Two new polls depict a potential matchup between Gov. Ed Rendell and Republican candidate Lynn Swann as a virtual tie.
Both surveys, by Zogby International and Rassmussen Reports, show the other major Republican contender, former Lt. Gov. Bill Scranton, trailing the incumbent with similar margins, by 45.7 percent to 37.9 percent in the Zogby poll and by 46 percent to 36 percent in Rasmussen.
The difference between Mr. Swann and Mr. Rendell's numbers were within the margin of error in each poll. With Zogby, it was Mr. Rendell, 43.9 percent; Mr. Swann, 43.6 percent; Rasmussen: Mr. Rendell, 45 percent; Mr. Swann, 43 percent.
Both polls, as the Scranton campaign was quick to note, use methodologies that differ from those of many public opinion surveys.
The Rasmussen poll is based on responses to automated, recorded calls, rather than questions posed by human interviewers as with more traditional public opinion sampling. The Zogby survey uses still another approach, with its results resting on an Internet survey of pre-screened respondents.
Some critics have noted that, overall, Internet access is skewed toward certain groups, such as younger and more affluent users. Zogby maintains, however, that their results are weighted to reflect the views of the general population. The firms sponsoring both surveys maintain that they, like more traditional polls, offer a snapshot of public views that is within a few percentage points of the results that would be found if every Pennsylvania voter had been interviewed.
"I'm not saying they're wrong, but both [methods] are controversial; they raise eyebrows within the academic research community," said Terry Madonna, a veteran chronicler of Pennsylvania elections who directs Franklin & Marshall College's Keystone Poll. "But having said that, with two polls using widely varying methodologies showing the race tightening, that's evidence that the race is tightening.''
Previous public polls, released by Franklin & Marshall, and a separate survey by Quinnipiac University, had shown Mr. Rendell with a double-digit lead over every potential challenger. A Quinnipiac survey released in mid-December showed Mr. Rendell with nearly identical leads of 48 percent to 36 percent over Mr. Scranton and 48 to 35 percent over Mr. Swann.
Since then, Swann generated a spike in publicity with his formal entry into the race.
Mr. Rendell's office had no comment on the results.
A Swann strategist welcomed the findings while Mr. Scranton's campaign manager shrugged them off.
"They certainly don't agree with what we have seen,'' said James Seif, Mr. Scranton's campaign manager. Contending that it is too early in the race for any poll's horse race numbers to be reliable predictors, Mr. Seif added, "We will go up; they will go down. They have this thing in this country called campaigning; we can do it; Swann cannot.''
Ray Zaborney, a chief strategist for Mr. Swann said, "This is a good indicator ... it shows, as we've said all along, that Ed Rendell is vulnerable and if we execute our game plan, this is a race.''
Mr. Swann and Mr. Scranton will face one another in a preliminary round of the race for the GOP nomination next month when they compete for the endorsement of the Republican state committee.
James Panyard, a former executive of the Pennsylvania Manufacturers Association, is also seeking the GOP nomination but he is not competing for the endorsement. Neither survey tested his potential strength in the governor's race.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.