After months of work, the latest local school property tax measure has landed with a thud, just as three other attempts to change the local tax structure have over nearly two decades.
Reader Forum: Local school tax reform
Just about everybody talks about local school taxes. But what, if anything, should be done about them? And how should the state and local communities pay for public schools?
This reader forum is a chance to say what you think should be done. Please send your comments to postscript@post-gazette.com. Be sure to include your full name and hometown.
This time, just four school districts -- none in Western Pennsylvania -- approved referendums designed to shift a portion of school taxes from property tax to income tax, according to the Pennsylvania School Boards Association. The specific proposal varied by district.
As many of the referendums were going down to defeat by 2-1 and 3-1 margins, Chuck Ardo, spokesman for the governor, said Tuesday night the defeat wasn't an indication of "anything other than confusion" by voters.
Some weren't buying that explanation.
"I think overall the reason people voted 'no' is because they understand that this is not really property tax relief. It's a sham," said Quaker Valley school board President Joan Murdoch, whose district spent about $15,000 on work connected with the proposal.
Mike Hornick, a former Western Beaver school board member who served on its tax study commission said, "It was nothing more than a smoke and mirrors attempt by the governor and General Assembly to deflect criticism from themselves and to use it as a shield to hide their cowardice in avoiding the reform of education and taxes in Pennsylvania."
Shauna D'Alessandro, West Jefferson Hills school board president and chairwoman of its tax study commission, said the district worked hard to inform the public. She said a higher income tax would have put the district at a competitive disadvantage with Washington County, just 10 minutes away.
Yesterday, Gov. Ed Rendell said he wasn't surprised by the defeat. He called it a tax-shifting idea "I accepted from the Republican [legislative] leadership."
That brought a quick response by Steve Miskin, aide to House GOP leader Sam Smith. Mr. Miskin said the governor is a "hypocrite," adding that Mr. Rendell issued a news release in June 2006 saying that Act 1 "delivers exactly what I requested and so much more."
Now more battles over tax reform lie ahead.
Mr. Ardo, a Rendell aide, said the governor now prefers to provide property tax relief on a statewide basis rather than on a piecemeal, school-district-by-school-district basis.
That's why, he said, Mr. Rendell fought to get slot machines legalized, because 34 percent of the state tax on gaming revenues will go for statewide property tax relief, starting in July 2008.
That's also why, he said, Mr. Rendell has proposed raising the state sales tax by 1 percentage point -- to 7 percent in most counties, but to 8 percent in Allegheny and Philadelphia counties, where the sales tax is already 7 percent.
His plan would raise $1.4 billion a year. He would devote about half of that to lowering people's property taxes, in addition to the relief the gaming money will provide.
But legislators of both parties, so far, aren't flocking to the idea of raising the sales tax. Some say they might support the plan if the full $1.4 billion were devoted to property tax reduction, but even then it's a long shot.
Thomas J. Gentzel, executive director of the Pennsylvania School Boards Association, considers the resounding defeat "a call for more comprehensive school funding reform."
"This has become an issue because state government has not been paying a fair share of the cost of education," he said. "That's shifted a large burden onto the local tax base."
In national studies over the years, Pennsylvania often has ranked low in equitable state support for public education.
"The answer is that we can't do this at the local level," Mr. Gentzel said. "People wanted more than a couple of hundred dollars off their property tax bill. They wanted something significant."
Pennsylvania for many years has been unable to find a workable plan.
Stephen MacNett, counsel to Senate Republicans, said the thumping the latest attempt took Tuesday reminded him of three previous failed efforts to lower property taxes by shifting some of the burden to income taxes.
In 1989, state voters rejected, by a 3-1 margin, an effort by Democratic Gov. Robert P. Casey to permit school districts to enact a personal income tax, rather than an earned income tax, and use that revenue to lower property taxes.
But senior citizens strongly opposed enacting a personal income tax because that covers unearned income and investments as well as wages. Also, there was no way to restrict property taxes from rising again.
Then in 1998, under Republican Gov. Tom Ridge, a piecemeal approach to property tax relief called Act 50 was enacted. It left it up to each school district to decide whether to increase the earned income tax and lower property tax. In the end, only four districts actually went through with the shift.
In 2004, Act 72 was passed, which again left it up to each district whether to swap property taxes for a higher income tax. Of the state's 501 school districts, only 110 decided to do so, which was considered disappointing.
But nothing ever actually happened. Districts were waiting for the promised slots revenue to roll in to decrease property taxes, and that revenue was delayed.
Next came what is known as Special Session Act 1 of 2006. It required school boards to set up tax study commissions and then recommend a referendum for Tuesday's primary. School boards had a choice of raising the earned income tax or replacing that tax with a personal income tax.
Neither would tax pensions and Social Security, but the personal income tax would be levied on more types of income.
In return, homeowners who filed for homestead or farmstead exemptions would be eligible for property tax reductions. In Allegheny County, the average homestead reductions ranged from $115 in Duquesne to $1,104 in Upper St. Clair.
Most voters considered raising the earned income tax while some weighed replacing it with a new personal income tax.
The proposed rates varied widely. In Allegheny County alone, the proposed rates ranged from a 2.95 percent personal income tax in Allegheny Valley to a 1 percent earned income tax in East Allegheny, an increase from the current 0.5 percent earned income tax.
That high figure in Allegheny Valley resulted in the highest percentage of "no" votes among Allegheny County districts -- 88.7 percent, according to unofficial results.
Despite everything, Pennsylvania property owners will see some modest reductions in their real estate taxes. Relief resulting from slots revenue is due to start in July 2008, when most homeowners will see a tax cut of about $250 a year, the governor has said.
But more substantial property tax relief seems unlikely without increases in either the state sales tax or the state income tax, the only two levies that are broad-based enough to generate sufficient revenue to make a serious dent in statewide property taxes.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.