HARRISBURG -- The newfound clout of conservative Republican voters, which helped topple 17 incumbent legislators Tuesday, could make it harder for the Legislature to resolve major issues such as property tax relief and a state budget in June.

Some conservative GOP legislators have been emboldened by the lopsided defeats of top Senate moderates Robert Jubelirer and David Brightbill and intend to press for stronger action on property tax relief when the Legislature reconvenes June 5.

House Majority Leader Sam Smith, of Punxsutawney, and Rep. Sam Rohrer, R-Berks, insist they won't settle for Democratic Gov. Ed Rendell's version of property tax relief, a bill Mr. Jubelirer and Mr. Brightbill had supported.

That bill was developed May 1 by a House-Senate conference committee on which Mr. Brightbill sat. It was approved by the full Senate May 2, only to be shelved, unexpectedly, by the House on May 3.

Advertise with us

Mr. Smith and Mr. Rohrer complained the Rendell plan mainly helps lower-income senior citizens and doesn't give meaningful tax relief to middle-class homeowners.

"We want more meaningful property tax relief than the governor's plan," Mr. Smith said. "We are fighting for significant relief for all property taxpayers, not just a few."

Mr. Rohrer, a leader of GOP House conservatives, wants to generate several billion more dollars by applying the state sales tax to more items, such as some food and clothing. He said doing that could sharply cut, or even eliminate, all school property taxes. Mr. Brightbill has opposed that idea, as have many Senate Democrats.

Mr. Rohrer said that just since Tuesday's primary, he'd been deluged by letters and e-mail from homeowners demanding greater relief than the governor's plan provides.

"I hope these guys [in the Legislature] finally get the message," Mr. Rohrer said. "We want school property taxes eliminated. [Tuesday's results] boost the chances that state taxpayers will get substantial relief."

Advertise with us

A House GOP plan to generate more sales-tax revenue by taxing food and/or clothing had met opposition from Mr. Brightbill. But his influence, along with that of President Pro Tem Jubelirer, could be greatly weakened by their new lame duck status.

No one, obviously, knows what will happen in June because the upheaval from Tuesday's primary remains hard to read.

But when lawmakers resume work, they'll face another type of pressure, a sort of countervailing wind which could offset the pumped-up conservatives.

First, Mr. Rendell will be strongly pressing them to approve the conference committee tax bill. And given the public's anger over the now-rescinded pay raise, legislators might well feel an urgency to do something for voters, even if it is just the modest property tax relief that the conference committee bill offers.

Wilkes University professor Thomas Baldino said the defeat of many incumbents on Tuesday could "provide an impetus for [property tax] relief" sooner rather than later.

Advertise with us

If legislators leave the Capitol on June 30 without giving voters any tax relief, "I'm sure they will feel even more pressure to deliver something concrete" when they return in the fall, he said.

Other observers think the Legislature's failure to deliver on property tax relief helped accentuate voters' anger over the now-rescinded pay raises.

"This was a pay raise vote in the context of a Legislature that hadn't produced a lot in the last few years. So I think that [situation] further increases the pressure to do something on property tax relief," said Ron Cowell, a former lawmaker who heads the Education Policy and Leadership Center.

But ex-Rep. Jeff Coleman, a conservative Republican, didn't think legislators would rush into a property tax bill.

He said they would be making a mistake "to read the tea leaves [from Tuesday] and start passing or repealing things in haste."

Advertise with us

One problem with repeal of the pay raise in November was that "it looked like a knee-jerk reaction to save careers," he said.

Some conservative groups such as the Club for Growth, had opposed Mr. Jubelirer and Mr. Brightbill, partly because they're not "conservative enough" and have cooperated with Rendell.

Because of the greater conservative clout, senators such as Jeffrey Piccola, R-Dauphin, could take on a bigger role and complicate budget talks with the Democratic governor.

Mr. Cowell sees rising conservative power causing conflict with the Senate GOP.