Martha Rial, Post-Gazette
Lt. Gov. Catherine Baker Knoll greets supporters last night at Finnegan's Wake on the North Side.MORE COVERAGE
Pay raise backlash ousts top legislators
Unofficial election results for Western Pennsylvania races
Lt. Gov. Catherine Baker Knoll, a McKees Rocks native and longtime presence in Pennsylvania politics, last night easily fended off three Democratic primary challengers in her drive to secure another term in the state's second-highest office.
The first female to ever hold the post, Mrs. Knoll yesterday faced the only crowded field of candidates in a statewide race.
As a veteran of 30 years of campaigning across Pennsylvania, she possessed much greater name recognition than her opponents: Valerie McDonald Roberts, Allegheny County's recorder of deeds; Gene Stilp, a Dauphin County activist; and William Hall, a Northampton County businessman.
They had questioned whether Mrs. Knoll, who will turn 76 this year, could handle her job's most important role: filling a vacancy in the governor's office.
Irwin Aronson, chairman of Mrs. Knoll's campaign, called the charge "absurd."
"That's campaign talk. They needed something to latch onto," he said as about 200 supporters of the lieutenant governor gathered last night at Finnegan's Wake on Pittsburgh's North Side. "No one else seeking this office can bring that kind of experience."
In November, Mrs. Knoll will face Jim Matthews, a Montgomery County commissioner and brother of MSNBC talk show host Chris Matthews, who was unopposed for the Republican nomination for lieutenant governor.
Her primary competition was much thinner than it was in 2002's race for the Democratic nomination, when Mrs. Knoll, a former state treasurer, defeated eight other candidates, all men.
This year, Mrs. Knoll had the strong backing of Gov. Ed Rendell, who stood by his running mate despite widespread speculation that he was considering a turn to another candidate.
A few recent missteps by Mrs. Knoll prompted the speculation. Last year, she attended the funeral of a soldier killed in Iraq and offended family members by handing out business cards. She has been known to make verbal gaffes in public, once referring to the governor as "Edward G. Robinson."
Ms. Roberts, 50, of Churchill, said she had discounted comments about the lieutenant governor's abilities until she spoke to Mrs. Knoll personally.
"I was concerned," Ms. Roberts said. "The lieutenant governor's post is a very serious position. That person has to be able to fulfill the responsibilities of governor."
Mrs. Knoll's defenders have described such criticism as gender and age bias.
But Bill Green, a Pennsylvania political analyst and consultant, said voters probably took little notice of the issue, which he described as "inside baseball."
Mrs. Knoll went into this election with a reputation as one of the state's biggest vote-getters. In 1992, she received 2.83 million votes, a half million more than any other winner at that point in Pennsylvania's history.
"Nothing against Valerie. You just don't beat Catherine Baker Knoll," Mr. Green said.
Mrs. Knoll's other duties include top posts with the state Board of Pardons and the Pennsylvania Emergency Management Agency.
But filling the office of governor is always a looming possibility.
In recent memory, two lieutenant governors have moved into the state's top office. Former Lt. Gov. Mark S. Singel served as acting governor for six months in the mid 1990s, while the late Gov. Robert. P. Casey was recovering from a heart and liver transplant, and former Lt. Gov. Mark S. Schweiker finished up the final year of former Gov. Tom Ridge's term when President Bush recruited his fellow Republican to become the first secretary of the U.S. Department of Homeland Security.
Some have speculated that Mr. Rendell may seek a spot in a future Democratic presidential administration or make a run for Senate before finishing a second term.
Also, Mr. Stilp has noted Mr. Rendell's eating habits, repeatedly quipping that Mrs. Knoll may be "just a cheese-steak away" from the governor's office.
Mr. Stilp, 55, a former legislative staffer and anti-nuclear activist from Dauphin County, last year became one of the state's most outspoken critics of the infamous Harrisburg pay raises. He even traveled the state with an inflatable pig.
"Win or lose, we'll keep on changing Pennsylvania," he said this week.
Ms. Roberts, a former Pittsburgh City Council and school board member, is in a position to build on her first statewide campaign. Her current office, recorder of deeds, faces elimination in 2008 because of a reorganization of Allegheny County government.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.