HARRISBURG -- A challenger to one top Philadelphia state representative was disqualified from the May 16 primary ballot yesterday as judges began hearing the legal objections to people campaigning for the Legislature and other top elective offices.

The case was among nearly 80 challenges to candidates being heard in the state's Commonwealth Court.

People filing the challenges either hoped to disqualify candidates for having an insufficient number of signatures on their petitions -- candidates must obtain 300 to run for state House and 500 to run for Senate -- or for failing to completely report their sources of income and debt on state financial-disclosure forms.

Ten incumbents are among the candidates facing legal challenges, which are expected to be heard through March 31.

Advertise with us

Commonwealth Court dismissed the petition of Lamont W. Thomas after Mr. Thomas agreed that he had not collected the 300 signatures he needed to compete against Democratic Rep. Dwight Evans in the primary election, said Samuel C. Stretton, an attorney for two Evans supporters who challenged Mr. Thomas' petition.

"He will not be on the ballot," Mr. Stretton said in an interview after the hearing in Philadelphia.

Mr. Thomas, who acted as his own attorney, could not be reached for comment yesterday and did not appear to have a listed home phone number. The decision means that Mr. Evans will be unopposed in the primary.

Yesterday's slate of hearings included one for Rep. Babette Josephs, D-Philadelphia, whose financial-disclosure statement is being challenged by a Democratic voter in her district who argued that it is too vague. No immediate ruling was issued, but Ms. Josephs has said she plans to file an amended financial form.

The financial-disclosure papers of Jonathan Keeler, a Republican hoping to challenge Rep. John D. Payne, R-Dauphin, in the primary, were the subject of a hearing in Harrisburg. Commonwealth Court Judge James J. Flaherty said he would issue an opinion "very soon."

Advertise with us

Steven M. Williams, an attorney for Mr. Payne's campaign treasurer, Linda Pagliarulo, who challenged Mr. Keeler's petition, said he should be removed from the ballot because he listed his occupation as "consultant," but also checked on his form that he earned no income last year.

Mr. Keeler's attorney, Lawrence M. Otter, said Mr. Keeler was unemployed for "a considerable part" of the year and should be allowed to amend the form. He noted that dismissing Mr. Keeler's petition would leave Mr. Payne unopposed in the primary.

"It's in the interest of that district that democracy be preserved," Mr. Otter said.

One legal challenge by Larry Homsher, a Republican candidate in the 95th House District, was dismissed because it was not filed with the Department of State in time. That means Mr. Homsher will have to compete with Karen Emenheiser for the Republican primary nomination; the winner will face Rep. Stephen H. Stetler, D-York, in the November general election.

"I'm disappointed, but now I'll be focusing my efforts on getting the message out to the people in the 95th District," Mr. Homsher said.

Tomorrow is the deadline for candidates to withdraw from competition. If they wait until after the deadline to do so, they must obtain a special court order to have their names removed from the ballot, Department of State spokesman Brian McDonald said.