Pennsylvania Republicans seem poised to steal a page from their opponents' fractious play book.
For much of the last decade, debilitating, divisive primary fights have been a staple among Democrats running statewide. Republicans have exhibited a more disciplined approach to candidate selection. Since former Gov. Tom Ridge took office in 1995, GOP leaders have, with rare exceptions, managed to broker consensus on statewide candidates, avoiding messy primaries and saving their resources for November.
That's about to change.
The first promise of GOP fratricide came this year with U.S. Rep. Pat Toomey's decision to challenge Sen. Arlen Specter for renomination to the Senate. Defying party leaders from the White House on down, Toomey is intent on exploiting conservative unrest over the centrist voting record of the Senate veteran.
Last week, it became clear that their race would not be the only catalyst for Republican acrimony.
After a group of county chairmen from the southeastern corner of the state endorsed Allegheny County's Tom Corbett for attorney general, a rival, Montgomery County District Attorney Bruce Castor, responded with a scathing statement claiming the endorsement had been bought with campaign contributions from a key Corbett ally, Robert Asher, Pennsylvania's national Republican committeeman.
Corbett is a former U.S. attorney for the Western District of Pennsylvania. Ridge, many of whose political associates back Corbett now, appointed him state attorney general after former Attorney General Ernie Preate was convicted of accepting and concealing illegal campaign contributions.
Castor buttressed his attack by pointing to Asher's 1986 federal conviction in an influence-peddling case involving the award of a state computer contract. Former state Treasurer Budd Dwyer committed suicide after being found guilty of related charges in the case. In his news release, Castor insisted that Corbett's candidacy would be clouded by the support of "a convicted felon."
Castor's statements brought a storm of criticism from GOP leaders including Sens. Specter and Rick Santorum, and state Republican Chairman Alan Novak.
Undeterred, Castor wrote Santorum promising to provide a report on yet unspecified machinations on Corbett's behalf next week.
"I am confident your opinion will change after you have had the opportunity to review the evidence," Castor wrote in a Dec. 19 letter to Santorum.
In an interview last week, Castor said his candidacy would go forward despite the opposition of the GOP hierarchy.
"I've been elected in the largest GOP region in the state," he said, referring to his re-election last month. "I have my own fund-raising base; I have my own voter base. ... Tom Corbett is unelectable."
Castor said he would have considered deferring to the wishes of the Republican state committee, which will endorse a candidate in the race next month, if he had been confident that the voting process was fair.
"Based on what I've seen so far, I don't see how Chairman Novak could get this back on an even playing field," Castor said. "I don't see how they could get this on an even footing."
Castor's determination to press on with his campaign, coupled with the Senate nomination battle, creates the prospect of increased party infighting in an election year in which the White House would prefer to see a united front in a state that eluded President Bush in the 2000 general election.
In the hope of reversing that result, Bush has visited Pennsylvania more often than any battleground state since then.
If either Toomey or Castor were to run against the endorsement and win the nomination, it would be a startling reversal of a pattern than goes back nearly a decade. With the GOP endorsement, Ridge won the nomination for governor after a tough primary fight in 1994. Since then, the GOP's endorsed candidates have gone on to win the party nomination in every statewide contest with the exception of one appellate court race.
The Democrats also have the potential for a hard-fought internal battle over state attorney general, but that is nothing unusual for their party.
Lawrence County District Attorney Matthew Mangino has already announced his candidacy. Northhampton County District Attorney John Morganelli has also indicated his interest in the race as has David Barasch, a former U.S. attorney for the Middle District of the state, and James Eisenhower, the party's unsuccessful nominee four years ago.
The big question hanging over the Democratic race involves Allegheny County District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr.
Zappala, re-elected without opposition last month, has been courted for the race by a variety of party leaders including Gov. Ed Rendell. A spokesman said last week that he had yet to make up his mind. Zappala would be considered a strong candidate and his entry into the race could dissuade some of the other Democrats from going forward.
The maneuvering in the GOP prosecutor's race has had a ripple effect in one of the other statewide contests that will be in the ballot. Joe Peters, a former federal prosecutor from Lackawanna County, had been in the hunt for the attorney general's nomination. Late this month, however, Peters, with the encouragement of some of the same figures who are backing Corbett, switched his sights to the race for auditor general. His rivals for the nomination are state Rep. John Maher, R-Upper St. Clair, and Chet Beiler, the former Republican chairman of Lancaster County.
On the Democratic side, state Sen. Jack Wagner of Beechview, and state Rep. Jennifer Mann, of Allentown, are pursuing the nomination for auditor general.
At this point, there are no battles in sight on either side for the nominations for treasurer, the remaining state row office on the ballot next year. Auditor General Bob Casey Jr., barred from seeking a third term in his current post, is unopposed on the Democratic side. Craige Pepper, a financial executive from Erie, is running for the GOP spot opposite him in the fall.
James O'Toole can be reached at jotoole@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1562.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.