HARRISBURG -- Maybe it's because a lot of voters think Republicans are tougher on crime than Democrats are.

Or maybe it's because Democrats haven't nominated attorney general candidates who have statewide name recognition or political clout.

Whatever the reason, Democrats have not been able to capture the post of attorney general since it became an elected job in 1980.

But despite their six straight losses, Democratic officials are vowing that 2004 will be their year for a breakthrough to the state's top crime-fighting office.

Advertise with us

"The hopes of winning the attorney general post are as high as they've ever been in our party," said Mike Manzo, chief of staff for House Democratic leader H. William DeWeese, of Waynesburg. "We have three stellar candidates in the April 27 primary and a Democratic governor who's committed to helping the winner of the primary go on to win in November."

Baloney, replied Josh Wilson, political director for the state Republican Committee.

"We have every reason to believe we'll retain control of the office," he said. "Our party has a strong record of performance in fighting Internet predators and telemarketers who seek to scam the elderly and in gaining funds for the state from the tobacco settlement."

This year's primary contest for attorney general is especially interesting because both parties are slugging it out. The Democratic Party has three contestants vying to run in November, while the GOP has two.

In the Democratic column are:

Advertise with us

David Barasch, 55, of Harrisburg, who was the federal attorney for middle Pennsylvania from 1993 to 2001 and state consumer advocate in the late 1980s under former Gov. Robert P. Casey.

Jim Eisenhower, 48, of Philadelphia, a former federal prosecutor who is now a partner with a Philadelphia law firm, Ballard Spahr, and the former chairman of the state Commission on Crime and Delinquency. He was the Democratic candidate for attorney general in 2000, but lost to Republican incumbent Mike Fisher.

John Morganelli, 48, of Bethlehem, who has been district attorney for 12 years in Northampton County in Eastern Pennsylvania. He narrowly lost to Eisenhower in the Democratic primary in 2000 and did well in Western Pennsylvania that year.

A fourth Democratic hopeful, Lawrence County District Attorney Matt Mangino, of New Castle, dropped out of the race.

On the GOP side, the competitors are:

Advertise with us

Tom Corbett, 54, of Pittsburgh, who served as interim attorney general in 1995-96 and was once the U.S. attorney for Western Pennsylvania. He has been endorsed by the Republican State Committee and is viewed as having political strength in Western Pennsylvania.

Bruce Castor, 42, of Norristown, the current district attorney of Montgomery County, outside Philadelphia. Although he isn't the endorsed candidate, he has strong support from Montgomery County GOP Chairman Frank Bartle, which should help him get votes in the Republican-rich Philadelphia suburbs.

The winners of those two party nominations will face off in a race in November that will include a Green Party candidate, Marakay Rogers, 42, of York. Rogers is a lawyer with almost 20 years' experience but not a prosecutor or ex-prosecutor, like most of the major-party candidates. She specializes in family and juvenile law.

"There is a myth in many people's minds that the attorney general is just a prosecutor, but there is much more," she said. "The attorney general does environmental rights, civil rights and other cases."

"My major concern is that I am anti-death penalty and I favor abolishing mandatory sentencing. Mandatory sentencing is like 'one size fits all,' attempting to fit every case and, therefore not fitting most of them."

Advertise with us

Neither the Democrats nor Republicans have a primary race for the other two state row offices -- auditor general and state treasurer.

State Sen. Jack Wagner, D-Beechview, is the Democratic candidate for auditor general after spending 10 years in the Senate and 10 years on Pittsburgh City Council before that.

Wagner will be opposed in November by Republican candidate Joseph Peters, a lawyer from Scranton who initially was running for attorney general but changed his mind in light of party leaders' support of Corbett.

Democrat Robert P. Casey Jr., who is finishing his second term as auditor general, is running now for state treasurer. Casey, who has wide name recognition at least in part because of his father, is considered a strong favorite over the relatively unknown Republican candidate, Jean Craige Pepper, of Erie.

The attorney general candidates are vying to succeed Fisher, a Republican from Upper St. Clair who spent two terms as attorney general before leaving the office in January to become a federal judge. He turned the job over to his deputy, Gerald Pappert, who has agreed to serve until the end of Fisher's term in early January.

Advertise with us

The attorney general oversees a wide range of litigation and investigations, including civil suits, complaints about fraud against consumers, protection of the environment and public health, and defends the state in federal court cases. The office has a $100 million annual budget and more than 800 employees.

Unlike the Republicans, the state Democratic Committee didn't endorse a favorite in January.

Eisenhower is, however, generally considered to be a political ally of Gov. Ed Rendell, who also worked at the Ballard Spahr law firm between the end of his term as Philadelphia mayor in 2000 and the start of his term as governor in January 2003. Rendell also named Nora Dowd Eisenhower, Jim Eisenhower's wife, as the state secretary on aging.

Officially, however, Rendell, who is still popular in the Democratic Party and is a prodigious fund-raiser, has remained neutral in the race.

Morganelli just barely lost in the 2000 primary, getting more than 49 percent of the vote and doing well in Western Pennsylvania. He's also strong in the Lehigh Valley, with larger towns such as Bethlehem, Allentown and Easton.

Advertise with us

The base of Eisenhower's strength, not surprisingly, is in the populous Philadelphia area.

Morganelli thinks one reason Democrats haven't won the attorney general's office is that they've never nominated a sitting district attorney, as he has been for the past 12 years in the Lehigh Valley.

Tom Flaherty, Pittsburgh city controller and Allegheny County Democratic chairman, said he and other Allegheny County officials were backing Barasch because they think he'd make the strongest candidate.

None of the three Democrats got the party committee's backing because the committee, at the urging of Rendell, changed the standard for endorsement from 51 percent to 67 percent of the committee members. But most of the 53 members from Allegheny County supported Barasch, Flaherty said.

Barasch also has considerable support elsewhere in southwestern Pennsylvania, Flaherty said. He added that if Barasch were the Democratic nominee and Corbett the GOP nominee, he expected a campaign issue to be Barasch's prosecution of Waste Management Inc. for environmental and health violations in the 1990s. At the time, Corbett was counsel to the firm and Barasch was the U.S. attorney for middle Pennsylvania. Corbett defended Waste Management, which operates a number of landfills in Pennsylvania.

Advertise with us

Barasch also is talking about other high-profile cases he handled as a federal attorney, including the prosecution of former state attorney general Ernie Preate in 1994 for trying to conceal illegal contributions from video poker operators and financial misdeeds for former Rite Aid Corp. officials.

Castor, the Republican challenger, has criticized Corbett about his work as Waste Management's attorney. The attacks are part of Castor's vigorous challenge to Corbett, who's generally seen as the GOP front-runner.

Castor said last week that Corbett, as assistant general counsel for government affairs for Waste Management, "frequently and vigorously defended the company as it received hundreds of environmental and safety violations from state police and the Department of Environmental Protection."

Some Republicans think Castor could be hurt by an ongoing political feud with Robert Asher, a Republican from suburban Philadelphia who is GOP national committeeman and who is supporting Corbett.

Wilson, of the state GOP committee, touted Corbett as "the only one [of the five candidates] who has served in the attorney general's post before. He has a track record. He fought organized crime and illegal drugs."

Advertise with us

After Preate went to prison, then-Gov. Tom Ridge picked Corbett to serve out the term in 1995-96. "Tom restored the public's trust in that office," Wilson said.

Corbett "created the insurance fraud section and reformed the statewide drug task force to more efficiently prosecute drug crimes," said another supporter, David Patti, of a pro-business group called Pennsylvanians for Effective Government.

"Unlike all of the other candidates, Tom Corbett has already served as Pennsylvania attorney general," Patti said. "He's proven himself in the job."