HARRISBURG -- A day after the Green Party turned in petitions aimed at getting its statewide candidates on the November ballot, Democrats said yesterday they may challenge the validity of the petition signatures in court.

As of yesterday, the state election bureau had not completed counting the signatures turned in by the Green Party, but the party's candidate for U.S. Senate, Carl Romanelli, estimated that 95,000 to 97,000 signatures were collected.

That's considerably more than the 67,070 needed to get Mr. Romanelli, gubernatorial candidate Marakay J. Rogers and lieutenant governor candidate Christina Valente on the ballot.

Democrats have no evidence of specific problems with the signatures, but are suspicious of a Florida-based firm hired by the Green Party to gather some of the signatures, said Democratic Party spokesman Abe Amoros.

Advertise with us

"This is a controversial firm with a history of fraudulent activity," Mr. Amoros said. "It is perfectly legitimate for us to ask questions."

The firm, JSM Inc., pays petition circulators for every signature they collect. It was hired by the Ralph Nader campaign in 2004 to try to get Mr. Nader on the presidential ballot in various states.

That effort failed in Ohio because many of the people hired by the firm were not Ohio residents, as the law dictates that circulators should be, and many signatures were found to have been forged, Mr. Amoros said.

"We are basing our concerns on their past history," he said. "Unless they have done a complete 180-degree turn, they are still questionable, and we have every reason to be suspicious."

Mr. Romanelli said that fraudulent activity in the 2004 campaign was "not necessarily" the responsibility of the firm.

Advertise with us

"When you have a big operation out there like this, you get unscrupulous people who will just take the money and then provide you with junk," he said. "It's up to the party to redline that stuff."

Mr. Romanelli said Green Party officials paid close attention to the petitions turned in to them, checking for invalid or questionable signatures.

"We took great care to weed that stuff out," he said. "I'm not going to lead my party down a reckless path. We want this done right."

Mr. Amoros also questioned the way JSM's services were funded, alleging that Republican incumbent Sen. Rick Santorum's campaign illegally funneled money to the Green Party to help pay for the firm.

Mr. Romanelli denied that the money came from the Santorum campaign. He did acknowledge that some of the money used to pay the firm came from donors who also supported Mr. Santorum.

Advertise with us

"There's nothing illegal or unethical about that," Mr. Romanelli said.

"I'm sorry the Democrats are offended that I found a way to get money. I did, and I don't apologize for that. And to all the Republicans who supported our campaign, I say thank you for providing a service to the principles of a fair and open debate."

Democrats are waiting for the final tally of signatures by the election bureau before they decide whether to challenge the Green Party in court, Mr. Amoros said.

The Democrats might want to disqualify enough signatures to get Mr. Romanelli and the other two statewide Green Party candidates kicked off the ballot, but are waiting to see if it would be worth the effort and resources, he said.

Mr. Romanelli said the Green Party would probably make a public plea for election law lawyers to help them defend their petitions on a pro bono basis.

"We can't commit to pay what such expert fees would cost," he said.