State Sen. Jeff Piccola, one of three Republicans vying for a chance to run against Gov. Ed Rendell next year, will announce today a sketch of his plan to eliminate school property taxes and replace them with a sales tax on food, clothing and a range of services.
Pennsylvanians already pay a 6 percent sales tax that doesn't touch food and most clothing items. Piccola's plan would lower the tax rate to 5.7 percent and expand its reach to everything from a quart of milk at the corner store to a pair of socks.
It would also target many professional services, such as lawyers and architects.
Property taxes have long been the principal source of revenue for public schools in Pennsylvania, and they bring in about $8.3 billion in revenue per year for the state's 501 school districts, according to Piccola's office.
Yet Piccola, the No. 3 Republican in the state Senate, argues that those taxes do not accurately reflect a property owner's ability to pay and unfairly burden elderly homeowners living on limited incomes.
"In theory, you can have no income and still have to pay the property tax," the Dauphin County legislator said.
His argument is echoed by many conservative lawmakers in Harrisburg, including the members of the Commonwealth Caucus, which first introduced a bill to swap school property taxes for an expanded sales tax 21/2 years ago.
The group's latest proposal would lower the sales tax to 5 percent, while raising the state's realty transfer tax from 1 percent to 3 percent. A series of bills making those changes could come up for a full vote in the House or Senate later this year.
The Piccola and caucus plans would exempt from the sales tax most medical services, including visits to doctors, dentists and hospitals, and the sale of prescription drugs. Homeowners and business owners would still pay property taxes to counties and municipalities.
Steve Kniley, press secretary for the state Department of Revenue, said earlier caucus proposals for a sales tax would not have raised enough revenue, and he said his office is doing a study of the current proposal being considered by the state Legislature.
An expanded sales tax has also faced criticism from Democrats and liberals who see it as way of shifting the tax burden onto poorer Pennsylvanians without property. Those people will have to pay a larger percentage of their incomes on food and clothing.
But Piccola thinks landlords, once they start paying substantially less in property taxes, will face market pressure to lower rents and balance the higher cost of basic goods. He also argues that lower property taxes would allow business owners to expand and create new jobs.
Forty-two states already tax clothing, while 18 tax food. In Pennsylvania, Allegheny and Philadelphia counties also have their own 1 percent sales taxes.
Rendell has been a big opponent of a new sales tax system here, but his plan to raise revenue at slot machine casinos still is several years away from reducing school property taxes across the state. The newly created Gaming Control Board has yet to award 14 available casino licenses.
Piccola and his two main rivals for the Republican gubernatorial nomination, former Steelers receiver Lynn Swann and former Lt. Gov. Bill Scranton, have criticized Rendell for failing to follow through on his promise to lower property taxes.
"Have you seen any of that?" Piccola said of the anticipated gambling revenue. "Gov. Rendell's proposal to provide tax relief through slot machines is a pipe dream."
Under Piccola's plan, school districts would initially receive the same amount of revenue they received from property taxes. That formula could change after a few years to meet the needs of different districts.
According to a poll conducted by Quinnipiac University in June, Piccola, who has been a legislator since 1977, trails both Scranton and Swann if all three candidates were to face off in a Republican primary.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.