Against her wishes, Lisa Barr watched her three sons go off to join the Marine Corps. Her youngest, Lance Cpl. Aric Barr, was 22 when he died in combat in Iraq.
Mrs. Barr and her husband, Anthony, marked the fourth anniversary of his death last week. As they grieved in Hazelwood, the two Democrats competing for their party's presidential nomination crisscrossed Pennsylvania, campaigning for votes in the April 22 primary election.
Ending the war in Iraq is an important part of the platforms of Sens. Barack Obama and Hillary Rodham Clinton. But the Barrs say neither candidate appeals to them.
They prefer the likely Republican nominee, Sen. John McCain, who wants to keep U.S. military forces in Iraq until he sees victory.
"I hate to see my son get killed and then we jump out of there," Anthony Barr said.
Lisa Barr said she does not believe either Democrat is experienced enough to lead the country in wartime. "Obama, I wouldn't even consider him. If it was [retired Gen.] Colin Powell, that would be different," she said.
Some 4,500 U.S. soldiers, at least 180 of them from Pennsylvania, have died in Iraq and Afghanistan since the war began more than five years ago. If America is divided over the worthiness of the cause, so are parents of soldiers who were killed by bullets and roadside bombs.
Freddie Jackson lost her only son in Iraq five years ago. She says she remains heartsick and feels betrayed.
Ms. Jackson, of Apollo, says she is undecided about which candidate she will support, but is positive it will not be Mr. McCain.
"Never," she said.
Ms. Jackson said the war was supposed to be about disarming Iraq of high-powered weapons. But now, she says, she is convinced that Iraq's military strength was overstated by the Bush administration.
She questions why her son, Army Sgt. Stevon Booker, was sent to war. A career soldier who was 34 years old, he died from enemy fire during a raid in Baghdad in April 2003.
"I don't understand why we're still over there," Ms. Jackson said. "I hear people saying it's about oil and that hurts. Every day our young men are dying. Many of them are so young they never really had the chance to live."
She says Mr. McCain would continue a failed policy in Iraq, so she cannot vote for him.
Ms. Jackson said she was still evaluating Mr. Obama and Mrs. Clinton, carrying on an internal debate about who would be a better president. One of them, she said, will get her vote.
Not another soldier
Even among Republicans who lost a child in the war, Mr. McCain is not necessarily seen as the right choice for president.
Tim R. Brown Sr., whose 21-year-old son died in a roadside bombing in Iraq in August 2003, says he is disgusted with every presidential candidate except one who has no chance to win.
He calls Republican Rep. Ron Paul, of Texas, "the only candidate I would vote for. I wouldn't give you two cents for the rest of them."
Mr. Paul, like the two Democratic contenders, is a critic of the war. He says it was "sold" to the American public with false information.
But that stance is not why Mr. Brown, of Beaver Falls, supports him.
"I like his integrity, his morals," Mr. Brown said.
Missing from Mr. Paul's long-shot campaign was any trace of sarcasm or meanness, a style that the contending candidates should emulate, he said.
Mr. Brown proudly voted for President Bush four years ago and says he still supports him. But the war in Iraq weighs heavily on his mind, pulling him one way and then another. His only son, Army Pfc. Tim R. Brown Jr., is always on his mind.
"I don't want to see another soldier die," he said. "I don't want any parent to go through that."
Then Mr. Brown says he remembers how Tim Jr. told him the war was worthwhile, that Iraqi children with nothing wanted the U.S. military in their country.
"My son had never seen such poverty. The children touched him and motivated him," Mr. Brown said.
In Confluence, Somerset County, Frances and Nils Thompson are Republicans with differing views on the presidential candidates.
Their son, also named Nils, died a day after his 19th birthday in 2005, shot by a sniper in Mosul, Iraq.
Mr. Thompson said his son, a private first class, fulfilled a dream by serving in the Army.
"He got interested in the service when he was 5 years old. It was like a calling from God."
Given his son's dedication and his own belief that the U.S. military is serving an important purpose in Iraq, Mr. Thompson is supporting Mr. McCain.
"One thing he said sparked my interest," Mr. Thompson said. "He talked about staying in Iraq for a hundred years. A lot of people attacked him for it. Not me. It showed he has some commitment. He has some character. There's none of this wussy stuff like with Obama and Clinton."
Mrs. Thompson has a different position, one that she said her husband is sure to disagree with.
"I'm going to vote for Ron Paul," she said.
But her support of the anti-war congressman has little to do with his stand regarding Iraq. She said she could not vote for a Democrat, given her opposition to abortion and gay-rights causes. She favors Mr. Paul over pro-war Republicans, but says her position is not a slap at Mr. Bush.
"I'm not bitter at anybody. I'm not bitter at Bush," she said. "I'm sure these boys have done a lot of good over there. I love our military."
A son who believed
Carol Polley, whose son, Army Staff Sgt. David Veverka, died in the war in May 2006, is not one to criticize military efforts in Iraq. But, she says, she is leaning toward Mrs. Clinton, who supported the invasion of Iraq, then turned against the war after saying she had been misled by the Bush administration.
"I am kind of impressed with her. I think I'm going with Hillary," said Mrs. Polley, a Democrat.
She wants to see the war end, but at the same time she does not want to think of it as futile. She said her son, who grew up in Jamestown, Mercer County, believed in the cause and wanted to serve in Iraq. He said it was his calling.
Sgt. Veverka, who died at 25, served in the Army for three years. After his discharge, he joined the Army National Guard. The extra money helped him pay his tuition and bills while he attended the University of Maine at Bangor.
He was just eight credits shy of receiving his degree in wildlife ecology when the Army called him to active duty.
After his death in a roadside bombing in Iraq, the university awarded him his degree. Mrs. Polley received his diploma. Maine designated him magna cum laude -- an honors graduate.
His mother said she is as proud of his military service as she is of his academic record.
For Denise Culbertson, whose son died in Iraq when he was 22, picking a candidate was easy.
A Republican, she said she is supporting Mr. McCain, whose position on the war is similar to her own.
"To me, it makes more sense to stay there and complete the job. If they pull out now, it's just going to be chaos," she said.
Her son, Army Cpl. Russell Culbertson III, died in October 2006 after a bomb exploded near the Humvee he was riding in.
While grieving, she has continued to pay careful attention to the war and the soldiers serving in it. Mrs. Culbertson has helped set up an "adoption" program, through which people in the United States send letters and care packages to soldiers.
She has remained friends with a number of the soldiers in her son's unit. Mrs. Culbertson said some are on their third tour in Iraq, evidence that the war is being fought by a small percentage of the population.
In Hazelwood, Lisa Barr felt uneasy when her sons decided to enlist in the Marines.
"I tried to talk all three out of it," she said.
But they were determined to serve, so she had to let them make their own decisions.
Her middle boy, Aaron, joined first. He has been in the Marines for 11 years. Anthony, her oldest, and Aric, went off to boot camp together about seven years ago.
Even before his sons volunteered, Anthony Barr's family had a history with the Marine Corps.
His older brother, Lance Cpl. Robert C. Barr, died in combat in Vietnam on Veterans Day 1969.
Aric's death in 2004 remains a source of pain, but he gave his life for the cause of freedom, his mother said.
"The question is, do you want to fight this war on your soil, or on someone else's?" she said.
Ms. Jackson, another mother in pain, does not see it that way. Her vote this election year will go to a Democrat, she said, because the war must end.
"One of my major issues is to bring the troops home," she said.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.