During the remaining weeks of the campaign, the Post-Gazette will periodically review television advertisements in the race for governor, U.S. Senate and some seats in the U.S. House. Today, an examination of the governor's race.

THE CANDIDATES: Democratic incumbent Gov. Ed Rendell and Republican challenger Lynn Swann.

THE TELEVISION AD: This is a Swann commercial, but its stars are Mr. Rendell and state Treasurer Robert Casey Jr., who is a Democratic candidate for U.S. Senate.

It opens with a debate clip in which Mr. Casey says the state lost 180,000 manufacturing jobs in five years.

Advertise with us

Then it moves to another clip, this one from a recent gubernatorial debate in Philadelphia. In it, Mr. Rendell says Harrisburg needs more "citizen soldiers" to replace "professional legislators" who avoid making difficult decisions that could be unpopular among constituents.

"They're right," a narrator chimes in, "and it's only going to get worse with four more years of Ed Rendell. He's a professional politician, not a citizen soldier."

Next, the words "higher taxes," "more welfare," and "more pay-raise politics" appear alongside a photo of Mr. Rendell.

Finally comes the commercial's only mention of Mr. Swann, "the positive change we need," says the narrator.

ANALYSIS

Advertise with us

On manufacturing jobs, the loss may be even more dramatic than Mr. Casey indicated. The National Manufacturers Association puts it at 190,900 jobs in five years, or 28 percent of the manufacturing work force.

Nationally, the decline has been 21 percent in five years, the association says.

Mr. Swann calls his opponent a "professional politician," but Mr. Rendell's supporters prefers to think of him as an experienced one. They use every opportunity to characterize Mr. Swann as unqualified because he has never held or run for public office before.

Mr. Rendell, meanwhile, has been a politician for nearly 30 years as a district attorney and as mayor of Philadelphia. He's on the national political scene, too. He was chairman of the Democratic National Committee during the 2000 election.

Yes, taxes are up but Mr. Rendell isn't the only one to blame. Most of the hikes were imposed by school districts and municipalities, not the Legislature and the governor.

Advertise with us

Still, Mr. Rendell did orchestrate the first increase in the personal income tax in 13 years. The rate went from 2.87 percent to 3.07 percent. Mr. Rendell wanted to increase it even more but could not get legislators to agree.

The commercial also correctly points out that welfare spending is up. The increase -- $2.5 billion since Mr. Rendell took office -- is partly the result of federal mandates.

The increase funded more than just cash assistance to poor families -- what most people think of when they hear the word welfare. The increase also paid for treatment for abused and neglected children and for medical care for the elderly, disabled and chronically ill.

Finally, even the governor now characterizes the 2005 legislative pay raise as a mistake -- and it's not one that will soon be repeated.

Repercussions, including public outrage that led to the ouster of 17 incumbents during the May primary, won't long be forgotten.