Bob Donaldson, Post-Gazette

Republican candidate for governor Lynn Swann thanks his running mate, Jim Matthews, before conceding the race to incumbent Ed Rendell last night at Swann headquarters at the Hilton Pittsburgh, Downtown.

Click photo for larger image.

Listen in

Advertise with us

Highlights from the concession speech.

A week before Election Day, Lynn Swann turned up at the Homewood Senior Community Center and jumped into a line dancing class with 75 delighted retirees. The center usually gets a crowd, but directors said Mr. Swann might have filled the place but for one thing: nobody told them he was coming.

It was, in some respects, a snapshot of the Swann dilemma: a famous man with a message, buried alive in a campaign that peaked before his nomination, then lay dormant for the next six months.

"It never got to be a serious campaign. Something was fundamentally missing," said Michael O'Connell, a Pittsburgh political consultant and longtime fixture in Republican politics.

Mr. O'Connell and others place much of the blame upon a state Republican leadership that adopted Mr. Swann prior to the party primary and forced out the more seasoned former Lt. Gov. William Scranton III. Their reasoning was that the party needed a nontraditional candidate to unseat the incumbent Democratic Gov. Ed Rendell.

Advertise with us

Once the nomination was secure, Mr. Swann's handlers seemed to keep him clear of events and occasions in which he would publicly declare clear positions. Essentially, he was prevented from laying the foundation for his message early enough to give him more than the mere name recognition that came from being a Football Hall of Fame inductee.

"What they chose to do was keep him locked up. I used to wonder what he was doing," said Michael DeVanney, chief aide to Mr. Scranton. Mr. DeVanney said he was puzzled that, after outmaneuvering Mr. Scranton for the nomination, Mr. Swann and his handlers failed to reach out to the Scranton camp, and, more surprisingly, failed to aggressively promote their candidate's positions.

Bob Donaldson, Post-Gazette

Lynn Swann thanks his supports last night while flanked by son Shaffer, left, wife Charena, and son Braxton at Swann campaign headquarters at the Hilton Pittsburgh, Downtown.

Click photo for larger image.

Advertise with us

Instead, say analysts, Mr. Swann dodged interviews and spoke in vagaries, allowing the Rendell campaign to paint its own portrait of the Republican challenger before he could introduce himself as anything more than a famous football player.

The election year arrived with little indication that Mr. Swann would prove so limp a candidate. Political advisers to Mr. Rendell warned the incumbent Democrat that he was in serious trouble. Internal polls in March showed Mr. Swann and Mr. Rendell statistically tied at 47-46. Voters were angry at Mr. Rendell about everything from his botched 2003 state budget to the gubernatorial signature he affixed to a middle-of-the-night legislative pay raise that ended the careers of 17 state House and Senate members.

"Rendell was so unpopular in this state that in every ad we'd only say his name once," said Neil Oxman, who oversaw the governor's media strategy. "We wanted to spoon-feed people Ed Rendell because he was so unpopular outside the Philadelphia area."

Then came the Republican State Committee meeting at which Mr. Swann accepted the party's endorsement in the forthcoming primary. He took the room as the nominee apparent and, in his first major break from the strategy of avoiding interviews, went on national television with George Stephanopoulos of ABC.

It turned into a disaster. Asked about abortion, Mr. Swann's answer made clear that he did not understand the landmark Roe v. Wade decision by the Supreme Court. Should the court overturn that ruling, he said, abortion would be illegal. Not so, Mr. Stephanopoulos had to point out. Roe v. Wade merely limited what restrictions states could put on abortions. If it were overturned, individual states would still have to pass laws outlawing abortion.

Advertise with us

Asked about embryonic stem cell research, he gave a line that suggested he could master the subject in due course.

"I am not an expert on stem cell research at this particular time," he said.

Abortion and how to deal with it is "Politics 101" according to Mr. DeVanney. Mr. Swann's advisers were stunned by his poor performance, insiders say, and kept him under wraps for much of the spring to avoid repeating the missteps.

This promise of forthcoming expertise never bore fruit, even though the Swann campaign put out a 143-page book in August outlining, if not detailing, his theories of tax cuts for economic growth, public-private partnerships to promote transportation, and tax credits for poor families to send children to private schools.

"We had information out there all along in terms of our positions, in terms of what we stood for, our vision for Pennsylvania," he said.

Advertise with us

By the time he put his vision to paper, Mr. Swann had already been swamped by a wave of Rendell advertisements, the first in a hurricane of spending by a governor who raised $30 million to Mr. Swann's $11 million.

"The factor here is that Rendell went on the air in May and started spending a million dollars a week," said Stuart Stevens, the Washington-based consultant who worked on Mr. Swann's media strategy. "It's not about where he stands on the issues -- it's about total and complete throw-weight."

Like many others in the Swann camp, Mr. Stevens was an alumnus of former Gov. Tom Ridge's two campaigns for governor.

The decision to coalesce around Mr. Swann as the most viable candidate against Mr. Rendell took place at the highest levels of the state's Republican establishment. With encouragement from presidential adviser Karl Rove, members of the Pennsylvania leadership quickly signed on. They included Robert Jubelirer, the president pro tempore of the state Senate, House Majority Leader Sam Smith, national committee member Christine Toretti Olson and Mark Holman, former chief of staff to Gov. Ridge.

Mr. Holman said setting up the campaign -- first courting the leadership, then the party, then presenting the candidate to the voters -- carried immense obstacles.

Advertise with us

"Pennsylvania, from a retail political standpoint, is just an enormous state. There's just a lot you have to do," he said.

Mr. Swann held out the promise of luring African-American voters from their long-standing allegiance to the Democratic party. Philadelphia, with its overwhelming Democratic edge and a 44 percent black population, becomes crucial in providing statewide victory margins for Democrats, offsetting Republican wins in the surrounding suburban counties and the conservative T, the state's Republican middle.

Republicans, noted Mr. Oxman, the Rendell consultant, "win" Philadelphia not by getting a majority, but by keeping the Democratic margin down. His lone fear as the race progressed was that Mr. Swann would set up shop in Philadelphia and blanket the area, campaigning there months on end.

He didn't.

"He had access to come here. Yet he didn't," he said. "They just sat in rooms and raised money all the time. If Swann had lived in this media market, could he have beaten Rendell? No. Could he have gotten more? Yes."

Advertise with us

As late as last Friday, Mr. Stevens, the Swann campaign's counterpart to Mr. Oxman, was predicting that undecided voters would swing overwhelmingly to Mr. Swann's column, and he called Mr. Swann "one of the most important figures in America."

"He's going to be a huge factor in American politics," he said.

Why Mr. Swann could not be a huge factor in Pennsylvania politics this year seems to lie in his failure to define himself before his opponent did the job for him, and an apparent inability by his campaign to complete such simple tasks as letting a senior citizen center know the candidate for governor was coming to visit after notifying the media days earlier.

Standing outside the center in Homewood last week, Mr. Swann took a few questions. He had to be prodded to note that his appearance also sent a message that Mr. Rendell had managed a misstep of his own the previous week, when he urged passage of casino gambling laws by saying it would lighten the "gray" and "dull" lives of seniors.

But the extent to which Mr. Swann seemed to be going through motions -- a man who drove himself to the campaign stop, with no entourage of cameras in tow -- spoke of a campaign that failed to launch.

Advertise with us

Reflecting on his state, he spoke of "a million things I could have done" to make election day more promising.

"I could have declared in 2004 that I was going to run for governor and spent two full years coming up to speed on a variety of things or raising money," he said. "But that's not the case. I don't worry about the things I didn't do or what could have been or the what ifs. If there's anything I've learned from sports it's you just take the hand you're dealt with whether it's good or bad and you try and work hard for the best outcome. That's it."

And for Mr. Swann, last night, that was, indeed, it.

"I can't tell you Lynn Swann will be governor," Mr. Stevens acknowledged in a rare moment when he put down his partisan shield. "I think if Lynn Swann wants to, eventually he'll be governor of Pennsylvania."

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.