WASHINGTON — Since winning election to the U.S. Senate last fall, John Fetterman has planted himself among the most liberal members in the Democratic caucus.
He joined Sen. Elizabeth Warren, D-Mass., in opposing legislation suspending the debt ceiling because it was tied to new work requirements for food stamps and other spending cuts. He endorsed two candidates for Philadelphia City Council from the liberal Working Families Party, in defiance of the local party establishment. Years earlier, he backed Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., for president over Hillary Clinton.
But ever since Hamas — designated as a terrorist group by the U.S. — attacked Israel last month, Mr. Fetterman has found himself on the opposite side of many of his progressive allies.
In the weeks after the Oct. 7 attack against Israel, which left 1,400 dead and more than 200 held hostage, the freshman Democrat repeatedly has affirmed unwavering support for the Jewish state and bucked progressives’ calls for a ceasefire. He has stood firm even after Israeli retaliatory strikes in Gaza killed thousands of Palestinians, forced even more to leave their homes, and raised calls for a ceasefire to a fever pitch.
“Hamas does not want peace, they want to destroy Israel,” Mr. Fetterman tweeted last month. “We can talk about a ceasefire after Hamas is neutralized.”
While Mr. Fetterman has mirrored President Joe Biden in calling for humanitarian aid to civilians in Gaza, his unwavering support for Israel has sparked a backlash among progressives, prompting pro-Palestinian protests outside his offices in Pittsburgh and Philadelphia, and former campaign staffers to accuse him of breaking a pledge to champion “forgotten communities.” He found himself at odds with a fellow Western Pennsylvania Democrat, U.S. Rep. Summer Lee, D-Swissvale, who has been among the outspoken advocates of a ceasefire.
Read More
Activists and anti-Israel groups have expressed similar frustration with Mr. Biden, Ms. Warren, and other Democrats who strongly back Israel.
“I know [Mr. Fetterman] supported some aid packages [to Gaza], but it really means nothing if he is allowing Pittsburgh and Pennsylvania tax dollars to fund militancy against innocent civilians,” said Allie Levin, of the Pittsburgh chapter of Jewish Voice for Peace, a group that has been critical of Israel. “I’m deeply distressed by his concern for specific human beings versus others. It’s outing him as not being progressive.”
Waleed Shahid, a progressive strategist who has worked with the Working Families Party in Pennsylvania, told NBC News that he believed Mr. Fetterman’s views were not sincere.
“I think a majority of Democrats in Congress fear the electoral and political consequences if they were to offer even a little bit of criticism of the Israeli government,” he said, referring to pro-Israel groups like the American Israel Public Affairs Committee, which spent $4 million to unsuccessfully defeat Ms. Lee in 2022. Mr. Shahid has praised Ms. Lee for her calls for a ceasefire — a stance criticized last week by more than three-dozen Pittsburgh area rabbis and cantors.
Mr. Fetterman declined to comment. But people close to the senator, some speaking on condition of anonymity, joined Jewish clergy members and pro-Israel groups in saying that he simply is acting on views he expressed during his campaign.
Mr. Fetterman told Jewish Insider last year that if elected, he’d “lean in” to efforts to strengthen the relationship between Israel and the United States.
He told Payday Report, a labor outlet, on Wednesday that his focus is on “making sure that Israel is able to do what Israel deserves to do.”
“I grieve for the death of any innocent civilian, Palestinian or Israeli,” he said. “But right now, I’m more concerned with making sure the hostages are back home, and that we are able to neutralize and eliminate Hamas.”
And Mr. Fetterman tweeted last week that he was “profoundly moved” to meet with survivors of the Oct. 7 attack and hostages’ family members.
“Senator Fetterman gets it,” said Rabbi Daniel Fellman of Temple Sinai in Pittsburgh. Mr. Fellman said Mr. Fetterman “immediately got after Hamas. The problem isn’t the Palestinian people. The problem is Hamas. So as far as I’m concerned, he’s handling this thing correctly.”
Jill Zipin, who chairs Democratic Jewish Outreach Pennsylvania, a pro-Israel political action committee, said Mr. Fetterman doesn’t describe himself as a progressive, but rather a Democrat, and is aligned with the party’s mainstream when it comes to Israel.
“When he was running for office, he was always very good on the Israel issue,” she said. “Fetterman is someone who lives his values. He speaks from the heart. He's not fake, I believe his gut and his heart is telling him to support Israel. When sometimes people say they’re a Democrat, they don't feel it in their kishkes. Fetterman is someone who does. It comes from who he is.”
Marshall Wittmann, a spokesman for AIPAC, the powerful pro-Israel lobby, said the group appreciates Mr. Fetterman’s “strong stance in solidarity with Israel’s right to defend itself against Hamas terrorism.”
“He has been a consistent supporter of the U.S.-Israel alliance,” Mr. Wittmann said. “In taking this stand, the senator is aligned with President Biden in support of America’s ally — in stark contrast to the extremist fringe which seeks to undermine Israel’s security.”
Even pro-Israel Republicans have applauded Mr. Fetterman — long a lightning rod for GOP criticism — over his stance on Israel.
Scott Feigelstein, regional director of the Republican Jewish Coalition, urged other Democrats to listen to Mr. Fetterman.
“I wish his colleagues would wake up and take a similar stance,” he said. “What he’s saying is appreciated.”
But Ms. Levin, of Jewish Voice for Peace, cited an online survey by the progressive group Data for Progress that found two-thirds of Americans wanting a ceasefire. She said she’s “deeply appreciative of Summer Lee’s consistency — not just supporting the lives of innocent civilians but deeply supportive of Jews, and consistent and clear about her message to stand for humanity.”
A Quinnipiac University poll of registered voters released Thursday showed Mr. Fetterman’s views aligned with a majority of U.S. voters.
Half of the respondents said they approved of Israel’s response to the attacks, while just 35% disapproved. And by a margin of 51% to 41%, respondents supported sending more military aid to the Jewish state.
But Democrats disapproved of Israel’s response, 49% to 33%, and just a plurality, 49%, backed more U.S. aid, with 43% opposed.
Young voters — those under 35 — disapproved of Israel’s actions by 52% to 32%, and opposed sending more aid by 65% to 29%.
The poll of 1,610 self-identified registered voters was conducted Oct. 26-30, with a margin of error of plus or minus 2.4 percentage points.
Ms. Levin said young voters’ views and increased support for civilians can help shape long-term U.S. policy.
“Jewish safety and Palestinian freedom are not opposing causes,” she said. “We’ll be here fighting for all human lives until the violence stops. We all just want peace.”
Benjamin Kail: bkail@post-gazette.com, @BenKail; Jonathan D. Salant: jsalant@post-gazette.com, @JDSalant





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.