Gov. Ed Rendell

No Pennsylvania governor has ever lost a bid for re-election.

Until last week, however, no Pennsylvania Supreme Court justice had ever lost a retention election.

Over the past four months, more attention has been focused on the Legislature that passed the middle-of-the-night salary measure than on the man who signed it. But the anti-pay raise fervor that has swept the state could prove a stiff political headwind for the Democratic governor re-election campaign as well.

Advertise with us

"He's certainly a target for anyone who cares about how this thing happened," Timothy Potts, the leader of the Democracy Rising movement, said of Rendell. "There's no way he comes out of this with clean hands."

Rep. T.J. Rooney, the state Democratic chairman, argues that the pay issue will prove a relatively small point in the overall re-election dynamics for Mr. Rendell.

"The governor is going to be re-elected because he has as a strong message of accomplishment. He's going to be able to talk about increasing support for education. He's going to be talking about economic development; he has a strong environmental message," Mr. Rooney said, "and he's going to have $40 million to deliver that message."

Russ Diamond, one of key activists in the state on salary issue, said that his group, Operation Clean Sweep, has not focused on the governor in the past but that may change soon. He said his board of directors planned to meet today to decide whether to adopt opposition to Mr. Rendell as one of its grass roots priorities.

"Several members of our board have said, 'He's part of the problem, what should we do about it,' " Diamond said.

Advertise with us

The state Republican Party, normally a reliable font of Rendell criticism, has been muted on this issue by the fact that the pay raise's principal architects included the Republican leaders of the House and Senate. But, to varying degrees, all four GOP candidates for governor have tried to hitch a ride on the anti-raise bandwagon.

Former Lt. Gov. Bill Scranton has been particularly aggressive in trying to capitalize on the issue. Atop his Web site, above even Scranton's own biography, is an invitation to sign a petition to "repeal the Rendell Pay Raise."

"We're going to continue to talk about that and talk about how Ed Rendell symbolizes the out-of-touch character of Harrisburg," said Mike DeVanney, an aide to Scranton.

Mr. Rendell has eluded the prime focus of the pay raise furor in part because of his increasing efforts to distance himself from it. In the immediate wake of the legislative accord that produced a budget and the salary legislation, Mr. Rendell avoided any criticisms of the increases. Later, he called for the repeal of the unvouchered expenses that were one of the most controversial parts of the legislation and, more recently, he has urged the Legislature to act quickly on a repeal that would preserve raises for judges.

Ken Snyder, a Democratic political consultant and former press secretary for Mr. Rendell, predicted that, in the public mind, the Legislature would continue to be more strongly identified with the controversy.

Advertise with us

"I think he's a lot less culpable for the pay raise than the Legislature and I think one of the overall dynamics you're going to see will be him running against the Legislature given all the administration initiatives they've blocked during his first term."

In pollsters' trial heats, Mr. Rendell has consistently run ahead of each of his would-be GOP challengers. But other early survey findings suggest some vulnerabilities.

The most recent Keystone Poll, conducted by Franklin and Marshall College, showed Mr. Rendell with the highest unfavorable and lowest favorable rating since he was elected. Mr. Rendell's unfavorable rating in the November survey was 38 percent and his favorable, 39 percent. His ratings in that category were in the same ballpark as those of U.S. Sen. Rick Santorum, the Republican incumbent who is being challenged by state treasurer Bob Casey Jr. By comparison, President Bush unfavorable rating in the same survey was 54 percent.

But in this as in other surveys, Mr. Rendell's numbers offer a tale of two states. In Philadelphia and its populous suburbs, the city's former district attorney and mayor is politically unassailable. But his popularity lags far behind in the rest of the state.

According to a Quinnipiac University poll conducted last month, Mr. Rendell's job approval rating was an impressive 72 percent in Philadelphia and 64 percent in the surrounding counties. In normally Democratic Allegheny County, however, Mr. Rendell's approval rating was only 34 percent, with 45 percent saying they disapproved of his job performance. In the surrounding counties of the Southwest, his numbers were still bleaker -- only 29 percent approved and 58 percent disapproved.

Advertise with us

Neil Oxman, the governor's veteran media strategist, acknowledged that he has ground to make up across the state, but he said that his Southeast base givens him a commanding position.

"He enjoys huge popularity in the Southeast and he's reasonably popular in the Scranton, Wilkes-Barre area," Mr. Oxman said. "The fact that he's so strong in the biggest media market in the state makes him a pretty tough person to beat in 2006."

Mr. Rendell's challenge in shoring up his numbers elsewhere in the state could be compounded, however, by the fact that the areas where his popularity is weaker are the same ones in which the pay raise issue proved most potent in Tuesday's startling rejection of Justice Russell Nigro.

Another survey finding that is a red flag for Rendell or any incumbent is the sharp jump in the percentage of Pennsylvanians who feel that the state is on the wrong track. The November Franklin and Marshall poll found that a majority, 52 percent, said they felt the state was on the wrong track while only 39 percent said it was headed in the right direction. That was a reversal of the same poll's findings in March 2005, when 50 percent said the state was headed in the right direction and 44 percent said it was on the wrong track.

Mr. Oxman, whose consulting firm, the Campaign Group, represents political clients nationwide, said that sour trend was not unique to Pennsylvania.

Advertise with us

"The 'right direction/wrong track' number is really bad right now. You see that across the country," he said.

Mr. Oxman said that the pay issue had provided a focus for that general unrest in Pennsylvania, but he said he was confident that it would take its place in a long line of issues as the general election got closer.

"People are angry and I don't underestimate the fact that some people will still be angry a year from now," he said. "But a year is a long time and a thousand things can happen and the governor's race will hinge on 50 other things as well."

He noted that Mr. Rendell's position as governor, buttressed by his robust fundraising, would give him the resources to put his own shape on the campaign agenda.

"He's got to focus on his accomplishments," said Mr. Snyder, the Democratic consultant. "If this becomes a referendum on the pay raise issue, the campaign will have failed in a lot of ways, because that's not a winning issue."

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.