Police in Butler County went into the days leading up to Donald Trump’s July 13 rally feeling “like there was no plan,” according to a report released Wednesday, noting that even two days before the campaign stop, U.S. Secret Service agents still could not answer basic questions such as where the stage would be placed at the Butler Farm Show grounds.

Butler County authorities left “disorganized” meetings with Secret Service agents feeling like they “lacked direction,” with one officer telling a Senate committee that a site walk-through two days before the rally was really more like “just people milling about.”

The revelations came the same day that Trump’s campaign announced plans for the Republican presidential nominee to not just return to Butler County, but to speak again at the venue where a would-be assassin killed spectator Corey Comperatore and wounded Trump and two others.

Trump’s Oct. 5 visit will be in part to honor Comperatore, “who heroically sacrificed his life to shield his wife and daughters from the bullets on that terrible day,” a campaign spokesperson said in a statement.

Advertise with us

Wednesday’s report, released by the bipartisan Senate panel investigating the attempted assassination of the former president, is not a final analysis of the panel’s findings; rather, it is a stopgap to release the information gleaned so far while interviews and investigations continue.

“What happened on July 13 was an accumulation of errors that produced a perfect storm of stunning failure,” said Sen. Richard Blumenthal, D-Conn., a member of the Senate investigative panel. “It was a tragedy and completely preventable from the outset.”

Many of the details surrounding the security breakdowns of July 13 have come out in bits and pieces in the 2½ months since 20-year-old Thomas Crooks tried to kill the former president, but the interim report does shed more light on just how seemingly fraught the security efforts were.

Michigan Sen. Gary Peters, the Democratic chairman of the panel, called the security breakdowns “shocking, unacceptable, and preventable.”

Investigators found that there was no clear chain of command between the Secret Service and other security agencies and no plan for coverage of the building where the shooter climbed up to fire the shots. Officials were operating on multiple, separate radio channels, leading to missed communications, and an inexperienced drone operator was stuck on a help line after his equipment wasn’t working correctly.

Advertise with us

Central to the dissection of how Crooks was able to fire off eight shots from the roof of the AGR International building just 150 yards from the former president is that roof itself.

In the weeks after the shooting, Secret Service agents in charge of the Butler planning still “could not say with any specificity how the AGR building would be covered and who was ultimately responsible for ensuring the AGR building was sufficiently covered,” the Senate committee wrote.

A Secret Service agent from Trump’s security detail who was part of the planning for the rally told the Senate committee she didn’t know how, exactly, authorities would have eyes on the AGR building but she knew Butler authorities would have it covered.

Butler authorities, however, told the committee they’d told the Secret Service they didn’t have the manpower to cover that building. One Butler officer said agents in charge of the site said “they would take care of it.”

Communications breakdowns seem to have run rampant July 13 and the days prior.

Advertise with us

Local officers first spotted Crooks using a rangefinder about 5:30 p.m. Even though some Secret Service agents were helping to actively search for Crooks, others — including the agents in charge of the planning at the site — were unaware a search was underway.

Then about 22 seconds before Crooks fired, the report found, a local officer sent a radio alert that there was an armed individual on the building. But that information was not relayed to key Secret Service personnel who were interviewed by Senate investigators.

The panel also interviewed a Secret Service counter-sniper who reported seeing officers with their guns drawn running toward the building where the shooter was perched, but the person did not think to notify anyone to get Trump off the stage.

Breakdown in communications

The communications breakdowns went beyond what one committee member called a “multistep game of telephone” and a series of intelligence-sharing failures.

Lawmakers noted that only two agents interviewed were ever made aware of “credible intelligence” of a threat against Trump prior to July 13, and only one “was made aware of the classified information underlying the threat.”

Advertise with us

While the committee did not specifically detail the threat, it often highlighted the foiled Iranian-backed alleged assassination plot that led to the arrest of Pakistani national Asif Merchant just a day before the Butler shooting.

The FBI told the committee that it had no advance knowledge of Crooks, and that there was no evidence of ties between Crooks and any Iranian-sponsored plot to assassinate U.S. officials.

The committee continues to seek information from federal agencies on “a series of enumerated threats known or being investigated in advance” of the Butler rally.

The Secret Service’s lead advance agent told the committee that four days before the rally, she received a call “from a supervisor in the Trump detail” who indicated there was “credible intelligence that he could not speak about, and that we were going to get Secret Service counter-sniper advance” for the rally. That advance agent told the Trump detail member to call her supervisor, she told the committee.

But her supervisor, the special agent in charge of the Pittsburgh Field Office, told the committee he was never informed of any credible intelligence of a threat — either from the Trump detail member or the lead advance agent. He told lawmakers he became aware that Secret Service counter-snipers were coming to the rally “through an email requesting housing for them.”

Advertise with us

The lead advance agent wrote in the “intelligence” section of her preliminary survey report that “no adverse intelligence has been developed concerning this visit” — despite what she said she’d heard from the Trump detail member.

“At the time I filled out this document my understanding was that there was no adverse intelligence to pass on to the group as a whole,” she told the committee.

The special agent in charge said if he’d been made aware of any intelligence regarding a potential threat, he would have requested more details and assets, “and might have pushed for the event to be moved indoors if it was deemed too risky.”

The committee said the decision to send counter-snipers to the rally — which marked the first time they were sent to protect someone other than a president, vice president or a candidate already formally nominated — “potentially saved lives.”

The committee also noted that the FBI did not alert a Secret Service intelligence advance agent of any threats against Trump, even though it was actively investigating Asif Merchant and even after the agent wrote to the FBI on July 10 “requesting any intelligence” regarding threats or the rally. That intelligence advance agent told the committee he received no information on threats, Mr. Merchant or why counter-snipers were being sent to the rally.

Advertise with us

The Senate report comes just days after the Secret Service released a five-page document summarizing the key conclusions of a yet-to-be finalized Secret Service report on what went wrong, and ahead of a Thursday hearing that will be held by a bipartisan House task force investigating the shooting. The House panel is also investigating a second assassination attempt on Trump earlier this month after Secret Service agents arrested a man with a rifle hiding on the golf course at Trump’s club in West Palm Beach, Fla.

In a statement Wednesday, Secret Service spokesman Anthony Guglielmi said the agency had already implemented some of the committee's suggestions and vowed to work transparently with Congress and other oversight bodies investigating the July 13 shooting. He said the agency had already raised Trump's security to the “highest level of protection that the U.S. Secret Service can provide.”

"We are also diligently examining long-term solutions to challenges such as enhancing communications and interoperability with our federal, state and local partners to make sure our coordinated efforts during protective events are seamless," he said.

Senate complains of stonewalling

Rep. Jason Crow, D-Colo., the top Democrat on the bipartisan House task force investigating the attempts on Trump’s life, told reporters last week that there were no signs of “stonewalling” from the many federal, state and local agencies involved in the investigation.

But the Senate committee painted a much different picture.

Advertise with us

The committee said “federal departments and agencies including [the Department of Justice] and [Department of Homeland Security] have failed to provide complete responses to the committee.”

The Secret Service has provided nearly 3,000 documents to the committee. But the agency and DHS “continue to provide heavily redacted or incomplete documents and productions in response to the committee’s bipartisan inquiry,” the report said.

The FBI has provided the committee 27 pages of documents, according to the report. The agency’s Pittsburgh field office has said publicly that it conducted almost 1,000 interviews, and the committee wants interview reports for all of them. The FBI on Sept. 20 told the committee it would begin making the records available on a rolling basis.

The committee is also still seeking to interview a Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives agent who was present at the Butler rally; thus far, the committee has received only an informal briefing from the bureau.

The lawmakers also laid out a handful of outstanding requests for documents and evidence. These include more specifics on personnel and the timeline for planning the Butler rally and communications including emails, texts and phone calls between agencies.

Advertise with us

They also want more information on Crooks, including his communications and online posts, handwritten notes, search histories, protocols on handling his body and the crime scene, his autopsy and toxicology reports, a time sequence and trajectory analysis of rounds fired on July 13, and security footage from the gun club where Crooks practiced.

The committee says it will continue to seek information on intelligence regarding threats to presidential candidates and other high-ranking officials, while also requesting more records and interviews with personnel involved in the Butler and West Palm Beach assassination attempts.

The Associated Press contributed to this report.