WASHINGTON — The last time Republicans tried to impeach a Democratic president, it didn’t go so well. The president’s party gained House seats in the next midterm election for the first time in 64 years, Bill Clinton’s approval ratings rose to the highest level of his presidency, and House Speaker Newt Gingrich left office under fire from his GOP colleagues.
Now a House GOP majority may try again — and even some Republicans wonder why, given that months of congressional investigations have yet to turn up any evidence that President Joe Biden profited from his son Hunter’s business dealings.
“There’s been no prior evidence that President Biden has done anything impeachable,” said former U.S. Rep. Jim Greenwood, a Republican who represented a suburban Philadelphia district and voted for two of the four impeachment counts against Mr. Clinton. “It looks like this is happening because a small handful of House Republicans are demanding it and have that much sway over the speaker. It’s retribution against the Democrats for impeaching Trump not once but twice.”
Speaker Kevin McCarthy, R-Calif., announced Tuesday that the House would begin an impeachment inquiry after being urged to do so by the far-right members of his conference and former President Donald Trump.
It was a 180-degree turn from Mr. McCarthy’s statement just days earlier that the full House would have to vote to begin an inquiry. Indeed, Mr. McCarthy criticized his predecessor, Nancy Pelosi, who launched an impeachment probe of Mr. Trump before the full House had a chance to weigh in. Eventually, the House approved an inquiry, as it had for Mr. Clinton and then-President Richard Nixon.
With Mr. Clinton, the report by independent counsel Kenneth Starr provided a roadmap to follow. Years later, there was Mr. Trump’s phone call to Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky, asking himto “do us a favor” by announcing an investigation of Mr. Biden and looking into debunked allegations that Ukraine, not Russia, intervened in the 2016 election. Then the Jan. 6, 2021, insurrection by Trump supporters aired live on television.
With Mr. Biden, there has been nothing so far except opposition to his policies, observers in both parties said.
“It’s obvious that the Republicans are not merely opposing Joe Biden but attempting to impeach him purely for political benefit,” said former Rep. Paul McHale, D-Pa., one of five Democrats who voted to impeach Mr. Clinton in 1998. “There is no evidence I have seen remotely close to justifying the impeachment of Joe Biden.”
“What is certainly not out there is some sort of connection to the president,” GOP consultant Mike DuHaime said. “If that's not proven, that's a wild goose chase.”
Rep. Frank Pallone Jr., who voted on the Clnton and Trump impeachments, said Mr. McCarthy acted because he wants to remain as speaker, not because there was any evidence of wrongdoing.
“He’s trying to figure out how he can get the extreme right wing to support him,” said Mr. Pallone, D-N.J. “He’s throwing them a bone. ... It’s now being treated as, ‘I’ve got to get somebody’s vote to keep me in office so I’m going to do this.’”
The top Democrat on the House Judiciary Committee, Jerrold Nadler of New York, said moving ahead without evidence makes impeachment just another political tool rather than a step to be taken only under the most extreme circumstances.
He noted that when GOP leaders are asked what evidence there is to justify taking this step, their response invariably is, “We’re going to come up with it.”
“I don’t think it's good for the country. It cheapens impeachment,” Mr. Nadler said. “There’s not a scintilla of evidence that the president had anything to do with any crime — not to mention a high crime and misdemeanor but any crime at all.”
Vince Galko, a longtime Republican strategist based in Northeastern Pennsylvania, called the inquiry a way to “excite the base, keep them engaged.”
“Sadly, I think the impeachment process now is becoming more of a political fundraising tool to censure a president,” Mr. Galko said.
Rep. Chris Smith, one of only 31 lawmakers still serving who voted on the three Clinton and Trump impeachment resolutions, said the latest inquiry is justified.
“That’s why you do an inquiry, to find out whether there’s sufficient evidence to take that next step,” said Mr. Smith, R-N.J. “You go where the evidence takes you and I think that’s all McCarthy has done here.”
Western Pennsylvania’s Republican lawmakers agree with him.
“The growing evidence does not lie — President Biden’s actions and conduct warrant an impeachment inquiry,” tweeted Rep. Guy Reschenthaler, R-Peters, the chief deputy majority whip.
Rep. Glenn Thompson, R-Centre, said “this process will provide answers for the American public."
And Rep. Mike Kelly, R-Butler, said that “investigations led by the House Committees on Ways & Means, Judiciary, and Oversight have produced important information, but questions still remain.”
But Mr. McHale said Republicans have it backwards. An impeachment inquiry should come only after the evidence points to high crimes and misdemeanors, not as a way to look for such evidence.
“You don’t begin with the accusation and then investigate to find proof,” Mr. McHale said. “The proof should precede the accusation. ... Not only is it degrading to the Constitution, it challenges the fundamental fairness of our government where an investigation is now going forward because there are those who are politically hopeful they will find the evidence.”
Mr. McHale said that while a vote of no confidence is sufficient to remove a leader in a parliamentary democracy, the U.S. system of government is different.
“It is important to return to the constitutional language that the individual charged with impeachment must be guilty of high crimes and misdemeanors,” Mr. McHale said. “We lower the constitutional bar by calculating impeachment on the basis of the next election that transformed this standard of proof from high crimes and misdemeanors to a simple political calculation.”
Both parties have contributed to that trend. Some House Democrats clamored to impeach Mr. Trump right as he took office, and more after special counsel Robert Mueller documented numerous links between the Russian government and the Trump campaign, while also saying there was no collusion.
Ms. Pelosi, D-Calif., regularly rebuffed those calls — until seven freshmen Democrats, all with military or national security backgrounds, endorsed impeachment following that phone call to Mr. Zelensky seeking a political favor as Mr. Trump held up congressionally approved aid to Ukraine.
That led Ms. Pelosi to change her position and begin an impeachment inquiry.
“I remember how important it was to me that if we were going to take such a serious step as impeachment that we had the evidence, that the crimes really were at the level that they were high crimes,” said one of the seven, Rep. Mikie Sherrill, D-N.J., a former Navy pilot and federal prosecutor.
J.J. Balaban, a Democratic strategist and ad maker from Philadelphia, called the inquiry an attempt to ethically equate Mr. Biden and his son with the twice-impeached and four-times-indicted Mr. Trump and his family.
Companies linked to Mr. Trump’s daughter Ivanka received more than 40 trademarks from the Chinese government when she served as a White House adviser. And a private equity firm formed by Jared Kushner –- Ivanka’s husband. Mr. Trump’s son-in-law, and another top White House adviser — received $2 billion from a fund led by Saudi Arabia’s ruler, Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman, after he left the federal government.
By contrast, Hunter Biden has never worked in his father’s administration.
“It’s pretty clear what they’re trying to do in the wake of the unprecedented number of Trump indictments is to draw some sort of moral equivalency, to say, ‘See, both candidates for president have legal issues,’” Mr. Balaban said.
Since Hunter Biden is an adult, the sins of the son can’t be visited on the father if the son acted on his own, Mr. Pallone said.
“Because my son did something, you’re responsible? That’s absurd,” Mr. Pallone said.
Even though the GOP allegations against Mr. Biden remain unproven, they have resonated with Americans. In a recent CNN poll, 60% said Mr. Biden took illegal or unethical actions while being involved in his son’s business dealings.
Some Republicans insist they eventually will find something.
“I believe the evidence is going to show a significant connection between Hunter Biden’s activities and his father’s position,” said Charlie Gerow, a Republican strategist and former congressional and gubernatorial candidate.
So far, that golden Republican ticket remains elusive.
“What is certainly not out there is some sort of connection to the president,” Mr. DuHaime said. “You have to hope the folks in charge know something that the rest of us don't.”
It remains to be seen what impact the impeachment inquiry will have on the 2024 presidential race.
“I don't think we know at this point which way it will go,” said Ashley Koning, a pollster and professor at Rutgers University in New Jersey.“We know it is distracting from the bigger issues like a government shutdown while giving more emphasis to the 2024 horse race. It plays into this hyperpartisan and super-politically charged atmosphere that we’ve had throughout the Trump era. The wind can blow any which way in today’s political environment.”
Strategists in both parties agree the inquiry will deflect attention from issues voters care about.
“Hopefully the House Republican conference can walk and chew gum at the same time,” said Christopher Nicholas, a longtime Harrisburg-based Republican consultant. “There’s obviously been some documented wrongdoing by Hunter Biden, but whether that connects to illegality by the president remains to be seen. What I hope happens is that we continue fact finding and get to the bottom of things, and hold the line on spending, getting the budget done and fixing immigration. Hopefully it won't be a distraction.”
Mr. Balaban said Republicans should have learned from their disappointing showing in 2022, when their gains in Congress were much less than projected.
“It’s not addressing what swing voters are pretty clear they want,” Mr. Balaban said. “This inquiry won’t make gasoline one cent lower.” Referring to last year’s far-right, losing GOP gubernatorial nominee, he added: “It’s taken straight out of the playbook of a Doug Mastriano, and that doesn’t seem to be a recipe for victory in Pennsylvania.”
There are Republicans who say this latest impeachment effort is a rerun of 1998. And if Democrats pick up just five House seats in 2024 — the same number they won in 1998 — they’d regain their majority.
In addition, many voters will empathize with Mr. Biden standing by his son, who lost his mother and brother, even in the face of any wrongdoing on Hunter Biden’s part, Mr. DuHaime said.
“There are two dangers for the Republicans: One, they don't prove anything they are alleging and, two, people sympathizing with someone who stands by a family member, even if that family member is a screw up,” Mr. DuHaime said.
And Mr. Greenwood, the former suburban Philadelphia Republican congressman, said an evidence-free impeachment effort could drive undecided voters into Mr. Biden’s camp.
“Look at the race right now: It’s neck and neck,” Mr. Greenwood said. ”Obviously, there are some who think this will drive Biden’s numbers down, but among the undecided voters, the swing voters, this is going to look like more politics, particularly the absence of any evidence. This is going to look like a pure political play without merit. I don’t think that does the Republican Party any good at all.”
Jonathan D. Salant: jsalant@post-gazette.com, @JDSalant; Benjamin Kail: bkail@post-gazette.com, @BenKail





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.