History, like the polls, suggests that Lynn Swann's campaign for governor is a long shot.
Iconic sports figures have often lost elections for statewide office, especially on their first try.
Bud Wilkinson won three national championships and an NCAA-record 47 consecutive games while coaching football at the University of Oklahoma. He proved less formidable as a U.S. Senate candidate, losing to a brainy young lawyer who spoke with a drawl.
An equally famous coach, Tom Osborne of the University of Nebraska, started with a 40-point lead in the polls, but in May lost the Republican primary for governor of Nebraska.
Two hall-of-fame players, pitcher Jim Bunning and wide receiver Steve Largent, lost gubernatorial elections. So did Jack Mildren, football's first great wishbone quarterback.
Pete Dawkins, a Heisman Trophy winner, Rhodes scholar and retired brigadier general, lost a U.S. Senate race.
Another Rhodes scholar, basketball star Bill Bradley, stands out from this pack. After retiring from the New York Knicks with two world championships, he won a U.S. Senate seat in New Jersey, the state whose voters would reject Mr. Dawkins.
Mr. Swann, who starred for the Steelers on four Super Bowl winners, is a Republican without experience in government service. His opponent, Democratic Gov. Ed Rendell, is an Eagles fan with a long resume. He was Philadelphia's mayor and district attorney before winning the governor's office four years ago.
In terms of visibility, Mr. Swann may be on equal footing with the governor. But former U.S. Sen. Fred Harris, the man who defeated Bud Wilkinson in Oklahoma, says name recognition alone cannot carry a sports figure in a statewide election.
Because Mr. Wilkinson's great teams had improved Oklahoma's "Grapes of Wrath" image, even people who did not care about football were intrigued by him. Mr. Harris said the coach lost some of that appeal as soon as he began campaigning.
"Wilkinson was a strong right-winger, almost a Bircher. He started giving speeches about why Rome fell, and said it was because the people got hooked on welfare," Mr. Harris said.
"I said I'd done my own research and found that Rome fell because people got too carried away with sports and gladiators in arenas. It was kind of bad history, but no worse than Wilkinson's."
Mr. Harris, just 33 years old during the campaign, had been in the Oklahoma state Senate for eight years. A Phi Beta Kappa graduate of the University of Oklahoma, he defeated two former governors in the primary election for the right to run against Mr. Wilkinson.
Mr. Harris' slogan was "Prepared for the job." By implication, he also meant that Mr. Wilkinson, then 48 and a football coach all his adult life, was not qualified.
Their race in 1964 came as the country was debating the landmark civil rights legislation of President Lyndon B. Johnson's administration.
Mr. Wilkinson had integrated the Oklahoma team in 1956 by giving a scholarship to Prentice Gautt, a black running back. During the Senate campaign, Mr. Gautt toured black neighborhoods to talk up his old coach.
But Mr. Wilkinson also had South Carolina Sen. Strom Thurmond campaign for him in a section of Oklahoma known as "Little Dixie." A segregationist, Mr. Thurmond undermined the coach's reputation as somebody committed to fair play.
"He brought in the strongest racist in the Senate when the polls showed we were splitting the black vote 50-50," Mr. Harris said. "By the end I was getting nine of every 10 of those votes."
Mr. Harris told voters that he was backing President Johnson in his bid for the White House. He challenged the coach to disclose his choice for president.
Against the advice of his strategists, Mr. Wilkinson committed himself to Republican Barry Goldwater, whose campaign was sinking. Mr. Johnson defeated Mr. Goldwater in Oklahoma by 107,000 votes.
Mr. Wilkinson finished stronger than the top of the Republican ticket, but still lost the Senate race by 21,000 votes.
Some say Mr. Wilkinson's fatal mistake was aligning himself with the Goldwater campaign. Mr. Harris maintains the coach lost for a more fundamental reason.
"His understanding of government was really rather shallow," said Mr. Harris, now 75 and an emeritus professor of political science at the University of New Mexico.
Even sports heroes with experience in government can struggle in statewide races.
Mr. Osborne, a third-term congressman representing western Nebraska, lost his primary race for governor this year, partly because he was methodical about two issues that had captured voters' interest. One would have allowed the Omaha Public Schools to take over various suburban schools. The other would have dissolved elementary-only school districts in rural areas.
Republican Gov. Dave Heineman jumped into the middle of the Omaha fracas, siding with the suburban districts. Critics said he was wrong to use the power of his office in a local matter, but many voters embraced him when he did. He narrowed Mr. Osborne's lead and ultimately defeated the legendary coach by about 17,000 votes.
Another experienced athlete-politician who faltered in a tough race was Tom McMillen. He had known nothing but success since his days in high school in Mansfield, Pa. Sports Illustrated put him on its cover during his senior year in 1970, when he averaged 47 points a game.
Mr. McMillen went on to play at the University of Maryland and then in the NBA. Yet another Rhodes scholar, he turned to politics after basketball, winning three terms as a Democratic congressman from Maryland. But his political career derailed in 1992, when redistricting forced him to compete with another sitting congressman, Republican Wayne Gilchrest.
The basketball great stood 6-feet-11 inches tall. Mr. Gilchrest was 5-feet-6 and told voters his last attempt at organized sports came in ninth grade, when he was cut from the baseball team.
Mr. Gilchrest portrayed Mr. McMillen as a jet-setter out of touch with common people. Mr. Gilchrest said he still remembers his good fortune when Mr. McMillen showed up for a parade in a BMW with a Pennsylvania license plate. In contrast, Mr. Gilchrest drove his pickup truck. It had Maryland plates.
Mr. McMillen outspent Mr. Gilchrest $1.5 million to $300,000 but never gained momentum. Mr. McMillen lost by about 7,000 votes.
Unlike many sports figures who stumbled in the political arena, Jim Bunning staged a comeback.
A pitcher in the majors from 1955 to 1971, he threw a no-hitter for the Detroit Tigers in the American League and a perfect game for the Philadelphia Phillies in the National League. After retiring, he returned to his native Kentucky and won election to local and state legislative offices as a Republican.
His campaign for governor in 1983 ended up making history, but not the kind Mr. Bunning wanted. He lost by 107,000 votes to Democrat Martha Layne Collins, who became Kentucky's first female chief executive.
He re-emerged in 1986, winning a seat in Congress. Mr. Bunning won six, 2-year terms before making a run for the U.S. Senate in 1998.
He outspent Democrat Scotty Baesler by a wide margin. Mr. Bunning needed every penny. He squeaked through, defeating Mr. Baesler, a former University of Kentucky basketball captain, by about 7,000 votes of 1.12 million cast.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.