HARRISBURG -- The certification of Allegheny County vote totals yesterday prompted Republican Party officials to claim victory in a hotly contested election for Superior Court nearly two months ago, while the Democratic candidate vowed to challenge the count in federal court.
Both sides agreed that Republican Susan P. Gantman, a family law specialist in Montgomery County, was ahead by about 30 votes. Gantman's supporters said the counting was over.
"Recounts have happened, votes have been tallied left and right. It is over. January first is upon us," said Dan Hayward, political director of the Republican State Committee.
But Gantman's Democratic opponent, Westmoreland County Common Pleas Judge John J. Driscoll, said he filed a lawsuit in U.S. District Court in Philadelphia seeking to force elections officials to count absentee ballots from disabled and elderly voters that were disqualified for being submitted too late.
"If we prevail in federal court, [her announcement] is premature. If we do not prevail in federal court, they will be correct" in declaring victory, Driscoll said.
The actual winner will be determined by the Pennsylvania Department of State, which certifies the winner in statewide contests based on county-by-county results. Allegheny was the last county to certify its results.
"Everything is on hold until the litigation has been heard. All we can do right now is sit and wait, basically," said Abe Amoros, spokesman for Gov. Ed Rendell.
Hayward said Gantman was unavailable for interviews. She did not return phone messages seeking comment yesterday.
With only a razor-thin margin separating Gantman and Driscoll out of more than 2.2 million ballots cast, campaign officials from both camps have been scouring the state in recent weeks, searching for votes.
Driscoll said the federal suit, filed by him and several disabled individuals, addresses whether or not elections officials improperly disenfranchised voters whose absentee ballots arrived at elections offices after the normal absentee ballot deadline of the Friday before the election.
He said such ballots, if identified as coming from a disabled or elderly voter, must be accepted until polls close on Election Day -- not left uncounted alongside other late-arriving absentee ballots.
"It's essentially a class action filed on behalf of disabled voters," he said. The suit names as defendants state elections officials as well as the boards of elections in Philadelphia, Allegheny, Carbon and Westmoreland counties.
"There's over 300 [such ballots] in Philadelphia alone. They'll clearly make the difference in this election," said Don Morabito, executive director of the state Democratic Party.
Swearing-in for the other two Superior Court judges elected this year, Northampton County Judge Jack A. Panella and Philadelphia Municipal Judge Seamus P. McCaffery, both Democrats, is scheduled for Jan. 5.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.