Ever since Pennsylvania governors have been allowed to seek a second term, every one has, successfully.

Three very different Republicans contend they will break that streak next year and, with it, the administration of Gov. Ed Rendell. Supporters of Lynn Swann, the broadcaster and former Steelers wide receiver, contend that his fresh celebrity face will allow him to compete with Rendell's money and strong political base.

Former Lt. Gov. Bill Scranton cites his business background and long-standing family and personal ties to statewide Republicans as unique qualifications for the GOP nomination. State Sen. Jeff Piccola, R-Dauphin County, argues that his in-depth knowledge of state issues will allow him to make the most detailed and effective critique of the incumbent's record.

They have disparate disadvantages as well. Swann has the challenge of convincing voters that, though a political neophyte, he is ready to leap to the top of the state's political ladder. Scranton must rebuild a political base after a two-decade hiatus from the state's electoral scene. Piccola has to overcome low name recognition beyond Harrisburg and his own district and demonstrate that he has the ability to raise the money essential to power a statewide race.

Advertise with us

Swann's reported haul from the Heinz Field fund-raiser was reasonably impressive, between $600,000 and $700,000, according to aides, but it was little more than a rounding error compared with the $40 million that Rendell raised in the primary and general elections of 2002. What was perhaps more impressive than the funds raised were the names on the host committee for the event. Swann stood with Republican Party heavyweights, including Christine Toretti Olsen, the state's GOP national committeewoman. Alan Novak, the party's former state chairman, also was on the host committee.

Such names as those are noteworthy because the state GOP hierarchy has been remarkably disciplined the past decade in making its endorsement meaningful. With few exceptions, statewide candidates endorsed by the state committee members tend to win nomination. Most of those who fall short in the party officials' balloting drop out.

Football to government

So, while 2006 elections remain far from the minds of most voters, some of the most decisive campaigning in the GOP governor's contest is going on right now among the rarefied electorate of the committee. Mostly away from the gaze of reporters and the public, Scranton, Piccola and Swann have been traveling the state, making their cases in person and on the phone to GOP insiders.

One of the most experienced insiders at Swann's side is Mark Holman, who served as chief of staff to Tom Ridge, former governor and later homeland security secretary. A more relevant part of Holman's resume in the campaign context is that he was the architect of Ridge's 1994 campaign, which took him from little-known congressman to the governor's mansion.

Advertise with us

In addition to the name recognition garnered in his football and broadcasting careers, Swann has a substantial record of community involvement in his post-NFL life. He has been a sharp critic of Rendell in his exploration of the governor's race. The major question mark about his potential candidacy is what policies he will embrace as his own and how credible he will be in advancing them.

He did little to answer that question Wednesday, sticking to broad generalizations about the need for lower taxes and reform in Harrisburg. NFL colleagues such as former Reps. Jack Kemp, R-N.Y., and Steve Largent, R-Okla., are examples of figures who have successfully negotiated the road from football to politics. More recently, the voters of Minnesota sent wrestler Jesse Ventura to their governor's mansion while Californians anointed Arnold Schwarzenegger, the former body builder turned movie action hero.

On the opposite end of the scale of political experience is Scranton, who served at the side of former Gov. Dick Thornburgh in Harrisburg from 1978 to 1986. He can boast having received, by a huge margin, more votes than anyone in the nascent GOP governor's race. After two statewide victories on the Thornburgh ticket, he narrowly missed capturing the governor's office himself in a rough 1986 battle against the late Robert P. Casey. He lost by fewer than 100,000 votes, with 1.6 million to Casey's 1.7 million.

Scranton describes himself as a conservative, although, like Ridge, his political profile reflects the strain of moderate Republicanism that has been more persistent in Pennsylvania than in many other states in recent years. He favors the provisions of the state's existing, relatively strict abortion control act, but he is the only one of the three Republican who favors a woman's right to choose an abortion. Swann describes himself as pro-life, as does Piccola, who had supported abortion rights earlier in his career.

Scranton, whose father was governor from 1962 to 1966, went into the private sector after his loss to Casey, working in California and later returning to Pennsylvania to oversee family investments. He describes his years away from the active political scene as one of his advantages.

Advertise with us

"I firmly believe that if you're going to be a politician, you should run for office every 20 years," he joked. He said he decided to explore the governor's race, because, "It's a critical time for the state."

"I'm passionate about competitiveness," he said, maintaining that his chief goal was to re-energize the state's economic development policies.

"We are one of the highest states in spending on economic development and we have been for some time," Scranton said. "Yet our economic growth is anemic compared to the rest of the country."

3 relative unknowns

Scranton and Piccola say they would eliminate the property tax as a source of education revenue. Neither has specified a precise blueprint for how to do that, but both point to proposals to broaden the state's sales tax, making it apply to currently exempt categorizes of goods or services, as one potential way to do that.

Advertise with us

Piccola is a respected member of the Senate, the No. 3 member of the GOP and a persistent critic of the Rendell administration. His position in leadership is a tactical problem in the gubernatorial race. That's because, after the GOP's leadership negotiations, he voted for much of the major, and controversial, legislation enacted under Rendell, including an increase in the personal income tax.

"He hated that vote," said his campaign manager, Dean Ouellette, referring to the tax increase. He maintained that, because of GOP opposition it was smaller than the one originally proposed by Rendell and noted that Piccola introduced legislation to repeal it in the next session of the Legislature.

He contended that the Senate leadership battles with the administration had demonstrated, that, "Jeff Piccola is more than able to compete against Ed Rendell.

"What we have to do is find a candidate who can stand up against Ed Rendell and debate him," he added. "Lynn Swann has yet to demonstrate that he can do that."

On Friday, the Piccola campaign sent out roughly 1,000 biographical videos to state committee members and major contributors. About a minute of that eight-minute presentation is devoted to Piccola's explanation of the evolution in his thinking on abortion.

Advertise with us

"I feel like I'm the front-runner for state committee endorsement," Piccola said in a recent interview. "I feel like I'm halfway there to the endorsement."

"I've been the most specific on taxes, on lawsuit reform; I've laid out a very specific agenda," he said.

Bruce Castor, the Republican Montgomery County district attorney, has said some unnamed Republicans have approached him about running for governor next year, but he has not been nearly as visible a presence in courting the state committee members. His chances in that forum would be hampered by the fact that he ran unsuccessfully without the GOP endorsement in a fairly bitter 2004 primary against Attorney General Tom Corbett.

While this contest is already the focus of intense interest and maneuvering among Republican insiders, an early survey of the race suggests that the public is paying next to no attention to it. Earlier this month, a Keystone Poll, conducted by Franklin & Marshall College, tested the favorability ratings of each of the leading potential contenders. In each case, the vast majority of those surveyed said they didn't know enough about the Republicans to express an opinion on them. For Scranton, the former lieutenant governor, the "don't know," number was 60 percent; for Swann, 63 percent; and for Piccola, 88 percent.