Surrounded by artwork that strangers have painted of her son, 95-year-old Malphine Fogel is a lesson in practiced stoicism.
She is upbeat but pleading when she talks about her son, Marc, who is nearing the third anniversary of his detention in a Russian prison, and she is polite but firm as she expresses her immense frustration with the president and his administration.
“The Biden administration has made it very clear that Marc has no value to America and, therefore, Russia is not motivated to release him,” she said Thursday at her home in Butler County. “Conversely, Brittney Griner received the wrongfully detained designation, signaling Russia that the U.S. valued her return.”
For more than an hour, Ms. Fogel held court from her couch with reporters and a team of documentarians, explaining her views on her son’s situation and what she says is a lack of support — or even any acknowledgement — from the same government that helped bring home Ms. Griner and has indicated it’s working to do the same for other detainees.
“As soon as Brittney Griner was arrested, [President Joe Biden] said, ‘We’re getting her out,’ and they did,” she said. “We don’t think they’ve made the effort to get Marc out and he, as we all know, is as important as anyone else on the planet.”
Mr. Fogel, now 62, was arrested at an airport north of Moscow in August 2021 as he returned for a 10th and final year of teaching at a school for diplomat’s children. Physician-prescribed medical marijuana — about 7 grams of it in his luggage — netted him drug charges and a 14-year sentence.
Read More
Hoping to compel Secretary of State Antony Blinken to designate her son as wrongfully detained, Ms. Fogel is suing Mr. Blinken and the Department of State in federal court, alleging he is shirking his responsibility to review and act on Mr. Fogel’s case.
The lawsuit, filed earlier this week, also alleges that Mr. Fogel and his family have received unequal treatment compared to other U.S. nationals detained by Russia, including Ms. Griner.
“I’m glad she’s home, but I want Marc home, too,” Ms. Fogel said.
Ms. Griner was arrested in February 2022 after she, too, was caught at the same airport with less than an ounce of medical marijuana. The U.S. government declared the WNBA star wrongfully detained a few months later and brought her home in a prisoner swap in December 2022. Mr. Fogel remains imprisoned and without the designation that his family is pleading for.
“As I understand it, until that happens, nothing else is going to proceed,” Ms. Fogel said.
When a U.S. national is deemed wrongfully detained under what’s called the Robert Levinson Hostage Recovery and Hostage-Taking Accountability Act, family members are offered legal resources, travel to and from Washington, D.C., and contact information for Department of State officials to answer questions.
There are more minor but meaningful examples of what can’t be done without the designation from the government. Mr. Fogel’s family sought to have him added to a Washington, D.C. mural that depicts Americans who are detained abroad. The artist would not add him, attorney Sasha Phillips said, because he has not been declared wrongfully detained.
Ms. Phillips, an attorney helping the Fogel family, said they put out a call for their own art, and more than 100 artists have since produced artwork for Mr. Fogel’s family.
Ms. Fogel said her son tries to call her each Saturday and Monday morning, and there is no detail too small to relay to him when it comes to Pittsburgh and Butler-area sports. She said he sounds as upbeat as he can but acknowledged that it’s likely that his phone calls are being monitored.
“He really has not complained very much, and the people there are nice, the inmates are nice,” she said. “Most of them are young men — I don’t know what they’re there for, I never asked — but he is making the best of the situation.”
She said her son walks a lot, as it’s one of the few physical activities he can do. He suffered severe back problems for decades before he was detained, and Ms. Phillips said that from what they’ve been able to glean, Mr. Fogel’s physician back home has been able to “piece [together] a pretty grim picture about Marc’s health and how he’s doing physically and mentally.”
Ms. Fogel’s stoicism falters only when she’s asked about how her son’s yearslong detention has affected her.
“You never get used to it,” she said, her voice cracking. “I’m calling every male ‘Marc.’ If my son-in-law is here, I call him Marc.”
Her daughter, Anne Fogel, spoke via video call.
“It’s sometimes hard for me to even begin, it’s all so incredibly overwhelming — the situation in general,” she said. “We’re on our knees. We are on our knees.”
Her mother added: “We have to depend on the State Department and our leaders to do something,” she said. “We can’t do anything more.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.