WASHINGTON — The acting head of the U.S. Secret Service told senators Tuesday that the July 13 assassination attempt on former President Donald Trump in Butler marked a security “failure on multiple levels.” But he was especially critical of local law enforcement, questioning how local officers didn’t spot the gunman on a nearby roof and testifying that warnings suggesting a looming threat never reached his agency.
While Ronald Rowe Jr., appointed last week after the resignation of former agency chief Kimberly Cheatle, acknowledged that “this is a failure of the Secret Service,” he expressed frustration and bewilderment with local agencies and communication breakdowns that may have prevented authorities from stopping the gunman after he had raised local officers’ suspicions almost two hours before he opened fire. Trump and two others were injured and former firefighter Corey Comperatore died in the shooting.
Mr. Rowe showed senators the view from a window in a building adjacent to where 20-year-old Bethel Park gunman Thomas Matthew Crooks opened fire. He questioned how local officers he believed were stationed near that window did not spot the shooter.
“Why was the assailant not seen?” he said, raising his voice. “We were told that building was going to be covered.”
He said he “cannot defend why that roof was not secured.”
The testimony, before a joint hearing of the Senate’s Judiciary and Homeland Security & Governmental Affairs committees, marked a stark turnaround compared to last week’s appearance by Ms. Cheatle, who revealed few details just a day before she resigned. The testimony also raised more questions as local, state and federal agencies — who are all pledging to work together better to prevent such failures in the future — point fingers about various aspects of the planning, communication and actions taken or not taken the day of the rally.
Read More
The hearing comes just days after the Beaver County SWAT team told ABC news that they had no communication with the Secret Service and that a planned face-to-face briefing with the agency never occurred in the run-up to the event. Mr. Rowe countered Tuesday that Secret Service personnel briefed a tactical team leader who was “leading that element.”
Mr. Rowe also testified that key information on the gunman was “stuck or siloed in that state or local channel” and didn’t make it up the chain of command in time to stop the shooter or prevent Trump from taking the stage. He suggested that there was a nearly 30-second window where local law enforcement officers were aware of Crooks with a long gun on the roof, but said “that information stayed in state and local channels and did not make it over to Secret Service.”
"It's troubling to me we did not get that information as quickly as we should have,” he said. He added that Secret Service received "nothing about man on the roof, nothing about man with a gun" in time. “The only thing we had was locals were working an issue at the president's 3 o’clock.”
He said he believed local officials “were in the midst of dealing with a very critical situation” that was shared over the radio but not to Secret Service channels. The agency is working to figure out “interoperability” and ensuring Secret Service has access to state and local communication channels so such lapses don't happen again, Mr. Rowe said.
Pennsylvania State police Commissioner Col. Christopher Paris told House members last week that about a half-hour before the shooting, photos of Crooks were sent via a text to a phone number believed to be “some sort of tactical asset” in the Secret Service.
Mr. Rowe said he won’t wait for the slate of congressional and agency investigations to conclude before he assesses the event’s failures and takes steps to address them. He said he has implemented several measures including expanded use of drones to check unprotected roofs and other elevated threats, improving site communications particularly with state and local partners, and increased personnel in today’s heightened threat environment.
Pressed by senators on why the Secret Service gave control of the outer buildings within range of Trump to local law enforcement, Mr. Rowe appeared to ease off a bit on local law enforcement and acknowledged that the Secret Service failed “to challenge our assumptions.”
“We assumed the state and locals had it,” he said. “State and local law enforcement do their jobs every day in the communities you represent. We made an assumption that there was going to be uniform presence out there ... sufficient eyes to counter that, counter-sniper teams in the AGR building. I assure you: We’re not going to make that mistake again.”
But Mr. Rowe — pressed by Sen. Richard Blumenthal, D-Conn., whether the buck stops with the Secret Service — again said the local counter-sniper teams should have had a solid view of the shooter. “I’m not saying they should have neutralized him, but if they had just held their post,” he said.
Butler County District Attorney Richard Goldinger said last week that members of both the Beaver County and Butler County SWAT teams were stationed at one of the buildings in the American Glass Research complex adjacent to the farm show grounds.
The officers had spotted a suspicious person — now identified as Crooks — sitting outside the building, Mr. Goldinger said. They took a photo of him and forwarded it and a description of Crooks’ suspicious nature to state police and U.S. Secret Service agents.
When Crooks moved to a different side of the building, Mr. Goldinger said, both SWAT officers moved within the building “attempting to keep eyes on Crooks.”
One spotted him sitting on a picnic table. When Crooks ran off, that officer ran out of the building to try to keep track of him. The other officer, Mr. Goldinger said, stayed in the building. When the first officer couldn’t find Crooks, he returned to the building.
Mr. Rowe told senators that the Secret Service is reviewing the actions of dozens of agency personnel involved in the planning and on the day of the attack. More than 150 law enforcement personnel were on the grounds that day, including roughly 70 Secret Service agents, he said.
“If violations of protocols happened, those employees will be held accountable,” he said.
Sen. Josh Hawley, R-Mo., prodded Mr. Rowe for not firing anyone or placing agents on leave yet — including those who were in charge of planning the event and making key decisions such as keeping the building complex within range of Trump outside the main security perimeter.
It remains unclear, Mr. Rowe said, whether there were supposed to be counter-snipers on top of the roof closest to the assailant, or inside the building.
“The fact that they were in the building is something I’m trying to understand,” he said.
Benjamin Kail: bkail@post-gazette.com; @BenKail





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.