As Democratic Party officials vote on their choices for the May primary this week, several long-shot candidates hope to grab at least part of the spotlight, even if they have no chance of prevailing in the endorsement votes that top the party agenda.

Treasurer Bob Casey Jr. is the dominant Democratic candidate for the endorsement to challenge U.S. Sen. Rick Santorum, R-Pa., while Catherine Baker Knoll is expected to win the party's endorsement to share the November ticket with Gov. Ed Rendell, who is unopposed for renomination.

A change in the Democratic State Committee rules two years ago gives challengers at least some hope of a partial victory, but in the party vote Saturday in Harrisburg, as in the May primary, they remain distinct underdogs.

It now takes the support of two-thirds of the committee for a candidate to receive its official support. Contenders such as Chuck Pennacchio and Alan Sandals, in the U.S. Senate race, have no expectation of being within shouting distance of a majority, but if they could combine to get a third of the votes, it would deprive Mr. Casey of the endorsement, resulting in an officially open primary.

Advertise with us

Mr. Pennacchio, who has had isolated successes with local Democratic committee votes in Bucks and Lancaster counties in recent weeks, isn't ready to guarantee such a moral victory, but he insists it's not beyond the realm of possibility.

"I feel like we have an excellent shot of getting one-third plus one," he said last week. "Am I going to predict that? No. But I think we have an excellent shot at it."

Neither the Casey campaign, nor the senior party officials who have coalesced behind his candidacy, thinks that's much of a threat.

"No one can say with certainty; the two-thirds rule is a factor in any multicandidate race," said state Rep. T.J. Rooney, the Democratic state chairman. "But I hope and fully expect that Bob Casey and Catherine [Baker Knoll] will be our candidates."

Though she still faces opposition, the lieutenant governor's grasp of the endorsement seemed much more secure after former U.S. Rep. Joseph Hoeffel was nudged from the race by Mr. Rendell. While the former Senate candidate was still a contender in this race, Mrs. Knoll's chances of reaching the two-thirds level was an open question.

Advertise with us

Now, although Valerie McDonald Roberts, the Allegheny County recorder of deeds, William Hall, a Northampton County retiree, and anti-pay-raise gadfly Gene Stilp all remain on the primary ballot, Mrs. Knoll seems assured of the party support.

She appeared to be the favorite for the endorsement four years ago, but after endorsing Mr. Casey as its choice in the race that he went on to lose to Mr. Rendell, the committee, at Mr. Casey's request, did not endorse a candidate for the second spot on the ticket.

Mr. Casey has not always been the committee's choice. It spurned his candidacy in his first run for auditor general, but he had the members' backing in every race since -- for his second term as auditor general, in the unsuccessful bid for the 2002 nomination for governor and in the treasurer's race he won two years ago.

His liberal Philadelphia challengers, Mr. Pennacchio and Mr. Sandals, are pinning their hopes on the fact that some pro-choice Democrats are alienated by Mr. Casey's long-standing opposition to abortion rights.

Spurred by that issue, Kate Michelman, the former president of NARAL Pro-Choice America, briefly considered entering the race as an independent candidate. It was noteworthy, however, that in announcing she would not run for the Senate, Ms. Michelman said Mr. Casey's election, for all her reservations about his stand on abortion, would be preferable to another term for Mr. Santorum. Her statement never mentioned the possibility that one of the pro-choice Democrats might deprive him of the nomination.

Advertise with us

Mr. Pennacchio characterized her statement as "consistent with the politics-as-usual approach of the state party, the pollsters, the mainstream media pundits, who all want to shut down the primary process."

Despite the seeming dismissal of his chances, Mr. Pennacchio said, "I'm still happy she did what she did because more Pennsylvanians are aware of Casey's anti-Roe views."

Mr. Pennacchio trumpeted the fact that Mr. Casey fell short of winning the needed majority for endorsement by the Bucks County Democratic Committee earlier this month. He pointed to the Lancaster County Democrats' support of an open primary as a boost if not an implicit endorsement of his candidacy.

Mr. Sandals has not been as active as Mr. Pennacchio in trying to cultivate support from Democratic activists. In an appearance in Pittsburgh last week, however, the Philadelphia pension rights attorney predicted that he would prove a stronger rival to Mr. Casey with the broader public.

He said he had received a positive response from a commercial he ran on cable television at the time of the Alito confirmation hearings, and said that his strategy rested in part on further television spots.