HARRISBURG -- U.S. District Judge Yvette Kane expects to decide within three weeks whether to dismiss a lawsuit alleging that state officials violated the U.S. Constitution when they negotiated and approved last year's pay raises.

She heard arguments yesterday from attorneys for plaintiffs, including Common Cause of Pennsylvania, and defendants, including legislative leaders, Gov. Ed Rendell and Pennsylvania Chief Justice Ralph Cappy.

Plaintiffs argued that the Legislature violated their rights to free speech and due process last July when it passed the 16 to 34 percent raises in the middle of the night without opportunity for public input. The raises for lawmakers, judges and some executive-office employees have since been repealed.

The plaintiffs' attorney, P. Anthony Rossi, argued yesterday that the raises were the result of "secret negotiations and a scheme to bypass the legislative process required by the Constitution."

Advertise with us

Attorneys for the defendants denied that and urged Judge Kane to dismiss the suit, saying political issues should be decided in the Capitol, not the courthouse.

Judge Kane agreed yesterday to dismiss two defendants, state Treasurer Bob Casey and the commonwealth.

Legislators already have faced repercussions from angry constituents in the form of protests, phone calls and, most recently, Tuesday's primary. Seventeen incumbents who supported the pay raise were defeated.

More repercussions could be on the way in the November general election and when the state Supreme Court rules on three other cases related to the raises.