In the aftermath of Sen. Barack Obama's strongly praised speech on race in America and his relationship with controversial pastor Jeremiah Wright, several Pennsylvania political experts warned yesterday the issue may not go away any time soon.
In a state chock-full of "Reagan Democrats" -- white, socially conservative and working-class -- Mr. Obama's Philadelphia speech may have done little to sway them, said Terry Madonna director of the Center for Politics and Public Affairs at Franklin & Marshall College.
"The speech may have stopped the hemorrhaging of undecided voters who liked Obama but had questions about his link to Pastor Wright, but does it get him new support from the blue-collar worker in Beaver Falls or Monessen who's worried about his job? I'm highly dubious."
Sign up to be a citizen contributor covering events and sharing your thoughts on the Pennsylvania primary campaign using your mobile phone.
Visit our VoxPop section to learn more and join up today!
Others, however, thought the speech was both a rhetorical and political success.
"Don't sell the people of Pennsylvania short. That speech was addressed to all Americans," said former Pennsylvania Sen. Harris Wofford, who introduced Mr. Obama before his speech at the National Constitution Center. "Any one voter, old or young, blue-collar or white-collar is a voter that counts and for people to think it was addressed to any one group is just an example of the old politics as usual that Barack is trying to replace."
Mr. Obama's description of himself as a "post-racial" candidate whose white mother and black father gave him unique insights into the country's racial divisions was compelling but incomplete, said Kareem Crayton, professor of law and political science at the University of Southern California.
"I don't think the speech resolved all of his political problems," he added.
And therein lies the conundrum facing Mr. Obama. While it would have been fatal politically to totally reject the Rev. Wright, refusing to do so -- "I can no more disown [Rev. Wright] than I can my white grandmother" who viewed black men on the street with suspicion -- Mr. Obama was not able put the issue behind him.
"Unfortunately it does not settle the Wright issue and gives ample ammunition to people in the Republican party," said Dr. Crayton.
Still, he called the speech -- which the Illinois senator dubbed "A More Perfect Union" -- "an important marker of where we are right now, coming in the midst of a presidential campaign when new questions are not just raised about Rev. Wright but what Sen. Obama's thinking is about race and its role in the political system, which he hasn't really talked at length. ... Those things are now open to discussion."
Throughout his campaign, Mr. Obama has tried to position himself as one whose candidacy is not just about race, but about transcending it. Now that it's landed in the forefront of his campaign, it's not going to go away, said Mr. Madonna.
"The speech stopped the bleeding," said Marcel Groen, a Clinton supporter and convention superdelegate who chairs the Montgomery County Democratic Party. "Whether or not it goes far enough to bring Sen. Obama back to where he was before is unclear. Once having started that discussion of race, we have to continue it, as much as we hate to."
Still, do voters in Pennsylvania really want to talk about race -- or would they rather focus on their economic futures?
A recent survey of 700 Pennsylvania voters by the Susquehanna Polling/Triad Strategies found that large numbers of working class voters -- those without college degrees making less than $50,000 a year -- "are angry at candidates who make undefined promises," said Tony May, senior vice president of communications for Triad.
"These people feel victimized and they tend to think they'll get a better deal from someone perceived as hard-nosed and tough-talking rather than someone who comes off as warm and sensitive. And I don't think yesterday's speech by Sen. Obama has changed those attitudes."
The video clips of Rev. Wright damning America for its treatment of blacks and claiming the U.S. had provoked the Sept. 11, 2001 terrorist attacks, are circulating widely on the Internet and won't go away, either.
"The language and its presentation on video is so jarring," Dr. Crayton said. "It's not something someone can easily forget."
Indeed, even U.S. Rep. Joe Sestak, D-Delaware -- one of Mrs. Clinton's strongest supporters -- said he thought Democratic voters "and Independents and thoughtful Republicans" will soon forget about the controversy.
"I think Sen. Obama was able to transcend the issue of race by holding up a mirror so people could say we are better than that," he said. "It will not be an issue in November. It cannot and I will fight every day to ensure that it won't. We must make it go away. I'm not trying to say I don't accept cold facts of reality, but I absolutely refuse at such a critical time in our history to believe that this could come back to haunt the senator. "
"Of course," Mr. Sestak added, "That takes nothing away from why I'm for Sen. Clinton."
Former Pittsburgh Mayor Sophie Masloff agreed.
"Peoples' memories are short. By the time November comes around, I don't know that it will make much difference, given people's nature. Believe me there will be a bunch of other issues and they'll all forget this one."
Mrs. Masloff, a superdelegate, is still refusing to commit to either candidate, but thought the speech was "super."
"I listened to every word. He wasn't on the defensive but went on the offensive. And I'm not saying this because I'm supporting him, because you know I'm uncommitted. I just thought the speech was wonderful."
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.