HARRISBURG -- Philadelphia lawyer Joseph Hoeffel's candidacy for lieutenant governor lasted about 17 hours.

Associated Press

Former U.S. Rep. Joe Hoeffel, left, stands with Gov. Ed Rendell during a news conference to confirm Mr. Hoeffel's decision to quit the race for lieutenant governor in Harrisburg.

Click photo for larger image.

Advertise with us

It officially began Tuesday afternoon when he turned in his petition signatures to the Department of State here. It abruptly ended yesterday morning when, under pressure from Gov. Ed Rendell and southwestern Pennsylvania Democrats, Mr. Hoeffel pulled the plug.

Mr. Hoeffel, a former congressman and state legislator from suburban Philadelphia, announced his candidacy for the Democratic nomination for lieutenant governor at a forum Tuesday in Pittsburgh.

He'd also scheduled a news conference for yesterday morning at a Downtown Harrisburg coffeehouse to repeat the announcement.

Instead, he startled reporters who'd gathered at the Caffeine Connection by reversing course and withdrawing from the five-way Democratic race. His decision came after a long talk with Mr. Rendell Tuesday, during which the governor said he had received strong criticism from Western Pennsylvania officials about the possibility of a ticket featuring two candidates from Philadelphia.

Mr. Hoeffel said he still thought he could have helped Mr. Rendell win a second term in November. But after hearing the governor tell a reporter on Tuesday that he wished Mr. Hoeffel would reconsider his decision to run, Mr. Hoeffel decided overnight to withdraw.

Advertise with us

Mr. Rendell's statement on Tuesday "surprised me," Mr. Hoeffel admitted, and then added he'd had "a very good, long and honest talk" with the governor Tuesday night.

"The bottom line is, he is asking me not to go forward with my race, due to some changes in his outlook,'' he said.

Mr. Rendell, who was with Mr. Hoeffel at the news conference yesterday, has said all along that he is supporting incumbent Democratic Lt. Gov. Catherine Baker Knoll, and Mr. Rendell insisted he didn't directly pressure Mr. Hoeffel to drop out.

"I have never, in my former role as mayor of Philadelphia or now in my role as governor, believed that it entitled me to be the political boss who made all the decisions for the Democratic Party,'' Mr. Rendell said.

But several Pennsylvania political analysts, including William J. Green of Pittsburgh, said it seemed certain the governor played a major role in what happened.

Advertise with us

"Joe Hoeffel would not have dropped out of this race unless he was asked to do so by Gov. Rendell," said Mr. Green.

The governor met privately in his Capitol office with Mr. Hoeffel three weeks ago. At the time, Mr. Rendell told Mr. Hoeffel that he supported Mrs. Knoll for another term as lieutenant governor.

But Mr. Hoeffel insisted that the governor had not told him not to challenge Mrs. Knoll, and so Mr. Hoeffel decided to press ahead.

So why, after saying for the last three weeks that he planned to run, did Mr. Hoeffel make such an abrupt about-face?

Because of great displeasure voiced by southwestern Pennsylvania Democrats, who weren't at all thrilled about the idea of having two white males from southeast Pennsylvania leading the Democratic ticket in the fall.

Advertise with us

"In the last three or four weeks, I have heard, with almost unanimity, from local and countywide elected officials in the southwest, that the burden of having two southeasterners on the ticket would be very difficult for them as they went out and tried to support my candidacy," Mr. Rendell said.

"Joe doesn't think they're right, and I'm not sure they're right," he said. "But I heard it enough from people in the southwest and from the media, and some elements of the Republican Party have already started trying to make this an east-west race," the governor said.

His GOP opponent will be former Steelers star Lynn Swann of Sewickley Heights. Mrs. Knoll, who lives in McKees Rocks, provides more geographic and gender balance for the Democratic ticket.

Mrs. Knoll issued a brief statement yesterday afternoon thanking Mr. Hoeffel for packing it in. She said she had "long admired Joe Hoeffel for his commitment and service to the Democratic Party in Pennsylvania. His decision today shows he has put the good of the party above personal desires. He has set an example for all of us."

With Mr. Hoeffel's withdrawal, there are still three Democrats left challenging Mrs. Knoll: Valerie McDonald Roberts, Allegheny County recorder of deeds; Gene Stilp, a Harrisburg political activist who gained attention for opposing last year's legislative pay raise; and William Hall, a retired steel worker from Northampton County.

Advertise with us

There is only one Republican candidate for lieutenant governor, Montgomery County Commissioner Jim Matthews, who is running with Mr. Swann.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.