HARRISBURG -- Voting by snail mail? Too complicated.
Voting over the Internet? Too newfangled.
Voting in the weeks leading to Election Day? Too pointless.
On the Net
Read the final report of the Pennsylvania Election Reform Task Force, in pdf format
When the Pennsylvania Election Reform Task Force issued its report last month, the document included not only the committee's recommendations, but also some proposed election changes that were considered, but then eventually panned.
Some of the discarded ideas were more intriguing than the ones later endorsed, and some may provide a glimpse of what elections will look like 25 years from now, if not imminently.
In its report, the 13-member task force also recorded how it voted on each proposed recommendation, so readers could get a sense of which proposals were most politically controversial -- such as those discarded by a 6-to-7 vote -- and which ones were unanimously approved.
Unlike a national report issued last week, which recommended sweeping changes like using centralized "vote centers" instead of tiny precinct polls, the state report recommended tinkering instead of wholesale reorganization of the way Pennsylvanians vote. The state panel's suggestions would require legislative action and approval from the governor before taking effect.
The ultimate goal of Gov. Ed Rendell's reform panel was to make suggestions that will lead to greater voter participation and ensure smooth elections, without putting extra strain on individual poll workers or the overall election process.
"Extra strain" is what did in voting by mail, which "would require extensive revision to Pennsylvania's voting process." The idea was scrapped, 0-13.
The proposal was initially intriguing to the panelists, because Oregon uses voting by mail with great success. (Oregon had the fifth-highest voter "turnout" in the 2004 presidential election.)
The voter gets a ballot in the mail about two weeks before the election, and sends the ballot to the appropriate office at his leisure. There is no polling place, so voters can't use the excuse that they didn't have time to vote or couldn't find a ride.
But in the end, the theoretical benefits were outweighed by the idea that democracy ought to be a communal experience, said Daniel Shea, a panelist and Allegheny College political science professor.
"We thought that to build broad civic and political involvement, you need to bring people out of their homes, out of their living rooms," Shea said. Mail voting "might be a short term fix, in terms of boosting voter turnout," but it wouldn't draw regular, active participants into the political exercise, he said.
Allowing voters to cast ballots over the Internet becomes a more enthralling idea each passing election, as more and more Americans have access to the Web at home and work. But there are still worries, mostly involving security and the notion that a savvy computer hacker could wreck an election by wiping out a candidate's votes, voting illegally or otherwise tinkering with vote totals.
"The technology just isn't there right now," said Douglas Hill, director of the County Commissioners Association of Pennsylvania. He noted that the U.S. military scrapped its own Internet voting pilot project.
The Pennsylvania panel did say, however, that Internet voting "is an idea that merits consideration in the future," as security issues are resolved.
What about early voting? In Texas and Georgia, voters can show up at a central polling place a week or two before Election Day and vote. It makes voting more convenient, allowing voters to cast a ballot on a day off.
The panel unanimously discarded this idea, saying there doesn't appear to be much correlation between early voting and improved turnout. Besides, voters in Pennsylvania already can request an absentee ballot prior to an election -- itself a form of early voting.
There also was the worry that people who vote early might not be fully informed.
"What if something breaks late in the election?" said panelist Barry Kauffman, director of Common Cause of Pennsylvania, a political watchdog group. "If everybody's voting on the same day, everybody's voting on the same information."
The task force also examined, but rejected, proposals that would have kept the polls open longer on Election Day and would have designated Election Day an official state holiday.
The proposal defeated most narrowly, by a 6-to-7 vote, was one that would have allowed would-be voters a chance to register on Election Day.
Current state law sets a registration deadline of a month prior to the election. Six states -- Idaho, Maine, Minnesota, New Hampshire, Wisconsin and Wyoming -- allow voters to register on Election Day, and most allow would-be voters to register right there at the poll.
The strength of this proposed reform lies in its apparently impressive correlation with voter turnout -- Maine, Minnesota, New Hampshire and Wisconsin had the four highest turnout rates in the 2004 election.
But Pennsylvania's panel worried that "election officials could be overwhelmed with individuals trying to vote, in addition to those who were voting." Another panelist worried that the confusion could lead to more fraud.
"There's too much chance that someone walks in, says they're someone, the [poll workers] look quickly at the driver's license ... but they're not really that person," said William H. Lamb, former state Supreme Court Justice and one of the seven panelists to vote against Election Day registration.
Lamb is a Republican. Shea, a Democrat, thought fraud worries were a "red herring."
"It's likely the one issue that would have been mixed in partisan politics," if it had been recommended to the Legislature, he said. "There is concern among Republicans that the type of person that would take advantage of the same-day registration is a Democrat."
Shea and five others thought the immediate increase in turnout would have been worth the same-day hassle.
A similar proposal, which would have allowed people trying to cast a "provisional ballot" to also register to vote using the ballot envelope, was also disapproved by the panel. A provisional ballot is a paper ballot available to voters who, for whatever reason, aren't on the electorate roster at the polling precinct where they've arrived.
Along with discussing how to make Election Day more user-friendly, the task force also examined the larger voting process -- issues like the Electoral College, third-party ballot access and other items. The panelists unanimously panned a proposal to allow presidential electors -- the slate of electors chosen via the Electoral College -- to be apportioned according to the number of congressional districts that a candidate wins.
In last year's election, President Bush received more votes than challenger Sen. John F. Kerry in some congressional districts, but Kerry took all 21 Electoral College votes because Pennsylvania, like most states, delivers votes via the winner-take-all model of apportionment. In a congressional model, both Bush and Kerry would have won some Electoral College votes.
Panelists also considered a proposal to separate the presidential primary from the state and local primary. The idea is that the regular presidential primary is too late in the spring, and renders Pennsylvania impotent when it comes to selecting a presidential candidate. By splitting the primary, local candidates keep the schedule they're used to, but the presidential primary is moved up to give Pennsylvania more influence.
That idea was shot down.
"Bad enough that you move a primary up, and you require election boards to work over the holidays," Lamb said. "But then to go back to the regular primary date and make them do it again, that was torture."
The panel did endorse keeping the primaries together and holding them earlier, but lawmakers so far have been slow to endorse this recommendation.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.