Gubernatorial candidate Lynn Swann said yesterday that his yet-to-be-announced plan to reform property taxes would likely entail a constitutional amendment, a legal and political process that under the most favorable circumstances would take years to complete.

Mr. Swann's spokeswoman later said other aspects of his developing plan could be implemented sooner.

Mr. Swann has sharply criticized his November opponent, Gov. Ed Rendell, over the fact that promised property tax relief has yet to materialize after more than three years of his administration. Implicit in the concepts Mr. Swann discussed yesterday, however, is a similarly lengthy timetable.

Mr. Swann, a Republican, has called for fundamental but unspecified changes in the state's property tax system. Among the key elements in the plan, which is expected to be unveiled by the end of the month, is a cap on property taxes that would protect homeowners from unpredictable increases. Legal experts have suggested that such a change would violate a state constitutional provision mandating uniformity in taxation.

Advertise with us

"If you want to have real reform and do something meaningful for the long term, you're going to have to dig down deep enough to make sure that it's foundational," Mr. Swann said. "I think herein lies a problem in terms of getting real reform of property tax; people haven't wanted to go in and ask for a constitutional amendment, or change. They looked to put a Band-Aid on it."

Except in emergencies, proposed amendments to the state constitution must be approved in two separate sessions of the Legislature, then by the public in a statewide referendum. That means if Mr. Swann were elected and the lawmakers voted in with him approved his constitutional proposal, it would be another two years before a newly elected Legislature could endorse it and submit it to the voters in a referendum that would have to take place at least three months after final legislative approval.

"You're asking me if it's going to take two or three years to get it done if there's a constitutional change. Yes, there will be, it will take that amount of time," Mr. Swann said. "But [we should] implement a real plan."

Melissa Walters, Mr. Swann's press secretary, said after the news conference that while a constitutional amendment would be at the core of the proposal, it would also include provisions to provide more immediate action. She declined to say what those other provisions might be.

"More people will get more relief in the first year than under Ed Rendell's plan," Ms. Walters said. "Taxpayers will not have to wait three years for relief under Lynn Swann's property tax plan."

Advertise with us

Dan Fee, Mr. Rendell's campaign press secretary, sharply criticized the Republican's latest statement on the controversial issue.

"Lynn Swann is the perfect candidate for this Republican Party because he doesn't care when property tax relief gets to Pennsylvania homeowners, either," he said. "Last week the House refused to vote on $1 billion in guaranteed tax relief. Now Lynn Swann says that his plan will take years. That is a match made in heaven."

The state House's Republican leadership last week blocked a vote on a property tax relief measure that had emerged from a House-Senate conference committee and been approved overwhelmingly by the Republican-controlled Senate. House GOP leaders maintained that they wanted a bill providing deeper relief.

Though it was supported by several close allies in the Senate GOP leadership, Mr. Swann dismissed that bill as a "Band-Aid," and said Mr. Rendell had promoted it because he was eager for an election-year accomplishment. Mr. Swann refused to say whether he agreed with the House action, but he strongly disputed suggestions that he had influenced the decision.

Some Democrats suggested that the vote was blocked to deprive Mr. Rendell of an accomplishment that he could brag about to voters.

Advertise with us

Mr. Swann made his observations on taxes and other issues in a brief news conference after an appearance at the North Shore high-tech firm, Confluence. In a question-and-answer session with employees, he touted his previously announced proposals to cut business and personal taxes. In response to one question he said he was confident that he would be able to establish good relations with the Legislature.

"But I'm not planning on buying any ChapStick," he said, in a kidding reference to a widely reported statement by Mr. Rendell, who told a group of Bucks County businessmen that he signed last year's ill-fated pay raise in an effort to "kiss a little butt" with the Legislature.