am paying a little under $ 4,000.00 per year and I have been upset about this for years. Do we wonder why people are moving out of the area!

Well, I am sure that school taxes are one of the reasons. It appears

Advertise with us

that if you would like to own a nice home you are going to pay royally for it (In the school tax sense). I do not agree that apartment/house renters do not have to pay any school taxes.

I truly, truly feel bad for the elderly people or those who never

even had children.

I have lived in other states and honestly have never felt so robbed tax wise as here in Pittsburgh. How many taxes can you conflict on people. Just think about it, Federal Tax, S.S. Tax, County Tax, School Tax, Local Tax, Wage Tax and Sales Tax.... this is insane if you ask me or others who are just down-right frustrated with the system.

We can't even fix the roads properly in this state. I think that increasing the sales tax is a wonderful idea, this way everyone who purchases items contributes to the tax reform, excluding people over 60 years of age.

Advertise with us

I am really glad that I had the opportunity to share how I feel along with tens of thousands of other Pittsburghers.

Sincerely,

Another Frustrated Tax Payer

Janet Kastan, White Oak

Please support the S.T.O.P. plan to abolish property taxes in our state. anything less than Total Abolishment Of Property Taxes is a sham.

Advertise with us

Property taxes steal homes from the poor , old and sick and have been responsible for family farms to be sold because of a bad crop years.

almost everyone I know or talk to knows someone who has lost their homes to a sheriff sale.How Sad for them and our state and us.

this tax not only steals peoples homes but their equity too.

Having no property tax would make people invest in fixing up their homes and property knowing they will not have to worry about loosing their home to sheriff sales.

no property taxes would make our state look good to outsiders considering moving here as they would own their home not just rent it from the state like we do now. it would attract business and people and our state and economy and population would grow again.

Advertise with us

the income tax would be more fair as everyone working with and income would pay .

look at all the assessments etc it would abolish and save money that way too.

the S.T.O.P. plan has been proven by a senate research committee to be sound and workable.

Over 1,800 petitions representing the wishes of at least a million Pennsylvanians want this plan enacted.

why are the people not represented as we have asked our elected our officials to do. why do they ignore our petitions and plea.

Advertise with us

why does the news media ignore this side of the story.

a larger population would mean a larger subscription for the press.A larger population would mean more businesses to support a larger population which would mean more advertising to a paper.

every person I have talked too want property taxes abolished . what do the people you talk to say.if they don't want property taxes abolished why not and what is their personal gain from it. why should a few gain from the loss of others when all could gain.what happened to common sense and fairness and justice for all. is legal stealing of peoples homes and equity just and fair and make good sense. I think not.

thank you,

john zelt

Advertise with us

It's not just about senior citizen tax relief, it's property tax relief for everyone. It's simple but congress doesn't want to pass anything. It's be going on for years and no one has come up with a plan. Just benefits and great pensions for congress.

It can be simple, if property taxes are eliminated all together then a county income tax needs established which is fair to everyone who works within Allegheny county since everyone uses the roads and services just the same as property owners. The local tax will need to increase their income tax for their services to their direct community.

The school tax is the biggest burden for everyone young and old which the state needs to step up and provide most of the funding either through sales tax, income tax, gambling revenue or a combination. Also taxpayers that actually have students attending their local school should have a small fee for books, etc, as well but a max limit should be set so school broads don't abuse there power. The State would provide the funding, the school board will still have the authority. A base year would need be set for the budgets and the state would have to approve any increases to the budgets there after. If property taxes would be eliminated then that would also eliminate the property appeal process, property assessment departments, tax collectors, etc, it would save a lot of money for local communities and all counties in PA.

Joe Molinaro, Scott township

The cost to the taxpayers to ASSESS, REASSESS, APPEAL and have the School Districts pay for maintaining records, and collecting the taxes is enormous. Not to mention those people who cannot afford to pay the taxes, possibly after paying off their homes, has the government take it away from them. WHAT A TERRIBLY HEINOUS way to treat the citizens of this great land. The dream of OWNING YOUR OWN HOME is not real. You pay a mortgage to buy the home, and you never really own it, you are still only renting it from the County, Municipal Government and the School Board. Don't pay the rent (HEINOUS TAX) and the dream becomes a nightmare, and the Sheriff's office tosses you out on the street.

Advertise with us

Hypocrites run our Government. They will not let utility companies throw you out on the street for not paying your utility bills, but don't pay their HEINOUS PROPERTY TAX and out you go.

It is time they came into the 21st century and did away with this regressive HEINOUS tax.

I believe that the young people will be able to afford the cost of a home and that this one action could bring people back to Pennsylvania. The greater the population the more attractive the Corporations find the state. There is a work force they can choose from, and this helps draw them into the state. I only see this as a win-win situation.

Sean Logan of Monroeville has two bills to fix this problem, Senate bills 717-718. This is the only way to truely fix this regressive tax.

Walter R. Greene III, Pittsburgh

Advertise with us

I lived in Pgh. now teach in North Carolina....all teachers are state employees....make same pay on each pay scale.....but pay is much lower than up North....benefits good.....but I dont think anyone has the answer to taxes, except too much tax wasted by the politicians.

Ken Bauer

An idea worth considering???? How about LIMITING the amount of winnings in the Pa. State Lottery? NObody needs to be winning $10-$20-$30 million. Cap any individual "pot" at some amount, even $5 million, and use the rest for Senior Citizen tax relief.

If the media would promote such an idea, the legislature & governor might find it an idea worth considering.

I personally am a homeowner, retired, 70 years of age, and am NOT in favor of property tax relief. Schools NEED a STABLE tax base, which an income tax is NOT. I would guess that's why public school funding was originally based on property tax. Income is often unstable, as is a sales tax. Property does not change appreciably and is, in my opinion, a very valid basis for ability to pay.

Advertise with us

Lottery payouts are excessive. Let's reduce them & apply the difference to property tax relief.

Jane Hunnewell, Pittsburgh

Let's start with the gambling revenue that was sold to the residences of that state as a way to reduce property taxes. As I understand it only about 27% of the revenue that state is to collect in gambling revenue will be used to reduce property taxes. The remaining 73% is to be used for what??? If 100% of these revenues were applied to property tax relieve we would all see a significant savings.

I would hate to see our local schools under the total control of the state, however once you element property taxes and shift to 100% state funding you lose all control. I would prefer to see a property tax reduction using gaming tax revenues which would still leave the property tax in place but reduced.

Phil Hosack, Mercer PA

Advertise with us

Gosh I wished the local and state politicians can get to work to come up with a plan to get rid of property tax. They spend days behind closed doors trying to come up with a plan to save the Penguins. Plan A, Plan B, Plan B part 2 and so on. And when they get on the news and start talking about it I just shake my head because I know I will some how pay for the big boys new arena.

Maybe they should think about eliminating the property tax with all of the money that will be generated from the casinos that have yet to materialize.

Does the governor and the elected Robber Barons in Harrisburg really think we are stupid? The voters rejected question on the ballot. It wasn't even real reform.

How about this idea. Why not increase the sales tax state wide and just get rid of the property tax?I myself am sick of thinking about how I am going to come up with a few grand to payfor a school district that I dont even use. At least a sales tax with money from the casinos will allow everybody to pay. Dont get me wrong I dont like any tax but at least home owners wont be tax out of a home in The Peoples Republic Of Pennsylvania...I mean the Common Wealth of Pennsylvania.

Vincent P., Brentwood

It is quite simple, don't shift the tax burden from one hand to the other, start finding ways to live within a budget.

Stop taxing so that legislatures can give the money away so they can be reelected.

Start with cutting back on the legislature and term limits so that we don't ahve these professional politicians

Then look at the expenses (pork barrell), and give aways.

I have not seen the state budget but I could bet (casinos) there are millions wasted on studies, grants, and unnecessary projects.

Make the school boards responsible to the communities they are supposed to serve.

Everyone would like to have abusiness where they could spend all they want and if there isn't enough money, just add a couple of mills and let someone else pay for it.

Bill Thomas, Wexford

Dear Sir/Madam,

The idea of property taxes stems back to feudal times. It's time has since long past since the costs of operating school districts have gone through the roof.

Consolidation of school districts as a way to save costs has not proved to be an effective manner as demonstrated by the fact that when the Churchill Area School District was merged into Woodland Hills the property owners of the former Churchill Area School District's taxes actually increased.

If people want each school district in the state to be on equal ground financially then the source of funding should not be from each local school district individually but on a state wide funding basis.

This would mean (barring going to a state wide property tax) that the only source of funding would be sales tax or income tax along with gaming revenues.

If we opt to go with sales tax or income tax I would further state that the funding level to schools could increase only as much as the revenue generated from sales and /or income tax increases. This would insure that the school districts and related parties do not get any richer than the constituents that they serve.

For example, if one year the income of Pennsylvanians goes up an average of 3% and the revenue generated from sales taxes goes up 3% than whatever dollar amount this generated would go to the school districts. If the school districts gas bills went up 7% a year then this would mean less dollars to allocate for other expenses like salary increases. They would have to budget just like ordinary citizens have to budget.

The state would have to take into consideration the affordability of special programs to make sure that they fit within the school's budgets before mandating these special programs.

As an additional note I would also exempt residential rental property from the property tax as market conditions should result in the savings from property taxes being passed along to renters. Also, the elimination of school property taxes would also make houses more affordable there fore also putting additional pressure on landlords to lower their rental rates.

One final benefit would also be that people would be able to afford more house there fore leading to an increase in the realty transfer tax that each school district shares in.

Is my solution perfect? I would answer no. But I think it is makes more sense than the present system that we have now.

Bob Boscia, Ross Township

One one hand, I am gratified that the voters rejected the proposed tax shift. Property taxes are screwed up enough. The last thing we need is an even more convoluted personal income/wage tax mess across the Commonwealth.

On the other hand, I am disappointed that our elected legislators evidently lack the gumption and/or imagination to achieve true property tax reform on their own without a referendum. Why are we sending them to Harrisburg if they pass off their responsibilities to us?

Dan Skantar, Oakdale