HARRISBURG -- State Democrats insist that Lt. Gov. Catherine Baker Knoll has been busy out on the hustings, campaigning for a second term for herself and Gov. Ed Rendell.

But political skeptics don't see it, saying it looks as if Rendell campaign bosses are keeping the malaprop-prone Mrs. Knoll under wraps.

Catherine Baker Knoll

Jim Matthews

Advertise with us

"We haven't seen hide nor hair of Catherine Baker Knoll this campaign season," said Thomas Baldino, a political science professor at Wilkes University.

Political pollster Christopher Borick, at Muhlenberg College, said Mrs. Knoll "has had a very low profile on the campaign trail so far. I haven't seen her around this part of the state."

Mrs. Knoll, 76, a veteran Democratic politician from McKees Rocks, has gone to 23 public events since Sept. 1, according to Rendell campaign spokesman Dan Fee. Mrs. Knoll's office referred campaign questions to him.

They include Labor Day events in Allegheny and Westmoreland counties, a Democratic State Committee meeting Sept. 9, a South Fayette community picnic, the Pittsburgh Irish Festival, an Ironworkers union dinner/dance in Cumberland County on Sept. 16, a Lebanon County "chocolate lovers" event Sept. 17, a Mercer-Butler county picnic Sept. 24, several receptions for state legislative candidates, a Mifflin County dinner Oct. 6 and the Columbus Day parade in Philadelphia last Sunday.

"She goes and speaks to incredibly important constituencies, such as community fairs and senior centers," Mr. Fee said.

Advertise with us

Mr. Borick still thinks Rendell campaign officials are keeping a tight rein on her.

"She may have an active record on paper of going to small events, but I'd been surprised if she's had a high profile at major political events."

For example, she wasn't on the platform with Mr. Rendell last week in Pittsburgh when U.S. Sen. Barack Obama, D-Ill., visited to boost the campaign of Democratic U.S. Senate candidate Bob Casey.

Mr. Baldino thinks Rendell advisers "made a strategic decision to limit her appearances severely, because she does have a tendency to insert her foot in her mouth."

She hasn't agreed to any debates against her Republican opponent, Montgomery County Commissioner Jim Matthews, who is running for lieutenant governor with GOP gubernatorial candidate Lynn Swann.

Advertise with us

One of the Democratic candidates she beat in the May primary, Harrisburg activist Gene Stilp, criticized her for not debating during the primary campaign and for not debating before the Nov. 7 election.

"She only has the ability to attend social events rather than take hard questions from reporters or function in a debate atmosphere," Mr. Stilp said.

Some Democrats privately fear a repeat of verbal slipups from Mrs. Knoll, such as calling the governor "Edward G. Robinson," the 1940s movie actor, rather than Edward G. Rendell.

She sometimes looks flustered when presiding at state Senate sessions, one of her few official duties. Her unease is especially evident when heated arguments for recognition erupt among Republican and Democratic Senate leaders.

Mrs. Knoll got into major political trouble in the summer of last year when she went to a slain soldier's funeral in Carnegie, handed out her business card to family members and then did TV interviews, making it look as if she was trying to capitalize politically on the event.

Advertise with us

She firmly denied that charge, and Mr. Rendell rushed to her defense, saying she was trying to offer help to the family and didn't mean any harm.

G. Terry Madonna, a pollster and political science professor at Franklin and Marshall College, said Mr. Rendell and Mrs. Knoll didn't really campaign as a team when they ran together in 2002.

And this year, Mr. Madonna said, "They are running completely separate campaigns. To my knowledge, the [Rendell] campaign hasn't asked her to do anything specific."

Mrs. Knoll served two terms as state treasurer in the late 1980s, but she did not join up with Mr. Rendell, the former mayor and district attorney of Philadelphia, until they both won contested primaries in May 2002.

William J. Green, a Pittsburgh political analyst, said, "Most of the political yard signs I've seen don't even mention the Rendell/Knoll team. They just have Rendell's name."

Advertise with us

Mr. Fee said the campaign used "different yard signs, rally signs and literature for almost every region [of the state]. Some carry local elected officials' names, some carry just Rendell and some carry Rendell/Knoll."

Matthews aide Josh Wilson said Democrats hadn't responded to the GOP's call for at least one debate with Mrs. Knoll. Mr. Rendell has debated Mr. Swann three times, in Hershey, Pittsburgh and Philadelphia.

"We agreed to a debate and are still waiting for her answer," Mr. Wilson said. "She's been invisible."

Mr. Fee said a debate was under consideration, "but, given Mr. Matthews' pattern of making wild and reckless charges, it is unlikely."

He conceded that Mrs. Knoll "may suffer the occasional malaprop," but said Mr. Matthews is "a loose cannon."

Advertise with us

Mr. Fee said Mr. Matthews was unprepared, at a recent Capitol news conference, to discuss details of his anti-crime agenda.

Pressed for specifics by reporters, Mr. Matthews said, "You are talking to a mortgage broker and a county commissioner, not a district attorney, so cut me a little latitude here."

Mr. Fee said Mr. Matthews once said Mr. Rendell went to a tavern owners convention and "promised" that taverns would get slot machines if he's re-elected. That's totally false, Mr. Fee said.

Mr. Wilson conceded that Mr. Matthews misspoke when he said the governor was at the convention, but Mr. Matthews insists he was told by a tavern owner that the governor promised slots for bars after November.

Mr. Fee said Mr. Matthews once said some Philadelphia judges let defendants off if their attorneys had contributed to the judges' campaigns.

Advertise with us

"Why would we want to share a stage [for a debate] with someone who is willing to make attacks out of thin air?" Mr. Fee said.

Even if Mrs. Knoll does get verbally confused at times, she brings strengths to the Democratic ticket. She is well known in Western Pennsylvania and has allies across the state after years in politics.

She often visits senior citizen centers, dinners and picnics to cement her popularity with older voters, who are known to turn out in large numbers on Election Day.

"Cathy Knoll built one of the best grass-roots political organizations in Pennsylvania, precisely because she was willing to go to those small events, such as community days, county dinners and senior citizen centers that other candidates didn't want to attend," said Tim Potts, of Democracy Rising Pa., a Harrisburg citizens action group.

Her vote-getting ability in Western Pennsylvania combines nicely with Mr. Rendell's proven popularity in southeastern Pennsylvania, giving the Democratic ticket a solid geographic balance.

Advertise with us

And she has won some tough elections. She defeated nine other Democrats, all men, in the May 2002 lieutenant governor primary, and then bested three challengers this year to remain as Mr. Rendell's running mate.

Some of her critics said they fear she wouldn't be up to the job of serving as governor should something happen to Mr. Rendell, but he has said she is fully qualified and such concerns are baseless.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.