HARRISBURG -- After trailing in the polls for months, Republican candidate for governor Lynn Swann took to TV and radio this month with three issue ads aimed at boosting his chances Nov. 7.
The choice for his first ad was the arcane subject of "welfare to work," the longtime federal-state effort to get low-income people off welfare and into training or schooling that leads to productive jobs.
In the 30-second spot, Mr. Swann says that when Tom Ridge was governor from 1995 to 2001, "Pennsylvania was a national leader in helping people move from welfare to work. And now, we're dead last. It's so bad, we're spending $2.5 billion more a year on welfare, while most states are spending far less."
It really isn't a fair attack.
The Department of Public Welfare sends statistics to the federal government each year on the number of Pennsylvanians getting assistance who have jobs or are enrolled in schooling or job training programs.
That number did hit rock bottom, at 7.1 percent, in 2004, when Mr. Rendell was governor. That was 50th in the nation.
But the number had never been very high. From 1998 to 2001, when Mr. Ridge was governor, it ranged from 19.3 percent to 10.8 percent. Pennsylvania was 47th or 48th in the nation in those years, meaning only two or three states were doing worse.
Mr. Swann, in complaining about $2.5 billion in additional welfare costs in the past four years, fails to note that that figure includes much more than just the Temporary Aid to Need Families cash assistance to low-income people; it also includes programs most politicians wouldn't want to get rid of, such as Medical Assistance, which pays health care for the elderly, disabled and chronically ill, and county protective services for abused and neglected children.
But whatever the statistics, is focusing on welfare reform really the way to cut into Mr. Rendell's persistent double-digit lead in the polls?
Mr. Swann's campaign spokesman, Leonardo Alcivar, maintained that the choice of welfare was a good one.
He said the Swann camp was trying to show that Mr. Rendell has a poor record, signing the legislative pay raise, failing to enact broader-based property tax reform, keeping state spending higher than the rate of inflation and not doing enough to get welfare recipients back to school or work.
Mr. Swann just began his assault on TV and radio this month. For "competitive purposes," Mr. Alcivar won't release the spending total. Mr. Rendell's campaign spokesman, Dan Fee, estimated last week that Mr. Swann had spent "almost $1 million on television ads."
Whatever the figure, it won't match what the well-heeled Rendell camp will spend.
According to the governor's expenditure reports covering March 28 through June 6, he had paid his Philadelphia media consultants, The Campaign Group, nearly $4.8 million, much of which went for TV advertising.
As of June 5, Mr. Rendell had nearly $13.8 million on hand, and his TV commercials have continued throughout the summer, so the spending will be up. The next round of fund-raising and expenditure reports are to be filed by 5 p.m. Tuesday.
In Mr. Swann's second add, which began airing last week, the GOP candidate attacks Mr. Rendell for failing to achieve a broad-based reduction in property taxes for middle-class homeowners.
"If your property taxes have been cut, then you're probably pretty content with the Harrisburg status quo," Mr. Swann says in the ad. "But if you are still waiting for the 30 percent reduction promised four years ago, it's time for fresh leadership."
The "four years ago" comment was clearly aimed at Mr. Rendell's campaign in 2002, when he made property tax relief a major issue.
Mr. Swann makes a valid point, because about 650,000 senior citizens are the only real beneficiaries of the Rendell property tax cuts.
In Mr. Swann's third ad, which began running on radio last week, he hits on what might be the most emotional issue for voters: Mr. Rendell's signing last year of the infamous pay raise for judges, legislators and executive branch members.
Using florid language, the ad says, "Under cover of darkness ... long after most were asleep, Ed Rendell was busy giving the Harrisburg insider crowd a pay raise."
For obvious reasons, Mr. Swann is trying to make Mr. Rendell look like the architect of the pay raise, but he really wasn't. He did advocate higher pay for his Cabinet members, an effort that was joined with Supreme Court Chief Justice Ralph Cappy's campaign to win higher judicial pay. Then General Assembly leaders joined in and pushed it through.
Mr. Rendell could have vetoed the raise, but he needed legislative support for his economic and gambling initiatives, so he gave General Assembly leaders what they wanted the most, a 16 percent to 34 percent pay increase. "Sometimes you have to kiss a little butt," he said later.
While Mr. Swann complains his opponent hasn't done enough to lower property taxes, Mr. Rendell isn't apologizing.
It is worth noting that he was able get any tax plan at all through a GOP-controlled Legislature which has no desire to make him look good.
Mr. Rendell, both in interviews and TV commercials, boasts that under his plan, 200,000 low-income senior citizens will get enough in tax relief, up to $650 a year, to eliminate their property taxes altogether. And he boasts that another 450,000 elderly will have their taxes reduced.
But Pennsylvania has a population of 12 million, and critics say several million middle- and upper-class homeowners who still haven't gotten any relief won't, for at least two more years, assuming the 14 new slots casinos generate $1 billion in revenue for the state. Many skeptics question that bold prediction.
Mr. Rendell's TV ad fuzzes over that point, saying merely that "every homeowner in the state will get property tax reductions."
He also doesn't say how much, perhaps because the average amount will be modest. If $1 billion is raised from slots -- a big if -- the average homeowner will get about $200 or $250 in annual relief. For many homeowners, with tax burdens of $1,500 or more a year, it seems minimal.
Even so, Mr. Rendell got farther on the thorny issue of property tax relief than previous governors.
Other Rendell ads boast about his efforts to balance four state budgets in a row and outline his efforts to raise the minimum wage and push for economic development.
Mr. Rendell does deserve some credit (or blame, if you're a business owner whose labor costs will rise) for pushing to increase the minimum wage from $5.15 an hour to $7.15 an hour over two years. He worked with legislative Democrats for months to get that through the GOP-controlled Legislature.
In promoting economic development, Mr. Rendell has been tireless in flying around the state, delivering state money for local projects. But much of it has come from state borrowing, the $640 million capital fund and a new $1.3 billion economic stimulus fund that Mr. Rendell pushed legislators to enact.
Some Republicans have complained that all that borrowing has to be paid back, with interest, which will make things difficult in the future.
But the boast about four balanced budgets seems hollow. Because the state constitution demands that each new state budget be balanced, and every governor does so every year, that hardly qualifies as a major accomplishment.
The ad notes that the current budget, which began July 1, "calls for no tax increases."
The ad, of course, doesn't point out that, in Mr. Rendell's first year, he pushed to increase the state's personal income tax rate from 2.8 percent to 3.75 percent, saying he had to make up for a deficit left over from the previous Schweiker administration.
After arguing with Republican leaders for months, Mr. Rendell settled for increasing the rate to 3.07 percent as a way to balance the budget.
The ad boasts about "tax cuts for businesses who create jobs," but that statement is a bit disingenuous, because Republican legislators have been putting pressure on Mr. Rendell for four years to reduce the corporate net income tax and other business taxes.
The only thing that can be said for sure is that the number and frequency of attack ads being broadcast will increase as the Nov. 7 election approaches.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.