HARRISBURG -- Lynn Swann's political blitz claimed another victim yesterday, as his last remaining Republican opponent, Jim Panyard of Lebanon, withdrew from the governor's race.

Mr. Panyard's departure followed recent exits by ex-Lt. Gov. Bill Scranton and state Sen. Jeff Piccola, and left Mr. Swann, a TV sportscaster and former Steelers wide receiver, as the only Republican standing in the campaign to oust Democratic Gov. Ed Rendell.

"We are happy to have a clear shot at Ed Rendell," said Mr. Swann's campaign director, Ray Zaborney.

In an interview, Mr. Panyard sounded sad, relieved and a bit angry about ending the long-shot campaign he'd begun last September. He said he was dropping out because he'd been unable to "attract enough financial support or any significant media attention to my campaign.''

Advertise with us

Mr. Panyard, a former Philadelphia newsman and longtime president of the Pennsylvania Manufacturers Association, also took a shot at the state Republican Party.

He claimed the Republican state committee's unanimous endorsement of Mr. Swann last weekend proves that the GOP "is not interested in principle, but in power and celebrity. It is interested in winning, principle be damned.''

Mr. Panyard said he doesn't think Mr. Swann will be independent of the entrenched Harrisburg power structure because his campaign is being directed by aides who used to work for Republican Gov. Tom Ridge and staffers for state Sen. Bob Jubelirer, R-Altoona.

"When a man of Bill Scranton's stature and resources believes a primary fight for the nomination is foolhardy, it doesn't take a weatherman to tell which way the wind is blowing," Mr. Panyard said. "Money talks and principle walks in the new monarchy in Harrisburg, Republicans and Democrats alike, which rules our state."

Many Republican leaders and legislators see the photogenic Mr. Swann -- who's garnered ample attention from the news media for his part in four Super Bowl victories and his 20 years as a college football analyst on TV -- as the party's best bet to defeat the well-known and more politically experienced Mr. Rendell, a former mayor of Philadelphia.

Advertise with us

If he does defeat Mr. Rendell in November, Mr. Swann would be the first African-American Republican to be elected governor in the United States; Douglas Wilder, a Democrat, was elected Virginia's governor in 1989.

Some journalists and Democrats have criticized Mr. Swann for failing, so far, to spell out specific positions on important state issues such as lowering property taxes and business taxes, improve delivery of services or cut government costs.

Democratic State Chairman T.J. Rooney said the fact that Mr. Swann won't have to face GOP opponents in a May primary means he can continue stalling on explaining his positions on issues.

Some Republicans had hoped that Mr. Swann would debate Mr. Scranton before last Saturday's GOP state committee endorsement, or that Mr. Swann would debate Mr. Panyard before May, so they could learn more about where he stands.

But now the debates, against Mr. Rendell, will likely have to wait until fall. Mr. Rooney said he's looking forward to those debates because he thinks Mr. Rendell will do well.

Advertise with us

"Ed Rendell understands state government inside and out," Mr. Rooney said. "He's a policy wonk."

Larry Ceisler, a campaign consultant from Philadelphia, said he thinks Mr. Swann could have benefited from "being tested in debates before the primary. He needs to be talking about substantive policy every day. His celebrity status will get him through the front door, but he needs to talk about serious issues in order to make the sale.''