Gov. Ed Rendell dismissed the Legislature's deliberations on an amendment banning gay marriage as "a waste of time" yesterday while branding the House version of the proposal as a "mean-spirited" exercise in politics.

Previous Story

Senate's same-sex marriage ban only fans fire

The House passed a proposed constitutional amendment this month that would have asked the public to ban both marriages and civil unions between gay people. Before the measure reached the Senate floor, the Judiciary Committee severed the language dealing with civil unions, focusing it solely on gay marriages.

Advertise with us

Efforts to reinsert the civil union ban, led by state Sen. Jane Orie, R-McCandless, were rebuffed on the Senate floor Wednesday before the members voted to approve the stripped-down proposal and send it back to the House. The House now faces the choice of agreeing to the Senate language or attempting to hold out for the original, more restrictive version.

Like several other critics, Mr. Rendell pointed out that, in its current form, the legislation essentially duplicates Pennsylvania's Defense of Marriage Act, passed a decade ago, a law that the governor said he supported.

"What we've got is a constitutional amendment that is superfluous," Mr. Rendell said yesterday. "It doesn't do any harm, but it just reiterates the defense of marriage act, which remains unchallenged ... why are we futzing around with a defense of marriage constitutional amendment when we haven't passed a minimum wage [increase]?"

The Democrat was particularly caustic on the original House version of the plan.

"I think this was put in, again, for political purposes only," he said. "The original amendment was horrible because it would have stripped away domestic partnership benefits, benefits that come from recognizing the union between committed adults."

Advertise with us

Mr. Rendell spoke after a speech Downtown as a new poll depicted him as maintaining a significant lead over his GOP challenger, Lynn Swann. The Quinnipiac University poll showed the incumbent with a lead of 55 percent to 31 percent. The results were little-changed from a similar survey a month earlier and came after weeks in which Mr. Rendell's well-funded campaign has been unchallenged on the state's airwaves. Mr. Swann's campaign hopes to be able to afford to begin its air war later this summer.

Mr. Swann was in Philadelphia yesterday discussing his plans for educational improvement. He reiterated his proposals to increase tax credits designed to encourage business donation for scholarships, and to establish so-called education opportunity zones, areas where a variety of largely unspecified pilot programs can be established and studied to see which would be worth pursuing on a broader scale.

In his Philadelphia speech, Mr. Swann turned a critical eye toward achievement gaps between white and minority students in urban school systems.

"We are losing an entire generation of African Americans who are dropping out of our education system, and yet many of us are afraid to talk about it," he said.

While acknowledging that he was not ready to offer an antidote to the chronic problem, Mr. Swann took a swipe at a Rendell proposal to fund expanded use of computers. "We must not pretend that the hopes of simply placing a laptop computer in every classroom will address the fact that an entire generation of African-American and Hispanic young people continue to lag behind others in education achievement."

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.