It was not long after Charlie Kirk was fatally shot on Sept. 10 that pitches for monuments to the 31-year-old conservative activist began to surface.

A day after his death, more than a dozen House Republicans circulated a letter calling for a statue of the influencer and organizer at the U.S. Capitol. Within a week, Oklahoma lawmakers introduced legislation requiring every state university campus to put up a Kirk statue in a dedicated square or plaza, and Texas state Republican Rep. Nate Schatzline called for similar legislation for all public campuses in his state.

New College of Florida, a public liberal arts institution that has recently undergone a conservative overhaul, went a step further, announcing it was commissioning a Kirk statue and sharing an AI rendering of how it might look. The school told The Washington Post it has had an “outpouring of artists who are willing to work with us about the monument” but did not provide names.

The push for such monuments, particularly at college campuses, is unusual, experts say. Many figures given statues in the U.S. have been deceased for decades, and some experts and former students were skeptical that these statues, which can take years to make and cost tens to hundreds of thousands of dollars, will actually come to be.

Advertise with us

The effort, however, reflects how Kirk — a star among young conservatives but also divisive for his controversial rhetoric on race, sexuality and other issues — has been hailed by the right as a kind of martyr. With many political leaders at his memorial service invoking the language of religious and political warfare, his death has become a rallying cry for a movement set on portraying itself as defenders of Western, Christian values that they say are under attack. In this polarized political environment, the statue proposals have revived a contemporary debate on who is commemorated.

Resistance to monuments

In recent years, there has been dramatic pushback over some public monuments, with statues of colonizers, Confederates and other controversial figures coming down during the racial justice protests of 2020 amid pressure from activists who said they were racist.

To Erika Doss, an art historian at the University of Texas at Dallas and author of “Memorial Mania: Public Feeling in America,” the call for Kirk statues reflects “an obvious backlash to what [conservatives] perceive as the taking down of great monuments,” such as those of Christopher Columbus and Robert E. Lee. (In August, the National Park Service said it would repair and reinstall a statue of Albert Pike, a Confederate Army brigadier general, in Washington, D.C., that protesters toppled and set alight in 2020.)

This urgency to memorialize Kirk, Ms. Doss says, diverges from traditional approaches to public grief. Before permanent monuments tends to come “the immediate emotional response from the public, which comes out in the form of the temporary memorial,” a fixture of major tragedies such as Columbine or 9/11 as well as “roadside memorials that we see every day,” she said. To Doss, this “jump” to permanence instead goes “straight to ideology.”

Advertise with us

“That’s a mistake,” Ms. Doss said, adding that “public art is about place making and community gathering and history telling.”

Brian Cody, a New College of Florida graduate and a board member of the Novo Collegian Alliance, a group opposing the school’s conservative turn, was alarmed by an email he received in which the school appears to celebrate the attention the statue announcement generated, citing the number of times the college was mentioned in media.

“Any time someone is murdered, there is respect and a moment of reflection, but maybe even more importantly, it’s an opportunity to have serious discussions,” Mr. Cody said, calling the announcement “inappropriate for an institution, and just really distasteful.” (The school did not directly respond to a request for comment on that portion of the email.)

Jackson Dawson, president of the New College chapter of Kirk’s organization Turning Point USA, told The Post in an email that “everyone in our chapter is fully supportive” of the effort and that the fast response “speaks to how deeply Charlie’s message resonated.”

Reflecting on the speed of such proposals, Kirk Savage, an art historian at the University of Pittsburgh who has written on public monuments, said “the only real precedent I can think of is Abraham Lincoln,” whose assassination was followed by swift calls for statues. The morning after, Charlotte Scott, a formerly enslaved woman, is said to have donated $5 to a monument to the president, eventually resulting in the controversial Freedman’s Memorial in D.C., which depicts a Black man kneeling next to Lincoln.

Advertise with us

Other public monuments, such as many to the Rev. Martin Luther King Jr., often appear several years to decades after death. The bulk of the contested Confederate monuments around the country were built in the late 1890s and early 1900s, during the Jim Crow era.

Mr. Savage noted that the Commemorative Works Act requires that most works memorializing an individual on federal land in D.C. and the area around it not be authorized until 25 years after that person’s death, to ensure historical significance over generations. While the act only applies to certain places, “Informally, a lag time has been observed over the course of our history” and beyond the capital region, he said.

Time can put things into perspective

That time allows for the public to arrive at a consensus or better understand a figure. But the monuments that result are not really about precise storytelling, said Gabriel Reich, a professor who studies historical consciousness at Virginia Commonwealth University, calling them “a technology for representing or projecting a collective memory to the public.”

Collective memory “simplifies history down into more simplistic morality plays,” he said.

Advertise with us

Such stories can fall flat if a figure sparks discontent. “If the monument is to a figure that people don’t agree upon, it can become a site for people with different identities to congregate but for very different reasons,” he said, pointing to monuments of Confederates and Soviet soldiers in Eastern Europe. “It can become a site of real contention later on.”

Public monuments, especially on school campuses, are usually determined by the school’s community, not legislation, experts said. Several statues at the University of Oklahoma — including the well-known Seed Sower, for instance — were built by the artist in residence there, Paul Moore, supported by alumni and depict figures with ties to the school.

For some college students, the proposed statues of Kirk — a figure known for his combative debate style, who was associated with a very conservative sect of right-wing politics — are already sites of contention.

A point of discussion on campuses

Speaking to The Post on the University of Oklahoma campus, Chloe Frazier, 20, said she has felt uncomfortable with the language around martyrdom used by some to describe Kirk, including by fellow students who have changed their social media profile pictures to Kirk and compared him to Jesus.

Advertise with us

“I don’t think he should be having a statue here,” said Ms. Frazier, who described herself as a moderate and said she disagreed with some of Kirk’s views, such as his critique of the civil rights movement and his strong opposition to abortion. “I think if colleges want to put up a statue and someone has the money to fund it, they can absolutely do that. I just don’t think a senator should make it law,” Frazier said.

The University of Oklahoma said in a statement that it is “deeply saddened by the tragic and senseless violence that took Charlie Kirk’s life” and that “should any legislation be enacted, OU will, as always, follow all applicable state and federal laws.”

April Ancinec, a 19-year-old New College student who described herself as an avid watcher of Kirk’s videos, was dismayed to hear classmates talk about defacing the planned statue at her school. “It makes me feel like it’s needed even more,” she said, calling it “a physical representation that other opinions and ideas are welcome on campus.”

For another 20-year-oldstudent at New College — who spoke on the condition of anonymity for fear of retribution, citing the school’s threat to withhold diplomas from student protesters — the statue proposal does the opposite.

The administration, which has framed campus culture as too progressive, says it wants diverse perspectives, the student noted.

“Elevating and memorializing a specific partisan opinion shows that their goal is not to break up this hegemony,” the student said, “but to replace it with a different hegemony.”