The contest for Pennsylvania Superior Court features seven Democrats and three Republicans seeking their parties' nominations for two openings on a court many Pennsylvanians do not understand.
Superior Court is, essentially, the first step in the process of appealing lower court decisions on issues ranging from criminal convictions to child custody. In most cases, the state Supreme Court declines to hear further appeals.
In 1980, the court was expanded by eight seats, to a total of 15 positions. While some appeal cases result in a hearing before a nine-judge panel, most appeals go before three-judge panels for consideration.
Traditionally, the court has also been a launching pad for bids for the state Supreme Court. This year is no exception: of seven people seeking Supreme Court nominations this year, three of them now serve on Superior Court, suggesting the possibility of still more openings after the November ballot.
"The word I've been hearing among the political people is 'getting traction,' " said one candidate, Timothy McCormick, a Westmoreland County lawyer.
Traction -- and attention -- could be hard to come by. As ever, party political endorsements are considered crucial in elections expected to produce low turnout, and the Pennsylvania Bar Association's Judicial Evaluation Commission ratings are also highly touted by candidates.
On the Democratic side, candidates range from a practicing attorney -- that would be Mr. McCormick, 53 -- to sitting judges, like Philadelphia's James Murray Lynn, 59.
The Democratic state committee has endorsed only one candidate -- John Milton Younge, 51, a Philadelphia judge who received a "recommended" rating from the bar association, its second-highest ranking.
"Highly recommended" ratings were given to Christine Donohue, 54, an attorney from Shadyside; Ronald W. Folino, 53, a Common Pleas judge from Fox Chapel; and Anne E. Lazarus, 54, also a Philadelphia judge.
The seventh candidate in the Democratic field, James M. DeLeon, 60, a municipal judge from Philadelphia, was rated as "not recommended" by the bar association. He failed to fill out their questionnaire.
On the Republican side, a smaller field includes two candidates endorsed by the state party -- Bruce E. Bratton, 57, a Common Pleas judge from Harrisburg, and Jacqueline O. Shogan, 53, a lawyer from Murrysville. Both were rated "recommended" by the bar.
The third candidate, Cheryl Allen, 59, of Hampton, is a sitting Common Pleas judge in Allegheny and was "highly recommended" by the bar.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.