As a review of Allegheny County's ballots continues, state Rep. Joseph Preston's narrow lead for the Democratic nomination in the 24th state House District appears secure, according to county elections officials.

Previous Story

Preston's election victory up in air

The initial and routine recanvass of votes in the East End district produced numerous discrepancies between the number of voters recorded as having cast ballots and the numbers of ballots counted in individual precincts.

Advertise with us

The majority of those discrepancies have been resolved. While several dozen remain, their total is not enough to tip the election to challenger Ed Gainey, even if every ballot were found and wound up in the runner-up's column.

Initial unofficial returns showed Mr. Preston with a 96-vote margin over Mr. Gainey, with a third candidate far behind. After a review of returns from all of the 24th district's precincts, Mr. Preston's lead was shaved to 93.

Records continue to show that as many as 16 optically scanned ballots may not have been counted. There is also an unresolved difference of roughly two dozen in the number of voters who signed in on election day and the totals recorded on the county's new iVotronic touch-screen machines. But the remaining questions don't add up to the potential to reverse the unofficial results.

The election division's review suggests that most of the problems were the result of poll workers' confusion over the county's new voting machines. They appear to have resulted in hundreds of initially uncounted ballots across the county although they don't appear to have the potential to change the reported winner in any of the county's races.

Most ballots last Tuesday were cast on the new, ATM-like touch screen machines. But the county also used optically scanned paper ballots and those were the source of recurring problems.

Advertise with us

The optically scanned paper ballots were available for use at voting places on election day, and were also used for absentee ballots. All of the paper ballots were to be counted together, but it appears that in many instances in the 24th district and elsewhere, poll workers sent the absentee ballots -- unopened and uncounted -- back to election headquarters with other voting materials. Finding and counting them slowed the process of the routine post-election review.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.