HARRISBURG -- A guessing game is going on within Capitol corridors: Who will be Gov. Ed Rendell's Democratic running mate when he seeks re-election in 2006.

John Beale, Post-Gazette

Lt. Gov. Catherine Baker Knoll, second from right, poses for photos after her swearing in in January 2003. With her, from left, are Supreme Court Chief Justice Ralph Cappy Jr., who swore her in, Mina Baker Knoll, Catherine's daughter, and Albert Baker Knoll, Catherine's son, holding the Bible.

Click photo for larger image.

Advertise with us

This is strange, because Rendell already has a running mate, Lt. Gov. Catherine Baker Knoll, the pride of McKees Rocks, a former two-term state treasurer and a veteran of decades of political battles. She insists she likes being No. 2 and wants to keep the job for another four years.

"Yes, I'm going to run again in 2006," she said in a recent interview. "Gov. Rendell and I will run together, as far as I'm concerned."

Nonetheless, some well-known political names continue to be mentioned as possible challengers to Knoll in a May 2006 Democratic primary:

Former state Treasurer and Auditor General Barbara Hafer, whom Rendell recently talked out of running against Republican U.S. Sen. Rick Santorum next year.

Harrisburg lobbyist Mark S. Singel, who was lieutenant governor under former Gov. Robert P. Casey Sr.

Advertise with us

Auditor General (and former state senator) Jack Wagner, of Beechview, who lost to Knoll in the 2002 Democratic primary for for lieutenant governor.

Former state Sen. Allen Kukovich, of Westmoreland County, who also lost to Knoll in 2002 and who now runs Rendell's Western Pennsylvania office.

Allegheny County Chief Executive Dan Onorato.

House Democratic leader H. William DeWeese, of Waynesburg.

Hafer, who lives in Indiana County and just started a consulting firm, left the state treasurer's job in January. She said last week she wasn't interested in running against Knoll, but added, "I think somebody will challenge her. I know she's worried about that."

Advertise with us

Other potential challengers won't talk for the record about running or openly criticize Knoll, who, at 74, retains considerable political support around the state, especially among senior citizens and women.

But the speculation about competition next year irks Knoll. She calls it "political mischief," adding, "Maybe these pundits don't have anything else to write about, so they hit on me."

State Sen. Sean Logan, D-Monroeville, said, "It's the season for political speculation," with races for governor and U.S. senator already gearing up. "Some people like to read their names in the newspaper."

Little public criticism

Knoll is the first woman to serve as Pennsylvania lieutenant governor. She said some people of a conservative leaning might oppose her because she's a woman in what traditionally has been a man's job.

Advertise with us

She noted that she defeated eight challengers, all men younger than she, in the 2002 primary, a race where she won 54 of the state's 67 counties.

"I find the challenges of the job exhilarating," she said. "It's very serious business and I'm up to it. I maintain a very active daily schedule."

Rendell insists he has no problems with Knoll, and virtually no state officials are willing to publicly mention her weaknesses.

"It's tough to criticize your grandmother," said Hafer, who is 62.

But privately, critics point to factors such as:

Advertise with us

Her age.

Questions about whether she could carry out the lieutenant governor's most important job, running the state if Rendell weren't able to do it. They note that two lieutenant governors in the recent past had to step up: Singel in 1993, when Casey had surgery, and Mark S. Schweiker in October 2001, when Gov. Tom Ridge took a job in Washington.

In light of Rendell's voracious eating habits, one Harrisburg political gadfly, Gene Stilp, has quipped that Knoll may be "just a cheesesteak away" from the governor's office.

A rapid turnover in her seven-member Harrisburg office staff, with 12 employees leaving in just over two years in office. She's had special trouble keeping press secretaries.

"She's difficult to work for," Hafer said. It is a claim Knoll denied. One of her longtime aides, George Toma, said 11 of the 12 aides who have departed did so voluntarily, usually for other political jobs or to return to school, and one was fired for insubordination.

Advertise with us

A couple of instances when, according to some officials, she misspoke and referred to Rendell as "Edward G. Robinson," the tough-guy actor in old movies.

Her apparent confusion or befuddlement on parliamentary procedural moves during heated, late-night Senate debate, causing her to rely heavily on Senate parliamentarian Mark Corrigan for help. She insists she understands the procedure well.

An episode late one night in October when Knoll ruled in favor of Republicans who wanted to shut off debate. She failed to recognize Democratic senators who were trying to insert some amendments to change the state's new slot machine law.

Two newspapers, quoting unnamed senators, later reported that Senate Democratic leader Robert Mellow, of Scranton, got angry and called her "too old" for the job. In an interview, she strongly denied the report, saying, "It's absolutely false. There weren't even any reporters there. Bob Mellow is a good friend, and we're not going to lose a friendship, no matter what the newspapers write."

She said Mellow had merely walked over to the podium that night and said, "Catherine, did you forget you're a Democrat?"

Advertise with us

Mellow and Logan also denied that Mellow had made any comment about her age. Logan dismissed the confusion over the amendments as much ado about nothing.

"Husbands scream at wives, parents scream at children, but we're all one big family and you move on," Logan said. "It was late at night, and we'd spent a lot of time and energy preparing our gambling amendments. She should have called on Mellow [to offer the amendments], but she made a procedural mistake."

Logan said he hoped Knoll runs with Rendell next year.

"She's done a hell of a lot more good than screwing up a few amendments late at night," he said. "She's got more energy than many people much younger than she is. She's traveled around the state to every firehouse and senior citizen building, touting the governor's programs."

Sen. Jay Costa, D-Forest Hills, agrees. "The governor hasn't indicated he wishes to cut her loose," he said. "She can withstand [the criticism] that comes at her. She's a tireless worker."

Advertise with us

A proven vote-getter

Knoll lost her first two times running for state treasurer, in 1976 and 1984, and said she was ready to forget politics until an aunt who'd been a suffragette, working to get women the right to vote nearly 100 years ago, told her not to quit. So she ran and won in 1988 and served eight years as treasurer.

"She's been a prolific vote-getter and a very visible part of the Democratic Party for 30 years," said Philadelphia political consultant Larry Ceisler, who grew up in Washington County.

"She pays attention to people, and that's the mark of a politician with a long shelf life," added Tony May, a political consultant and former staff member for Casey.

No one doubts Knoll's stamina for political events. She's been to more than 1,000 in the first two years of her tenure. Knoll said senior citizens often come up to her at community events and say, "Be there for us."

Advertise with us

Knoll tries to encourage more women to get into politics.

"Women have a tough time running in Pennsylvania," she said. "I could be out playing golf or bridge, but I'm trying to make a difference for the young people who will follow me."

At a recent state Commission on Women rally at the Capitol, a 10-year-old girl read a paper she'd written about how Knoll is a role model for girls, especially those going into politics.

"I sat there dumbfounded," Knoll said, swearing she didn't put the girl up to the glowing tribute.

Because Knoll is a proven vote-getter in Western Pennsylvania, some observers think Rendell might favor Hafer as a replacement, because it would soften complaints that Rendell had dumped a woman from the west.

Advertise with us

But Hafer insists she just "wants to make some money" with her consulting firm and won't run next year.

Rendell has told Capitol reporters several times that he wouldn't try to replace Knoll. Some politicians, however, dismiss those comments as something Rendell is forced to say to avoid a civil war within the party, and his statements haven't stopped the speculation.

The lieutenant governor is chosen separately from the governor, so Rendell couldn't prevent Knoll or anyone else from running for the post in the May 2006 primary.

Almost everyone agrees that no challenger would have a chance against Knoll without strong public and financial support from Rendell, a prodigious fund-raiser who remains popular with voters, especially in southeastern Pennsylvania.

"For Knoll to be beaten in a Democratic primary, the governor would have to come out publicly and endorse her opponent," Ceisler said. "He'd have to expend a lot of political capital."

Advertise with us

Some people are also wondering if Rendell might be eyeing the 2008 Democratic presidential primary, a situation that could affect his choice of a running mate in 2006.

If he were elected president in 2008, a long shot, to be sure, it would mean the lieutenant governor would have to serve out the final two years of his second term as governor, 2009-10.

The fact that a top Rendell aide, Director of Communications Penny Lee, is moving to Washington, D.C., to take a job running the Democratic Governors Association has fed speculation about Rendell's interest in a 2008 national race.

Asked about Rendell's intentions, Lee said, somewhat cryptically, "Governor Rendell is focused on his re-election in 2006, and 2008 will have to wait for 2008."

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.