WASHINGTON — U.S. Rep. Mike Kelly, an eyewitness to the July 13 assassination attempt during Donald Trump’s rally in his hometown of Butler, is keenly aware not only of the ongoing back and forth between federal and local authorities over what went wrong, but also the conspiracy theories swirling around that fateful day at the farm show grounds.

“These things bring out the best in people and the worst in people,” he told the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette in an interview Thursday, as he and his team geared up to lead the House of Representatives’ task force digging into the shooting. “I think it’s time for people to back off, let us find out, let us get the answers the American people deserve.”

Hearings on Capitol Hill over the past two weeks have revealed harrowing details about the 20-year-shooter, Thomas Matthew Crooks of Bethel Park, and the security failures that allowed him to fire eight rounds from an AR-style rifle while perched on a rooftop within range of the former president and not far from local law enforcement teams. A trove of documents and videos, including one released on social media Thursday that showed local authorities scrambling to find the suspicious young man for almost two minutes as Trump addressed the crowd, suggest stunning planning and communication breakdowns that remain unexplained. 

Fiery congressional hearings and a flood of testimony and documents have raised more questions and suspicions among lawmakers who have grilled Secret Service, FBI and Pennsylvania State Police leaders. Why was Trump allowed to go to the podium? Who made the call to leave the building from which the sniper shot outside the main security perimeter and its rooftop unmanned? Did repeated warnings texted by local police reach the Secret Service and its counter-snipers before the gunman opened fire?

Advertise with us

By December, when the bipartisan group is set to release a report on its inquiry, it won’t be political and it won’t be a conspiracy theory, Mr. Kelly, a Republican, said. His goal is to stick to the facts, and he’s zeroing in on the security planning and related preparations for the rally, he said.

“It will be exactly — from the conception [of the Butler rally] to the very end of it — what happened,” he said. “We’re going to talk to as many people as we can, especially eyewitnesses that were there. … My main concern is, from this point forward, if we really have it together, this shouldn’t happen again.” 

A longtime resident

Mr. Kelly, who has lived in Butler since he was 10 years old, finds his town at the center of one of the gravest American security failures in decades.

The attack came during what the FBI describes as an elevated threat environment and rising concerns about political violence across the U.S. and worldwide. It also came in the middle of a tumultuous election year — with Pennsylvania seen as ground zero in Democrats’ and Republicans’ fight for the White House and Senate — rocked by near-constant campaign news at home and geopolitical turmoil abroad.

Crooks, described as a loner and gun hobbyist by the Secret Service and FBI, had amassed firearms and explosive materials for months. In the weeks leading up to the shooting, he searched online for information about President Joe Biden, Trump, the upcoming Democratic National Convention in Chicago and political assassinations, including a chilling Google search on his laptop for “How far away was Oswald from Kennedy?”

Advertise with us

Mr. Kelly said Butler holds a new place in history alongside Ford Theater in Washington, where former President Abraham Lincoln was shot and killed about a month before the end of the Civil War. He said the Butler community has been deeply affected by the shooting, which left Trump and two others injured and former firefighter Corey Comperatore dead.

The congressman said he’s determined to lead the task force in a manner that’s focused on answers to help prevent such security failures in the future, so that “the fact Butler is where it took place is not a stain on the history of Butler.” 

“I know that town intimately, I know that property intimately, and I know the people there pretty well after being there for over half a century,” he said. “You never would expect this to happen in that town and that venue.” 

Mr. Kelly said his office has received hundreds of calls and messages in recent days from residents and attendees wanting to discuss the shooting. 

Tapped for the task force

Tapped to chair the bipartisan task force last Tuesday by House Speaker Mike Johnson, R-La., and Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries, D-N.Y., Mr. Kelly’s mission is made more difficult by the House being out of session in August. He plans to hold a conference call with the 13-member group early this week, and lay the groundwork for gathering information, a likely site visit and holding public hearings in the months ahead. 

Advertise with us

The same day the task force was announced, acting Secret Service Director Ronald Rowe Jr. acknowledged security failures by his agency, which “failed to challenge assumptions,” but he also singled out local authorities, suggesting they failed to spot Crooks on the roof despite what he described as a clear vantage point from a nearby building where a team was stationed.

Local authorities say the post described by Mr. Rowe was not abandoned: One officer at one point temporarily left to try to find Crooks, but came back to the post after losing track of him.

State police leaders say troopers on scene passed messages and photos of Crooks from local authorities to a phone number believed to be a tactical asset with the Secret Service.

But Mr. Rowe testified that key information about Crooks was “stuck or siloed in that state or local channel,” and didn’t make it up the chain of command in time to prevent the shooting.

“It’s troubling to me we did not get that information as quickly as we should have,” he he told senators on the Judiciary and Homeland Security committees. He added that the Secret Service received “nothing about man on the roof, nothing about man with a gun” in time. “The only thing we had was locals were working an issue at the president’s 3 o’clock.”

Advertise with us

Beaver County District Attorney Nate Bible staunchly defended the actions of his SWAT team, insisting his team’s actions helped prevent the gunman from causing much greater harm.

“There’s been a lot of blame and maybe rightfully so, on the Secret Service for failing to act quicker. From my guy’s standpoint, had he not identified him as suspicious early on, at the time Crooks got those shots off, they knew he had been around the building,” Mr. Bible told the Post-Gazette. “That’s what allowed the Secret Service snipers to get those shots off so quickly. Who knows, Crooks could have potentially gotten off several magazines before they knew who he was.”

‘Who said what to whom?’

Mr. Kelly said he wants “to find out who said what to whom.” But he suggested that communications problems on July 13 are only a part of a greater planning failure.

“When we talk about this communications problem, why was there a communications problem?” he asked. “Did we realize there’s a communications problem once there’s a serious incident, or do we actually talk about it beforehand? The preparation for that event is the key. How prepared were we for that event? How ready were we for what was going on?

“I’ll tell you right now — it was the lack of preparation that I’m looking at, that I think was the biggest problem,” he continued. “The finger-pointing goes on and on, and it will continue to go on and on. But at the end of the day, any time you run any play, you better have a huddle and you better have a snap count.”

Advertise with us

He suggested it appears that on July 13, “we broke the huddle but nobody knew what the play call was.” 

The task force will find out “the whole game plan … and what wasn’t taken into account and why it wasn’t,” he said. 

The group will also seek details on how plans were communicated with the 150-plus law enforcement personnel on the ground that day, and how teams coordinated and responded.

While many witnesses have already come forward, Mr. Kelly said the task force has subpoena powers, so “even to people who say, ‘I’m not going to testify,’ we have the ability to say, ‘Hey, listen, we need you to be part of this. We need you to answer the questions we have to ask.’” 

“It’s a search for the truth,” he said.