Three of the four Democratic candidates for lieutenant governor formed a mutual admiration society last night. In a debate on the campus of Carnegie Mellon University, they exhibited relatively few differences on the issues and aimed only isolated barbs at a target who wasn't in the room: the incumbent, Catherine Baker Knoll.
It was their second public encounter of the week, and the second time that Mrs. Knoll had declined to join her rivals. They are Valerie McDonald Roberts, the Allegheny County recorder of deeds, Gene Stilp, the anti-pay-raise activist from Dauphin County, and William Hall, a retired builder and developer from Northampton County.
The moderator read a letter from Mrs. Knoll explaining that she would not attend because the state Senate was in session in Harrisburg. But an aide to Mrs. Knoll had acknowledged earlier that she did not plan to participate in any debates before the primary.
"The lieutenant governor has been endorsed by the Democratic Party [and] by labor groups across the commonwealth," said Jeff Coyne, her campaign manager. "She is well known to Democrats across the state."
Ms. Roberts, the hometown favorite of the crowd of about two dozen, said she would be the best choice because she would bring balance to the ticket, and because, she like Gov. Ed Rendell, supports abortion rights.
Mr. Stilp cited his record as an opponent of last year's legislative pay raise, and his knowledge of emergency management issues as qualifications for the second spot on the Democratic ticket.
Mr. Hall, the retired businessman said he, too, was committed to reform.
"I'm not going to Harrisburg to make friends with anyone," he said.
In answering a question on the abortion issue, Mr. Stilp said that he was pro-life, while Mr Hall said the government had no role in such a personal decision even though he personally opposed abortion.
The candidates agreed on the need for property tax reform and increased education. Mr. Hall contended that property tax reform could be accomplished though a $25,000 exemption on the assessed value of homes, while Mr. Stilp said he would demand that the state's lawmakers stay in Harrisburg until they achieved real progress on the contentious issue.
Asked how they would promote minority employment, Ms. Roberts pointed to her record in her current post, saying that she had boosted minority representation in the county office from 7 percent to roughly 18 percent.
Mr. Stilp said he would work "like a tiger," to advance diversity issues in the Legislature. Mr. Hall said he had no overall answer to the question but added, that "What I do know in my heart I want minority people working with me."
Throughout the evening, Mr. Stilp was the only candidate to direct really pointed criticism of Mrs. Knoll. He argued repeatedly that she was not capable of assuming the duties of governor.
"Right now we are in crisis," he said. The lieutenant governor is one cheese steak away from the governorship ... the lieutenant governor has to be a person that can be counted on in a time of crisis; the current lieutenant governor is not capable of doing that."
The debate was sponsored by the League of Women Voters, the Black Political Empowerment Project and the graduate schools of Carnegie Mellon University and the University of Pittsburgh.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.