HARRISBURG -- State Sen. Jeff Piccola, a potential GOP gubernatorial candidate, says he hopes his plan to eliminate school property taxes by expanding the sales tax to include food and clothing will be considered by the Legislature by this autumn.
Piccola, who met with reporters yesterday to discuss his proposal, says his plan to lower the sales tax to 5.7 percent, then broaden it to include food, clothing and professional services, would raise an extra $8.5 billion annually -- that's in addition to the $8 billion already raised under the current 6 percent rate.
The $8.5 billion increase in tax revenue would be offset by identical tax reductions at the local level.
For decades, lawmakers have given lip service to the need to reduce or wipe out school property taxes in Pennsylvania, but little has been accomplished toward achieving that goal. Most recently, Democratic Gov. Ed Rendell's hallmark plan to reduce those taxes with gambling revenues fell flat when about four in five districts opted not to participate in the program, known as Act 72.
Piccola said yesterday that the time is finally right for progress toward the goal.
"It has to be eliminated," he said of the school property tax.
If the state collected the 5.7 percent sales tax on food, clothing and services, then returned it to the schools, Pennsylvania would contribute about 86 percent of the total money spent on public education. Currently, the state pays less than 40 percent of public education's total cost.
The bugaboo against the tax is that it disproportionately affects those who can afford it least -- poorer households that spend a greater share of their monthly budgets on food and clothing. Nickels and dimes mean more to them than to wealthier families, opponents say, and yesterday, a familiar opponent of the plan, state Rep. Mike Veon, D-Beaver Falls, chimed in.
"This plan is nothing more than a tax hike that would force working families to pay sales tax on food and clothing and force professionals like accountants and attorneys to charge sales tax on their services," Veon said, in a statement distributed following Piccola's Capitol briefing.
Piccola said it's not the sales tax that's regressive, it's the property tax, since property tax bills are sent even to those people who aren't earning incomes -- retirees, for example. He also noted that most states tax clothing, and 18 already tax food.
Piccola said he couldn't provide any estimates on how the tax plan might affect the average homeowner, because there are too many variables in play -- the extra money they might spend on food and clothing would be offset, to some degree, by the reductions in their tax bills, and those amounts would vary greatly from school district to school district.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.