The major Republican candidates for governor mixed direct shots at Gov. Ed Rendell with subtler jabs at one another last night as they courted the support of Beaver County Republicans.

Their antipathy for the performance of the Democratic governor was nearly matched in vehemence by their criticism of the property tax system which, they contended, Mr. Rendell had failed to rectify in the gambling and tax relief legislation enacted with the support of the Republican-controlled Legislature.

As in the past, however, the three Republicans differed on how they would deal with that long-standing issue.

State Sen. Jeff Piccola, R-Dauphin, maintained that he was the only candidate who has offered specifics on property tax relief. He pointed to his proposed legislation that would eliminate the property tax for schools while substituting the revenue from a sales tax that would have a lower rate but would apply to a broader range of goods and services than the current levy.

Advertise with us

"I am the only candidate with a plan," he said.

In an interview after his remarks at the Jeffries Landing restaurant in Bridgewater, former Lt. Gov. Bill Scranton III said that a broader sales tax should be part of the answer to property tax concerns but maintained that it would be a mistake to totally eliminate the local tax, arguing that Mr. Piccola's sales tax proposal went too far in its broader reach.

"You'd end up adding taxes to things like home heating oil or tuition," he said.

Lynn Swann, an ABC broadcaster, said reform of the property tax system was long overdue but insisted it was premature to offer a specific alternative before finding out what the Legislature might produce in the special session on tax reform called by Mr. Rendell.

Each of the candidates insisted that their background gave them unique assets to devote to the common goal of defeating Mr. Rendell.

Advertise with us

Mr. Swann said that his leadership ability gave the GOP the best chance of turning out the incumbent.

"We can create a culture of winning in the Republican Party," he said, suggesting the crowds he has drawn to various GOP gatherings demonstrated his ability to do that.

Mr. Piccola repeatedly reminded the crowd of about 100 that he had "been in the trenches," fighting legislative battles in Harrisburg.

Mr. Scranton has worked in private business since serving as lieutenant governor under Dick Thornburgh, then losing an election for governor to the late Gov. Bob Casey. He said that he was the only candidate able to offer "executive experience, in and out of government."