Pennsylvania's lieutenant governor has a variety of usually obscure duties -- presiding over the state Senate and chairing the Board of Pardons, for example. But, most importantly, the lieutenant governor waits.
Waiting paid off for the state's previous two lieutenant governors. Former Lt. Gov. Mark S. Singel was acting governor for six months while the late Gov. Robert P. Casey recovered from a heart and liver transplant, and former Lt. Gov. Mark S. Schweiker finished up the last year of former Gov. Tom Ridge's term when Mr. Ridge was drafted to become President Bush's homeland security adviser.
Lt. Gov. Catherine Baker Knoll, 75, the current officeholder and a veteran of state politics, is being challenged for renomination on the Democratic ticket by three people, two of whom say flatly she is not qualified to take over the top spot.
The challengers are Allegheny County Recorder of Deeds Valerie McDonald Roberts; Gene Stilp, an activist who has been one of the most outspoken voices against lawmakers' perks and pay raises; and William Hall, a businessman and developer.
One of the four will form a ticket with Gov. Ed Rendell in November. In Pennsylvania, candidates for governor and lieutenant governor run separately in the primary and as a team in the general election, a system which has drawn recurring criticism.
As is often the case in Pennsylvania politics, things are tidier on the Republican side. Montgomery County Commissioner Jim Matthews, 57, the brother of national television commentator Chris Matthews, is unopposed for the GOP nomination to run alongside Lynn Swann, who faces a similarly unobstructed road to the Republican nomination for governor.
Voters made Mr. Rendell and Mrs. Knoll a team. In 2002, in an expensive, hard-fought campaign for the governor's nomination against then-Auditor General Robert P. Casey Jr., Mr. Rendell declined to endorse anyone in the nine-person field seeking the second spot on the Democratic ticket.
Mrs. Knoll won the nomination with an edge of about 30,000 votes over her nearest competitor, Auditor General Jack Wagner, in an election in which more than 1 million votes were cast. Some critics had contended, and some Democrats feared, that Mrs. Knoll would prove an electoral liability to Mr. Rendell.
One of the reasons was that during her tenure as state treasurer several associates were targets of a Securities and Exchange Co0mmission investigation into charges that they had improperly benefited from the refinancing of a state bond issue. She was never charged or directly implicated in the case, and, in November, Mr. Rendell cruised to a landslide victory over then-Attorney General Mike Fisher.
A few missteps
For the most part, Mrs. Knoll's first term has proceeded with the relative anonymity common to her predecessors. She occasionally raised eyebrows with verbal missteps, referring to the governor as "Edward G. Robinson," for example. She sparked a critical storm last summer when she attended a GI's funeral and one of the dead serviceman's relatives took sharp offense to her handing out her business card.
Mrs. Knoll said her presence had been misinterpreted and that she merely meant to offer her sympathy. She insisted that she in no way meant to exploit the situation. Since then, she has frequently noted that she makes a habit of visiting wounded troops in Army hospitals.
The resilient Mrs. Knoll is a political survivor and veteran of decades on the state political scene. Before winning the Democratic nomination for her current post, she had lost four statewide elections, won two terms as state treasurer, and, along the way, set what was then the record for the most votes collected by a Pennsylvania candidate. Among the boasts of her tenure was the development of the Tuition Account Program, a college costs saving plan.
Mrs. Knoll was born in McKees Rocks, one of nine children, and, before embarking on the first of her political races, was a PennDOT official in the administration of former Gov. Milton Shapp.
Mr. Rendell did not recruit her for the coming election, but he has stood by her despite widespread speculation that he might turn to another candidate. He has said repeatedly that she is no more given to malapropism than is Mr. Bush. He also points out that many world leaders, including Charles de Gaulle and Winston Churchill, governed well into their 80s.
The governor's loyalty might also reflect political self-preservation. In winning two terms as state treasurer, Mrs. Knoll proved one of the state's biggest vote-getters. Her home base, southwestern Pennsylvania, is an area of the state where Rendell's popularity lags. Dumping her from the ticket would have risked offending some Democrats, particularly women, whose support Mrs. Knoll has cultivated over decades.
Mr. Rendell's loyalty was tested when a long-standing political ally, former U.S. Rep. Joe Hoeffel, decided to run for the nomination. If Mr. Rendell sent signals dissuading him from the race, Mr. Hoeffel didn't get them. The former Senate candidate repeatedly told reporters that he had discussed the race with the governor and that Mr. Rendell hadn't told him not to run.
On the day Mr. Hoeffel declared for office, however, Mr. Rendell told reporters he hoped he would change his mind. A chagrined Mr. Hoeffel promptly did so, sacrificing his candidacy on the altar of Mr. Rendell's re-election hopes.
While proclaiming their support for the governor, the remaining Democratic challengers aren't as deferential. In recent interviews, Mr. Stilp and Mr. Hall have plainly asserted that Mrs. Knoll is not capable of serving as governor. Their charges echo previous critical characterizations of her performance in her current office.
"She does not have the ability to take over in a crisis," Mr. Stilp said. "Her office is totally staff-driven."
Mrs. Knoll's campaign manager, Jeff Coyne, insisted that such charges were groundless and sexist.
The lieutenant governor is the only person in this race who has worked as an executive on a statewide level, he said. "She is more than qualified to be governor, if that should happen."
"If this was a man of the same age, we wouldn't even be having this discussion," he said. "My internal, gut instinct is that there's a double standard out there."
On campaign stops and other public occasions, Mrs. Knoll typically speaks freely to reporters. Aides in her public and campaign offices said, however, that her schedule precluded an interview for this article.
Ms. Roberts, 50, has been less critical of Mrs. Knoll than the incumbent's other two rivals, but she is straightforward in the claim that she would do a better job. She points out that she, like Mr. Rendell but unlike Mrs. Knoll, is a supporter of abortion rights. Ms. Roberts, who is African American, says her candidacy can "make history," as potentially the first black person to be elected to a nonjudicial statewide office.
She argues that, in addition to the geographic and gender balance she shares with the incumbent, she would offer Mr. Rendell's ticket racial balance in a campaign against a GOP team headed by an African American.
As recorder of deeds, the former Pittsburgh school board and City Council member was the first African American elected to a nonjudicial countywide office in Allegheny County. That post, recorder of deeds, will cease to exist in 2008.
Mr. Stilp, 55, of Dauphin County, is a merry warrior in political battles against a variety of targets. In the past year, the former legislative staffer and anti-nuclear activist has attained new prominence as one of the most outspoken and colorful voices against Harrisburg's notorious pay raises and perks. He's traveled the commonwealth with an inflatable pig, drawing attention to what he sees as political excess. Last week, he walked the 26 miles from the house of state Sen. David "Chip" Brightbill, one of the chamber's Republican leaders, to the Capitol to demonstrate his contention that the senator's acceptance of per-diem payments was excessive.
Mr. Stilp said he would bring the same spirit of reform to the lieutenant governor's office.
Mr. Hall is a newcomer to politics. A successful businessman and developer, his interest in public issues was piqued in the 1990s by the presidential campaigns of Ross Perot. In 1996, in fact, he was briefly a candidate for the Reform Party's presidential nomination. After selling his Naples, Fla., building firm, Mr. Hall, 55, moved to Northampton County in 1997. As lieutenant governor, he pledges that he would reduce the size of the office while combatting "the country club politics of Harrisburg."
Mr. Hall has emphasized property tax reform, urging the state to provide tax relief by exempting the first $25,000 of a home's assessed value from taxation. He has said that he would take a particular interest in Medicaid, hoping to spotlight the need to address its accelerating financial problems. Mr Hall notes that he is a member of the National Rifle Association, but says he could support some moderate initiatives against gun trafficking, such as a proposal to limit gun purchases to no more than one a month.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.