Voters next month will have the final say, but the Allegheny County Bar Association has begun separating the horde of candidates seeking to become Common Pleas Court judges.
The bar has issued its ratings for the 27 attorneys, including three who recently were appointed to fill vacancies in the court. They are campaigning for seven open seats on the county bench.
Two high-profile candidates, former U.S. Rep. Doug Walgren and City Controller Tom Flaherty, were "not recommended at this time" by the bar association.
Flaherty, who became a lawyer in 1998, said yesterday that he did not feel slighted by the rating. He said he will run on his record as a lawmaker and public servant.
Ten of the 27 candidates received the association's top ranking, "highly recommended." Two received the lowest of the four ratings: "unqualified."
"We do the evaluations based on their experience in the field of law. It's a pretty thorough process," said James Carroll, bar association president.
The association's judiciary committee, made up of 24 members elected to three-year terms, reviews writing samples of each of the judicial candidates. Then each candidate is interviewed before the full committee.
"We believe that, at the least, we know these candidates better than the average voter," Carroll said. "We can give insight into what these candidates might bring to the bench."
Most of the judicial hopefuls are registered as Democrats, though 18 of them cross-filed for the primary election as Republicans.
Three of the candidates are registered Republicans, according to Bob Hillen, chairman of the city GOP committee.
One of them, Patricia A. McCullough, was among three people appointed to the bench this year by Gov. Ed Rendell to fill unexpired terms. Former City Councilman Alan Hertzberg and former First Assistant District Attorney Edward Borkowski are the others.
McCullough is one of two Republicans among the county's 41 judges.
Ballot position could play a factor in determining who will win nominations in the May 17 primary.
When voters get to the polls, they will see two lines of judicial candidates on the ballots for both major parties. They will be allowed to vote for up to seven.
The bar association ratings:
Highly recommended
Kathryn M. Hens-Greco, 47, of Squirrel Hill; Jon Pushinsky, 50, of Highland Park; Jack McVay, 48, of the North Side; Dwayne Woodruff, 48, of McCandless; Edward Borkowski, 54, of Stanton Heights; Chuck Evans, 62, of Squirrel Hill; Anthony Mariani, 52, of Ross; Tony Basinski, 58, of Upper St. Clair; Beth Lazzara, 39, of the North Side; James Mahood, 57, of Richland; Roger Wise, 59, of McCandless.
Recommended
William T. Simmons, 55, of East Liberty; Jacqueline Morrow, 48, of Squirrel Hill; Michael E. McCarthy, 55, of Ross; David Joseph DeFazio, 50, of Shadyside; Frank Cecchetti, 56, of Mt. Lebanon; Patricia A. McCullough, 48, of Upper St. Clair; Dan Cusick, 56, of Mt. Lebanon; Alan Hertzberg, 48 of Crafton Heights; Wrenna Leigh Watson, 50, of the Hill District; Sumner L. Parker, 54, of Ross.
Not recommended at this time
Douglas Walgren, 64, of Mt. Lebanon; Kelly Eileen Bigley, 39, of Upper St. Clair; Tom Flaherty, 54, of Shadyside; Kathleen Miskovich, 48, of Richland.
Unqualified
Stephen Begler, 46, of Squirrel Hill; Robert Downey Jr., 51, of Penn Hills.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.